One clean air canard reiterated tirelessly and with great conviction–but without much supporting evidence–is that the current Clean Air Act, if left untouched, would far outpace the public health and environmental benefits achieved by Clear Skies. Conrad Schneider, advocacy director of the Clean Air Task Force, was adamant on this point during yesterday’s Clear Skies hearing. “In short,” Schneider asserted, “CSA trades nearly all the protections of the current Clean Air Act and its promise of continuous progress in cleaning the air for a set of half-measures that will not achieve the Act’s air quality objectives.” John Paul, supervisor of the Regional Air Pollution Control Agency, opined that “given the serious deficiencies” of Clear Skies, “we believe that continued implementation of the Clean Air Act will provide far greater, and more certain and timelier protection of public health and the environment.” How? Both Paul and Schneider asserted that, among other tools, New Source Review and continued Section 126 enforcement would be far superior to Clear Skies.
FACT: New Source Review and the Section 126 process cannot match the singular advantages of Clear Skies legislation: specific reduction targets and timetables that will mandate a 70 percent reduction of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and mercury by 2018. Clear Skies is based on the market-based, virtually litigation-free Acid Rain program, which has cut emissions further, faster, and cheaper than command-and-control alternatives. Can NSR and Section 126 ensure the same? Let’s look: In 1997, eight northeastern states petitioned EPA to force midwestern states to reduce NOx emissions. After four federal court decisions and EPA retooling, these 126 petitions culminated in the NOx SIP call, which went into effect not in May 1998 but in May 2004, seven years after the process began (is this the “more certain and timelier protection” of which Mr. Paul spoke?). Similarly, in 1999 the Clinton Administration initiated several NSR enforcement actions, many of which were challenged, several of which are still being litigated, nearly six years later. Moreover, if the legal standard reached in the Duke Power NSR case prevails-and we won’t know for some time-NSR can’t be applied nearly as often and to the degree Paul and Schneider would presumably prefer. And just yesterday, a federal court heard oral arguments on the Bush Administration’s first round of NSR reforms, promulgated two years ago (oral arguments on its 2003 routine maintenance reforms won’t happen until at least 2006). Such lawyer-rich history probably explains why Mr. Schneider stated that the existing Clear Air Act “could potentially require” future emission reductions beyond Clear Skies.