Fact of the Day: Friday, October 14, 2005 Green Bigotry and Natural Gas This week, the Energy Information Administration (EIA) provided Americans with a hard dose of reality. According to EIA, “households heating primarily with natural gas are expected to spend about $350 (48 percent) more this winter in fuel expenditures. Households heating primarily with heating oil can expect to pay, on average, $378 (32 percent) more this winter. Households heating primarily with propane can expect to pay, on average, $325 (30 percent) more this winter. Households heating primarily with electricity can expect, on average, to pay $38 (5 percent) more. Should colder weather prevail, expenditures will be significantly higher.” EIA also points out that “NOAA projects a 0.4-percent colder winter in the lower-48 States, in terms of heating degree-days, relative to normal winter weather, which would be 3.2 percent colder than last winter.” Fact: Households already suffering from rising energy prices now face even higher prices after the devastation of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Americans deserve to have the answers for these higher costs – and solutions. Well before the hurricanes devastated the Gulf Coast region, Senator Inhofe and the Environment & Public Works Committee, concerned about the rising costs of natural gas, conducted a hearing to examine the environmental impacts of U.S. natural gas production. At the time of the hearing, Senator Inhofe stated: Tactics employed to stop exploration and production of new natural gas sources under the pretense of “environmental protection” are costing this country dearly and will only get worse if we don’t act. There are those who are simply opposed to drilling anywhere, anytime and will go to all lengths to prevent it from occurring. But we can explore and produce while protecting the environment. Following the hearing, the EPW Committee addressed several factors – both natural and artificial – that contribute to higher prices in a white paper, Energy And The Environment: The Future Of Natural Gas In America. The paper found several artificial reasons for higher natural gas prices including: Ø “Changes to the Clean Air Act and other air-related regulations are the single greatest reason for the increased demand in natural gas use. Yet, other federal environmental policies have effectively prevented a sufficient and corresponding increase in supply of natural gas. These conflicting federal policies have created an artificial barrier for the market to adjust itself.” Ø “Natural gas prices have increased as demand, mostly in the electricity generation sector, has increased. The U.S. historically relied on coal as the principal fuel for electricity generation. The national economy grew significantly and with that growth U.S. businesses and homes demanded more energy. However, federal air quality regulations along with other environmental regulations promoted the use of natural gas as a cleaner generating fuel than coal and less controversial than nuclear. For example, implementation of EPA regulations such as the New Source Review, among others, has driven the electricity generation industry away from coal and toward natural gas to meet customers’ needs.” Ø “Further, special interest groups, that only a few years prior, praised natural gas as the bridge fuel to a clean environment, today oppose increasing supplies. Interest groups have largely chosen their sides between the political parties and refuse to work within reasonable bounds. Instead, they seem to happily if not blindly balance on the edge of a partisan cliff while U.S. competitiveness tumbles down it.” The consequences of low supply and high energy prices resulting from government policies and selfish special interest influence certainly impact some more than others. Syndicated columnist Thomas Sowell wrote in the Tulsa World September 26, 2004 that “[a]mong the many luxuries that wealth can buy is insulation from reality — the most dangerous luxury of all. Another dangerous luxury is a sense of being one of the wonderfully special people with superior wisdom and virtue. Environmental extremism flourishes among those who can afford both luxuries.” Sowell refers to such people as green bigots: “Denying other people the same rights that you claim for yourself is the essence of bigotry. People who call themselves environmentalists could more accurately be called green bigots. Selfishness is never a pretty thing but it is at its ugliest when it masquerades as some kind of lofty nobility.”