Posted by Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In the News…
Politico Pro
New tests: No abnormal radiation in Pennsylvania wells
By Bob King | 3/7/11 6:15 PM EST
Water samples from seven Pennsylvania rivers have found no signs of abnormal radiation, state regulators said Monday, a week after The New York Times warned that natural-gas drilling could be putting radiation-laced waste into public drinking water supplies.
The tests were conducted in November and December at sites downstream of wastewater treatment plants that accept waste from gas drilling and fracking operations in the Marcellus Shale, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection reported.
While the tests were conducted months before the stories appeared last week in the Times, Travis Windle, a natural-gas industry spokesman, said the results should allay some of the concerns the newspaper raised.
"This solid cross section of analysis proved exactly what The New York Times doesn’t want us to prove: These levels of radiation are extremely low and within permitted limits," Windle said. He added that the newspaper "could have waited for these test results."
Among other findings, the Times reported that wastewater from the gas operations "is sometimes hauled to sewage plants not designed to treat it and then discharged into rivers that supply drinking water." It added that the waste "contains radioactivity at levels higher than previously known, and far higher than the level that federal regulators say is safe for these treatment plants to handle."
The Times attributed the information to documents from state regulators, the federal EPA and the drilling companies themselves. But it also reported that lax monitoring requirements leave it unclear exactly how much radiation might be winding up in drinking water.
In its statement Monday, the Pennsylvania DEP said all the samples tested in November and December turned up radioactivity at or below naturally occurring background levels.
The samples also turned up levels below the federal drinking water standard for radium 226 and 228, according to the DEP statement. It said the sampling stations "were installed last fall specifically to monitor stream quality for potential impacts of Marcellus development."
The brief DEP statement did not say how many samples were tested.
The rivers tested were the Monongahela at Charleroi in Washington County; South Fork Ten Mile Creek in Greene County; Conemaugh in Indiana County; Allegheny at Kennerdell in Venango County; Beaver in Beaver County; Tioga in Tioga County; and the West Branch of the Susquehanna in Lycoming County, the department said.
The test results appeared to fall well short of a recent suggestion from ex-Gov. Ed Rendell and former DEP Secretary John Hanger, who said in a letter to the Times on Sunday that "Pennsylvania should order all its public water systems to immediately test for radioactive pollutants. Only testing of our drinking water can resolve this question and give citizens peace of mind."
Rendell and Hanger made that recommendation despite having harsh words for the Times stories, which they said ignored the state’s record of inspecting natural gas operations, fining violators and even ordering one company to halt operations temporarily.
"If the goal of your report about natural gas drilling was to gratuitously frighten Pennsylvanians, then congratulations on a job well done," Rendell and Hanger wrote to the newspaper. They added: "Pennsylvania has the strongest enforcement program of any state with gas drilling. Period."