With the upcoming movie on global warming, The Day after Tomorrow, there will be plenty of opportunities to respond to the charges of politically anxious liberal environmentalists hyping the fears of global warming and for us to set the record straight. For years these extremists have exaggerated claims to garner attention to their cause. With the releases of the movie this month, we should be prepared for a heavy onslaught of these same tactics.

 

For example, take the question of the relationship between malaria and global warming. Posted on the Grist website is an article discussing the benefits and faults of the movie. The article emphasizes much of the movie is factices, but claims increasing danger of outbreak of malaria is one of the realities of global warming. The article states:

 

“When, in fact, the more likely horror stories happen a little more slowly — and a little farther away from the Hollywood hills and the Manhattan canyons. For instance: The World Health Organization estimates that the spread of mosquitoes in a warmer, wetter world will cause malaria and dengue fever to explode. The deaths won’t come all at the same time, and they won’t involve people who look like Dennis Quaid, but they’ll be plenty real.”

 

Or an article entitled “Apocalypse soon” in the Guardian, which links the catastrophe of September 11 with global warming:

 

“This is no rhetorical exaggeration. About 2,900 died in the Twin Towers on September 11 2001, and just over 200 died in Madrid. But the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine has estimated that 160,000 people are dying each year from the consequences of climate change – malaria, dysentery and malnutrition. And even that excludes some of the most extreme storm disasters plausibly linked to climate change, notably the tropical cyclone in Bangladesh in 1991, which killed 138,000, as well as Hurricanes Mitch and Andrew in the Caribbean, both hyper-intense category-five typhoons.”

 

 

FACT: The scientific claims made in these articles are nothing more than a politically charged campaign of disinformation. The articles are based on scientific reports made by scientists well outside the field of infectious diseases. Those scientists who do specialize in infectious diseases dismiss such conclusions. One such specialist is Dr. Peter Reiter.

 

Who is Paul Reiter? Paul Reiter is Professor at the Institute Pasteur in Paris, where he is in charge of setting up a new Insects and Infectious Disease unit. A British-born scientist, Professor Reiter spent 22 years in the Division of Vector-borne Infectious Diseases at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control. He has conducted field research for numerous national and international organizations, including the World Health Organization, in twelve South American, African, North American, and Asian countries and is considered one of the world’s leading authorities on the transmission of mosquito-borne diseases such as dengue fever.

 

Specifically, Reiter questions the research by one of the most referred to documents by environmental extremists, the Second Assessment Report on the Impacts of Global Change published by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change (IPCC). Reiter was disappointed to discover “Neither the nine lead authors nor the sources they cited were specialists in the field.” But Reiter clearly understands the importance of the findings stating, “Nevertheless, their authoritative pronouncements gave authenticity to a new crop of erroneous articles, many with inventive explanations of new situations.”

 

Reiter is clearly frustrated and would like for nothing more to get the science right and solve the real problems of infectious diseases when he says “The sad fact is that there is little we scientists can do to challenge this campaign of disinformation. None of us denies that temperature is a factor in the transmission of mosquito-borne diseases, and that transmission may be affected if the world’s climate continues to warm. But it is immoral for the political activists to mislead the public by attributing the recent resurgence of these diseases to climate change, particularly in Africa. The true reasons are far more complex, and the principal determinants are politics, economics, and human activities. A creative and organized application of resources to change the situation is urgently needed, regardless of future climate.”

 

Reiter is right, let’s get the science straight and get to work.