Thursday, December 15, 2005
Emissions Caps Unpalatable to Northeastern States Governors Cite Carbon Cap Costs That Would Be Passed Along to American Consumers Several days after the close of the Montreal climate change conference, where Kyoto Protocol nations failed to reach an agreement on the next series of mandatory greenhouse gas caps beyond 2012, global warming alarmists suffered yet another defeat with the apparent unraveling of the northeast Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) amidst fears that increased energy costs associated with caps would be passed along to American consumers. “Talks broke down Wednesday among state officials trying to reach an agreement to reduce carbon dioxide emissions in the Northeast,” the AP writes (“Northeast Emissions Talks Break Down”). “A spokesman for Rhode Island Gov. Don Carcieri said Rhode Island, Massachusetts and Connecticut had misgivings over the proposed nine-state plan to cut so-called greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming. Carcieri is concerned about the costs, according to spokesman Jeff Neal. ‘Ultimately we don’t know how much this plan will raise energy prices,’ Neal said. A spokeswoman for Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney said he would likely comment on the matter on Thursday. Romney has expressed concerns with the initiative in the past, saying the costs of cutting emissions would be passed on to consumers.” According to the AP, “[e]nvironmental groups were disappointed that the states couldn’t reach an agreement. ‘It’s very disappointing, but we’re hopeful it will proceed,’ said Seth Kaplan, senior attorney for the Conservation Law Foundation in Boston.” (Brooke Donald, “Northeast Emissions Talks Break Down,” Associated Press, December 14, 2005) Fact: Talk is cheap, but implementing mandatory caps on carbon dioxide emissions is not. Expectations were high moving into the Montreal discussions, yet the industrialized nations backing Kyoto balked at producing future targets beyond those set for 2012 (understandable considering that the overwhelming majority of those nations are actually increasing their emissions and thus missing their 2012 targets). A narrow majority of the United States Senate voted in favor of a Sense of the Senate that stated the Congress should enact a policy, sometime in the future, that would implement emissions caps – provided that the U.S. economy would not suffer as a result. But when it came time to vote on legislation that would actually enact mandatory caps, 60 senators voted against it. The costs associated with caps would hurt American families. Despite the misgivings and warnings about the costs from three of the RGGI states, the remaining states may still attempt to reach an agreement to avoid further political embarrassment. As they do so, they should keep the following examples of the high costs in mind (Charles River Associates / United for Jobs estimates based on McCain-Lieberman legislative approach): Impacts of CO2 Controls / Cap and Trade Legislation on Maine – A loss of 4,000 to 5,000 jobs by 2010 – A loss of 5,000 to 7,000 jobs by 2020 – A 33% energy cost increase for the poorest households – A 3% energy increase for the elderly – A 19% to 53% increase in natural gas prices and 2% to 3% increase in electricity prices for industry by 2020 Impacts of CO2 Controls / Cap and Trade Legislation on New Hampshire – A loss of 4,000 to 6,000 jobs by 2010 – A loss of 5,000 to 8,000 jobs by 2020 – A 47% energy cost increase for the poorest households – A 9% energy increase for the elderly – A 19% to 53% increase in natural gas prices and 8% to 19% increase in electricity prices for industry in 2020