Fact of the Day: Friday, August 5, 2005 Understanding Mercury Deposition in the U.S. “…[R]esults from ancient remains are consistent and provide evidence that humans have always been exposed to naturally occurring mercury through fish and marine mammals in their diets.” Use of Traditional Foods in a Healthy Diet in Alaska: Risks in Perspective Second Edition: Volume 2. Mercury Scott M. Arnold, Ph.D. John P. Middaugh, M.D. Section of Epidemiology Alaska Division of Public Health Department of Health and Social Services State of Alaska December 2, 2004 The League of Conservation Voters, in its latest liberal partisan “E-jab,” states that “Mercury is a real horror show. It comes out of power plants, into our air, and causes brain damage in children. And now the Bush Administration actually wants to increase the amount of mercury in our environment.” Fact:Actions to significantly reduce mercury emissions from the nation’s power plants are being taken with a recent federal regulation promulgated by the Administration and even more effective Clear Skies legislation pending in Congress that will cut mercury emissions 70 percent. However… It’s important to understand that power plants are a minor source of emissions. There are a number of mercury sources in the country, and not all sources are anthropogenic (man-made) — Combustion: -Automobiles -Factories -Incinerators -Power plants Naturally-occurring: -Forest fires -Geologic deposits -Geysers -Underwater cracks in the Earth’s crust -Volcanoes (surface and underwater) All of these sources contribute to mercury deposition throughout the United States and the rest of the world. It is generally believed that emissions from U.S. power plants contribute only one percent to total global emissions of mercury. Perhaps the largest source of mercury is nature: volcanoes, forest fires and oceans. For example, according to a report on research conducted in 2003, Yellowstone National Park “could emit as much mercury as all the coal-fired power plants in Wyoming.”[1] Indeed, some estimate, when oceans are factored in as a source, that U.S. power plants may account for as little as 0.002 percent of total global emissions. That said, mercury will be present in the human bloodstream, regardless of whether power plants are regulated by a cap-and-trade emissions reduction program or a more costly but less effective maximum achievable control technology (MACT) standard – or even if all combustion sources are eliminated. Consider that one study provides evidence showing traces of mercury in human beings as far back as the 5th Century. Also, eight 550-year-old Alaskan mummies (four adults and four infants) that were tested contained levels of mercury twice as high as pregnant Alaskan women today. The study’s authors concluded that, “All of these results from ancient remains are consistent and provide evidence that humans have always been exposed to naturally occurring mercury through fish and marine mammals in their diets.”[2] The map below shows the extent of mercury deposition in the United States from all sources in 2001: The map below shows the extent of deposition in 2001 attributed to power plants alone: Deposition in 2020 – with power plants removed from the equation: While introducing S. J. Res. 20, a resolution to disapprove of the Bush Administration’s mercury regulation – the first ever – Senator Leahy stated: “You cannot even see my state on EPA’s maps showing mercury pollution because so much of it is being dumped on us from upwind power plants. Vermonters and New Englanders have been waiting for decades for EPA to take action so that our lakes can be cleaned up.” Interestingly, EPA’s maps indicate that even if it was possible to completely eliminate mercury emissions from power plants, there would be virtually no effect on mercury deposition in New England, particularly Vermont. When considering the EPA’s maps above, Mercury Deposition from All Sources in 2001 and Mercury Deposition from Non-Power Plant Sources in 2020, the range in deposition levels is unchanged. In both cases, deposition levels fall somewhere between 10-15 micrograms per square meter. Even after removing power plants from the equation, the fact is that deposition is roughly the same in southern New England – because power plants are not the only sources of mercury. Compared with the current mercury regulation, a MACT standard, if one was technologically-feasible, would reduce mercury deposition in the United States by only about 2 percent more – but at a cost of up to $358 billion. The current regulation, with its significant 70 percent emissions reduction, is estimated to cost a tiny fraction of that – $2 billion. ——————————————————————————– [1] Mike Stark, “Scientists find major mercury emissions in Yellowstone,” Billings Gazette, October 22, 2003 [2] Scott M. Arnold, Ph.D. John P. Middaugh, M.D. Section of Epidemiology Alaska Division of Public Health Department of Health and Social Services State of Alaska, “Use of Traditional Foods in a Healthy Diet in Alaska: Risks in Perspective, Second Edition: Volume 2. Mercury,” December 2, 2004, p. 4