The only real “consensus” in the global warming debate appears to be on the disdain for climate change legislation pending in the U.S. Senate. With the McCain-Lieberman carbon cap amendment continuing to lose support – Environment & Energy Daily reports today another three Democrat senators are defecting and will vote against the amendment – some attention has shifted to Senator Bingaman’s proposed amendment. But this amendment, too, which also caps carbon dioxide, faces strong opposition from liberal special interest groups. Dan Lashof, science director for the Natural Resources Defense Council’s Climate Center says, “This trading scheme is watered down to the point where it is basically ineffectual in getting us on the path,” and “If the Hagel provision is a fig leaf for the climate problem, this (Bingaman provision) is basically a banana leaf.” Fact: Passage of a carbon tax amendment will undoubtedly cripple the American economy, and, at the same time, provide virtually no benefit. The McCain-Lieberman amendment, according to the most recent Charles River Associates (CRA) study, would: cost more than one million American jobs over the next 15 years, impose an additional cost of $810 dollars a year on households, increase already high gasoline prices by 55 cents a gallon, increase electricity prices 20% by 2020, and increase the cost of natural gas by 47%. At such a great expense to the American people, the McCain-Lieberman amendment would only result in the aversion of 0.029ºC in temperature – assuming climate alarmists are correct about causation. The Bingaman amendment, which environmentalists admit would have little or no difference in emission reductions, would cost taxpayers $27 billion annually. Paul Bledsoe, communications director for the non-governmental National Commission on Energy Policy (NCEP), which forms the basis of the provisions contained in the Bingaman amendment, says, “My concern is that it can be portrayed as a carbon tax – anathema to the GOP.” Bledsoe further states the amendment is more about passing something and less about reducing emissions: “Our view is that the more important thing is timing – to attach a price to carbon emissions as soon as possible.” United for Jobs points out that the recent CRA study reveals that the full NCEP proposal would actually yield smaller emissions reductions than President Bush’s voluntary programs. According to a new report from the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the Bingaman (NCEP cap-and-trade) amendment would: reduce cumulative U.S. GDP by $588 billion from 2010 to 2025, result in the loss of 171,000 non-farm jobs in 2025, and result in virtually no benefit to justify such costs – the aversion of 0.008oC in temperature by 2050 (again, assuming climate alarmists are correct).