New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer and his cadre of litigious state AGs are suing the Bush Administration for its “failure” to regulate carbon dioxide emissions under the Clean Air Act. Spitzer and co. want CO2 to be regulated as a “pollutant,” arguing that it causes “harm to the environment.” That raises a fundamental scientific question: Just what is CO2 anyway?

 

FACT: Dr. Andrew Weaver, who helped shape the Kyoto Global Warming Treaty, and who heads the climate modeling group at the University of Victoria, describes it this way: “Carbon dioxide is not a pollutant and no scientist would ever say it is. Carbon dioxide is essential for plant growth. Humans breathe it out with every breath.”

 

By comparison, here’s how Webster’s dictionary defines sulfur dioxide, which EPA now regulates and President Bush’s Clear Skies Initiative seeks to reduce by 73 percent: “A heavy pungent toxic gas (SO2) that is easily condensed to a colorless liquid, is used especially in making sulfuric acid, in bleaching, as a preservative, and as a refrigerant, and is a major air pollutant especially in industrial areas.”

Or what about nitrogen oxide, which EPA now regulates and Clear Skies would reduce by 67 percent? Again, from Webster’s: “Any of several oxides of nitrogen most of which are produced in combustion and are considered to be atmospheric pollutants.”