MYTH: The Feingold-McCain independent peer review amendment will delay project construction. ALLEGED FACT: The amendment includes strict deadlines for the panel to report – if they fail to report in the allotted time, the Chief of Engineers is directed to proceed with planning.
REALITY: Any mistakes found by the end of the process review envisioned in the Feingold-McCain amendment would necessitate a repeat of the study process to correct the problem. Clearly this would delay project construction. Under the Inhofe-Bond proposal, since reviews are integrated into the process, any mistakes made or improvements suggested would be corrected or incorporated more efficiently.
MYTH: The Feingold-McCain amendment will require reviews of too many projects. ALLEGED FACT: The $40 million review trigger will on average subject about 5 projects a year to independent review.
REALITY: The $40 million trigger is only one of four triggers. Plus, due to constrained budgets, the Corps doesn’t undertake many new studies each year, so 5 per year is a large percentage. Another trigger would allow the Governor of a state anywhere within the drainage basin of a proposed Corps project to claim an environmental or economic impact and require a review. It is interesting to note that 31 Governors reside in the Mississippi River drainage basin.
MYTH: The Feingold-McCain amendment gives a handful of experts the right to dictate Corps projects, taking policy decisions away from the Corps. ALLEGED FACT: Project recommendations remain in the hands of the Chief of Engineers, and Congress retains the ultimate decision regarding whether to authorize a project.
REALITY: The intent of the Feingold-McCain amendment is made clear by the fact that the opinions of these panels would be given the same weight as those of the Chief of Engineers in legal proceedings. What other Federal agency has been stripped of the benefit of judicial deference?
MYTH: The Feingold-McCain amendment will increase project costs. ALLEGED FACT: Costs associated with independent review are capped and taxpayer watchdog groups strongly support the amendment.
REALITY: In the same way an end of the process review leads to delays to project construction, it will lead to increases in project study costs. Obviously, it will cost more for both the Federal government and the non-Federal sponsor (50-50 cost share) if a study must be done twice because a mistake wasn’t found until the end of the process. True, the costs of the peer review itself are capped, but it is the project costs that will be greatly increased. So-called “taxpayer watchdog groups” have a long history of opposing Army Corps projects, so it is no surprise they would support an amendment that would result in delaying or stopping as many Corps projects as possible.
MYTH: The Feingold-McCain independent peer review will apply to already authorized projects. ALLEGED FACT: The independent peer review applies to projects as they enter the feasibility stage, not after authorization, at which point the Chief’s report is already complete. If necessary, certain already authorized critical flood control projects will get the benefits of a safety assurance review which will analyze engineering and technical aspects that are not fully defined in the feasibility study.
REALITY: The Feingold-McCain amendment encourages repeated, lengthy reviews of the same information. A model used in 10 separate projects, for example, should not undergo peer review 10 times; it should be peer reviewed once to ensure quality and accuracy, but after that only the application of the model to a specific project study should be subject to further peer review.
MYTH: The Feingold-McCain amendment will create a whole new layer of bureaucracy. ALLEGED FACT: The amendment does not create a bureaucracy; it establishes a workable system to address a very real problem – poorly planned and designed project that put people at risk, unnecessarily damage the environment and waste taxpayer dollars.
REALITY: A statutorily required Director of Peer Review is unnecessary micromanaging of the Corps, as is the specification of the size of the peer review panels. The responsibility of establishing panels is more efficiently performed by the Chief and the Corps’ Centers of Expertise as is called for in current Corps peer review policy pursuant to the Information Quality Act.
MYTH: The Inhofe-Bond amendment would create a system of true independent project review. ALLEGED FACT: Their amendment makes the Chief of Engineers the final arbiter of whether an independent review will happen at all. The Corps gets to select the reviewers, and there are no criteria at all for ensuring independence of those reviewers. Review is not independent if the Corps has control over whether, how, and who will review projects.
REALITY: The Inhofe-Bond amendment is clear that an independent peer review must be performed if the project is estimated to cost $100 million or if the Secretary of the Army determines the project is controversial. The Chief is given no discretion on this matter. The Chief certainly is bound by specific criteria for ensuring independence of reviewers. The Office of Management and Budget Bulletin of December 2004, applicable to all Federal agencies, discusses at length these criteria, and the Inhofe-Bond amendment requires Corps guidelines to comply with this Bulletin. The Corps has no more flexibility in managing peer reviews than any other Federal agency under OMB’s Bulletin.