Posted by Katie Brown Katie_Brown@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It… 

Politico Pro 

Senate NRC hearing could produce fireworks

By Darius Dixon

August 2, 2011

Link to Article

Divisions within the NRC are expected to be on full display Tuesday when all five commissioners sit before senators to discuss the agency’s new set of post-Fukushima safety regulations – and the fact that the majority of members oppose pushing them through the agency in 90 days.

The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing could be a forum for Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) to poll each commissioner on their support for NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko’s 90-day push and ask tough questions about why three of them prefer a longer review process.

At the same time, the hearing provides Republicans already critical of the Jaczko with the chance to prod at why he chose 90 days for the review and why he would make a speech before the National Press Club to push the issue if he didn’t have the support of a majority of his colleagues.

"Given the lack of apparent comity that exists now between him and the other commissioners, it might’ve made sense to poll them to know where they’re going before you go out a stake a position in the ground about what the commission should be doing," said Chris Guith, vice president for policy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s Institute for 21st Century Energy.

"If the rest of the commission ends up undercutting him, which appears to be the case now, it demonstrates that his credibility to the public and to the press is less than stellar," he said. "And it’s further evidence of the lack of comity that has traditionally existed at the commission."

Last month, Jaczko said that he wanted the commission to review and decide on any new regulations resulting from the Fukushima task force report within 90 days, followed by implementation of the approved changes fleetwide by 2016.

But in the two weeks following Jaczko’s public push, a majority of NRC commissioners shot down his proposal.

Three members the commission, William Ostendorff, Kristine Svinicki and William Magwood, agreed to review the findings of the special agency task force created in the wake of the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear crisis in Japan voting to support the review of the recommendations – just not as fast as the chairman wants. All three commended the task force for their work but said it lacked technical expertise because the group only consisted of six members.

The task force report says U.S. reactors and licensing activities are not an imminent risk to public health and the environment. But it wants the country’s nuclear plants to reevaluate their vulnerabilities to earthquakes and floods and develop additional safeguards for spent fuel pools, venting systems and extended blackouts.

Upon the release of the task force report a few weeks ago, EPW ranking member Jim Inhofe believed findings blindsided Congress and the nuclear industry.

"In the wake of the Fukushima accident NRC Chairman Greg Jaczko has assured us repeatedly that our nuclear reactors are safe," the Oklahoma Republican said in a statement. "So why has the NRC suddenly recommended sweeping regulatory changes in this report apparently without an adequate technical or regulatory basis to justify these modifications?"

"The recommendations of the report go well beyond Fukushima," said Inhofe spokesman Matt Dempsey. "If you limit it and you keep it down to just a handful of people, you’re bound to have issues pop up later in the process.

"Like the rest of the commission has already suggested, let’s open this up, take our time and let’s get this right," he said.

Some Republicans have argued that Jaczko’s 90-day push was mainly a political move.

The hearing also offers an opportunity for members of the NRC to air their own grievances. After commissioners testified before the House Energy and Commerce Committee this spring on the agency’s role in the shutdown of the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository project, exposing deep divisions over the issue, Guith said, anything goes.

"I think you’ll see more commissioners trying to distance themselves from the chairman," Guith said. "This is just another opportunity to do that."

NRC spokesman Eliot Brenner said that divisions within the commission are not uncommon and that Jaczko’s effort to have new recommendations reviewed in 90-days was proposal, not edict from the chairman.

"The commission is a group of people who if they were all of like mind, you’d only need an administrator, not a commission," he said. "Every member is free to make up their own mind and he was expressing his opinion."

Regarding how Jaczko decided on 90 days, Brenner said, "The chairman views it as a substantive step toward safety."

###