Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) gave an elaborate visual presentation during the Senate ANWR debate, showing awe-inspiring pictures of wild game. We recount in full: “This picture on the plain shows the caribou and beautiful mountains with the water in front…. This unbelievable photograph shows a polar bear reflected in the water. Cast your eyes on this…. The muskoxen is seen running through this area. The next photograph shows the porcupine caribou swimming. These are pretty extraordinary photographs. This gives Members an idea of what we are trying to save and why we ask colleagues from both sides of the aisle to please support us in striking this instruction from the budget.”

 

FACT: Sen. Boxer is implying that oil and gas drilling in Alaska’s North Slope has hurt wildlife. She’s wrong. We’ll let the National Research Council’s study, titled "Cumulative Environmental Effects of Oil and Gas Activities on Alaska’s North Slope," speak for itself:

Caribou: "For the past 50 or 60 years, all four [caribou] herds have been exposed to oil and gas exploration activity, but only the [Central Artic Herd] has been in regular and direct contact with surface development related to oil production and transport….The [Central Artic Herd] has increased from around 5,000 animals in the late 1970s to its current (2000) size of 27,000."

Polar Bear: "Industrial activity in marine waters of the Beaufort Sea has been limited and sporadic and likely has not caused serious cumulative effects on ringed seals or polar bears."

Muskoxen: "No effects of seismic exploration on muskoxen have been detected to date."

Porcupine Caribou: "To date, oil and gas activities have had little influence on the Porcupine Herd…"