Posted by: Matt Dempsey (202) 224-9797 Matt_Dempsey@inhofe.senate.gov  

EPW POLICY BEAT: THE HOBSON’S CHOICE

From the Inhofe-EPW Press Office 

 

As EPW PolicyBeat continues its walk-through of the Waxman-Markey discussion draft, we found reason to applaud the authors for recognizing, and proposing to rectify, the glorious mess of regulating greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act.  Sections 831, 832, 833, and 834 of Waxman-Markey succinctly preempt regulation under Title I and Title V of the Act, meaning no new source review, no national ambient air quality standards, no MACT standards, and no costly permit requirements for greenhouse gases. 

 

This is undoubtedly a welcome development, but in our view these provisions should stand alone.  Instead they are wrapped into flawed legislation that resembles, in important respects, the anti-consumer, job-destroying Lieberman-Warner bill, which the Senate handily rejected last summer.  Therefore the Waxman-Markey draft presents a classic Hobson’s choice by offering no real alternative: it replaces a very bad option—regulating carbon under the Clean Air Act—with another very bad option—a cap-and-trade bill wrapped in a sea of mandates that will burden every consumer in America with higher energy prices.  We respectfully suggest simply taking Clean Air Act regulation off the table.  Period. 

 

Here are the relevant sections from Waxman-Markey:

 

 “SEC. 831. CRITERIA POLLUTANTS.

“No greenhouse gas may be listed under section 108(a) on the basis of its effect on climate change.

 

“SEC. 832. HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS.

“No greenhouse gas may be added to the list of hazardous air pollutants under section 112 unless such greenhouse gas meets the listing criteria of section 112(b) independent of its effects on climate change.

 

“SEC. 833. NEW SOURCE REVIEW.

“The provisions of part C of title I shall not apply to a greenhouse gas solely on the basis of its effect on climate change or regulation under title VII or this title.

 

“SEC. 834. TITLE V PERMITS.

“Notwithstanding any provision of title III or V, in determining whether a stationary source is required to apply for, or operate pursuant to, a permit under title V, the Administrator shall not consider the source’s greenhouse gas emissions.”

 

# # #