The Truth Behind “Environmentalists’” Opposition to Judge Alito “Environmental” Special Interests: Shills for a Broader Liberal Agenda Unable to provide any specifics in its latest e-mail blitz, Earthjustice has gone on the record opposing Judge Samuel Alito’s nomination to the Supreme Court: This is it: hearings on Judge Samuel Alito Jr.’s nomination to a lifetime seat on the Supreme Court are taking place all this week. Though Earthjustice has not opposed a Supreme Court nominee in almost two decades, this time we have no choice: Judge Alito has a record of extreme decisions that threaten to invalidate laws protecting the environment and enabling citizens to enforce those laws in court. We cannot afford to have someone with Judge Alito’s record deciding which rights will be protected, and which will be thrown out. America’s highest court, and our nation’s landmark environmental protections, deserve better. Fact: Americans deserve better than such deceptive rhetoric. Organizations such as Earthjustice and the Sierra Club are merely components of a liberal coalition that nearly always, in an effort to exploit environmental issues to pursue a broader liberal agenda, oppose Republican judicial nominees. Earthjustice and the Sierra Club are members of the so-called Alliance for Justice, whose president, Nan Aron, pledged to do “whatever it takes” to keep conservatives off the Court. When asked what she would do to stop the Alito nomination, she replied, “You name it. We’ll do it.” The “first time in almost two decades” claim is meaningless when one considers that Democrat Bill Clinton was president for the majority of that time. Recall that “environmental” special interests actively opposed Clarence Thomas’ nomination in 1991. Judge Alito’s Solid Track Record in Protecting the Environment and Upholding the Law: Ø In FMC Corp. v. Dept. of Commerce, 29 F.3d 833 (3d Cir. 1994), Judge Alito joined a 9-3 decision that ordered the Federal government to spend millions of dollars to clean up toxic waste from a World War II industrial facility that polluted ground water. Ø In Southwestern Pennsylvania Growth Alliance v. Browner, 121 F.3d 106 (3d Cir. 1997), Judge Alito wrote the court’s opinion upholding the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) designation of the Pittsburgh-Beaver Valley region as violating national ozone standards after it exceeded those limits. Judge Alito wrote, “Although we are sympathetic to the view expressed by many within the Area that this rule threatens serious economic harm, we recognize that our role as a reviewing court is strictly limited.” Ø In ALM Corp. v. Environmental Protection Agency, 974 F.2d 380 (3d Cir. 1992), Judge Alito voted to uphold the EPA’s assessment of fines against a company for violating reporting requirements of the Toxic Substances Control Act.