Washington Post: Obama green-tech program that backed Solyndra struggles to create jobs
By
Carol D. Leonnig and Steven
Mufson
September 14, 2011
A
$38.6 billion loan guarantee
program that the Obama administration promised would create or save 65,000
jobs has created just a few thousand jobs two years after it began, government
records show.
The
program — designed to jump-start the nation’s clean technology industry by
giving energy companies access to low-cost, government-backed loans — has
directly created 3,545 new, permanent jobs after giving out almost half the
allocated amount, according to Energy Department
tallies.
President
Obama has made “green jobs” a showcase of his recovery plan, vowing to foster
new jobs, new technologies and more competitive American industries. But the
loan guarantee program came under scrutiny Wednesday from Republicans and
Democrats at a House oversight committee hearing about the collapse of Solyndra,
a solar-panel maker whose closure could leave taxpayers on the hook for as
much as $527 million.
The
GOP lawmakers accused
the administration of rushing approval of a guarantee of the firm’s project
and failing to adequately vet it. “My goodness. We should be reviewing every
one of these loan guarantee” projects, said Rep. Marsha
Blackburn (R-Tenn.).
Obama’s
efforts to create green jobs are lagging behind expectations at a time of
persistently high unemployment. Many economists say that because alternative-energy
projects are so expensive and slow to ramp up, they are not the most efficient
way to stimulate the economy.
“There
are good reasons to create green jobs, but they have more to do with green than
with jobs,” Princeton University economics professor and former Federal Reserve
vice chairman Alan Blinder has said.
The
loan guarantee program can also be unwieldy. It works like this: Companies
negotiate with the Energy Department for a government loan guarantee, which
means taxpayers will pay off bank loans if the project fails. Then the Office
of Management and Budget must sign off on the guarantees, often changing terms.
The
Energy Department says that the green-jobs program is still on track to meet
its employment goals. It claims credit for saving 33,000 jobs at Ford
Motor Co. — about half of the Detroit automaker’s entire hourly and
salaried U.S. workforce. The department says the biggest of its loan guarantees,
for $5.9 billion, protected the jobs at Ford by enabling the automaker to
upgrade plants in five states to build more energy-efficient vehicles. The Energy Department
said the loan would “convert” the Ford jobs to “green manufacturing jobs.”
Several
economists said they doubt the loan program saved 33,000 jobs at Ford.
“I
always take these job estimates with a big grain of salt,” Josh Lerner, a
Harvard Business School professor who has written about failed government
efforts to stimulate targeted industries, said in an e-mail. “There tends to be
a lot of fuzzy math when it comes to calculating these benefits (regardless of
the party taking credit for the program).”
A
Ford spokeswoman said the loans helped “transform what were primarily truck/SUV
plants into flexible manufacturing plants capable of building more
fuel-efficient vehicles.” That flexibility is key to “helping retain the
33,000 jobs by ensuring our employees can build
the fuel-efficient cars people want to drive,” said Meghan Keck, who
handles government relations for Ford.
Mark
Muro, a Brookings Institution fellow who researches the clean-tech industry,
said the agency appears to be counting every employee working in upgraded
plants, when the more relevant question is how many workers would have been
laid off without the loans.
The
Energy Department’s loan guarantee program, a key component of Obama’s 2009
stimulus plan, is under heightened scrutiny since Solyndra,
the first company it backed, declared
bankruptcy and closed its doors two weeks ago. The failure of the
solar-panel manufacturer, which got a $535 million government loan
guarantee and later direct government loans, led to the layoff of 1,100
workers. It drew down money as recently as July. The government had dispersed
$527 million of the loan to Solyndra.
Energy
Department officials had vowed earlier this year to create or save more than
65,000 American jobs once its 42 projects were financed and complete. They say
the program is now “on pace” to create or save roughly 60,000 jobs. (It shaved
roughly 5,000 from the target after two companies turned down the department’s
offer of help.) The department adds that its projects have helped generate
7,391 temporary construction jobs.
“This
does not include tens of thousands of indirect jobs these projects create up
and down the supply chain, or the countless additional jobs that depend on
America staying competitive with countries like China
in the clean-energy race,” department spokesman Damien LaVera said.
Renewable-energy
firms say many other workers and companies have prospered by being part of the
supply chain. BrightSource Energy, for example, a developer of utility-scale
solar-power projects, is the recipient of a $1.6 billion loan guarantee, the
second-biggest awarded so far; it says it has purchased goods in 17 states.
Still,
agency projections indicate that creating jobs is a laborious process. If the
20 companies that have won loans so far deliver all the new jobs they have
promised, they will hire a total of 8,050 new workers for permanent positions.
Half of those 20 companies have neither created nor saved any permanent jobs
yet; several won their loans only recently. Even the BrightSource project,
which employs 700 construction workers now, will employ only 86 people on a
permanent basis.
Obama
administration officials say the jobs are high-quality and will improve the
economy’s productivity. In addition to the loan guarantee program, the Obama
administration has targeted “green jobs” through cash grants for wind farms and
weatherization grants to state agencies.
Muro
said administration-supported projects “that may have been honorable
investments in technology were sold as short-term job creators for political
reasons,” he said. “Exaggerated expectations about jobs were set.”
The
eventual cost of the loan guarantee program for taxpayers remains unclear. If
the revised 60,000 target is reached, it would work out to about $640,000 in
loan guarantees for every job created or saved. These financing guarantees were
approved by Congress as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.
If
the companies do well, they won’t need to draw on the guarantees and won’t cost
the government anything. But if the companies go bankrupt, as Solyndra did,
taxpayers will be on the hook. Moreover, the Treasury Department’s
Federal Financing Bank has been directly lending — at extremely low, subsidized
rates — to companies that win Energy Department guarantees. Congress and the
administration assumed a failure rate of 5 to 10 percent for the program.
Solyndra represents about 3 percent of the loan guarantees made so far.
Solyndra
received the Energy Department’s backing and also a federal bank loan — at
rates as low as 1.025 percent. It’s unclear how much, if anything, the
government can recover in bankruptcy proceedings, but it can pursue claims as a
creditor.
Solyndra’s
closure prompted concerns about whether the administration made good bets in
the rest of its portfolio of clean-tech projects it had helped subsidize with
taxpayer-guaranteed loans. The primary investors in Solyndra were funds tied to
a major Obama fundraising bundler, Tulsa oilman George Kaiser.
Although
the financing of renewable-energy projects was never an ideal way to create
jobs, the 2009 stimulus package gave Obama a way to get Congress to appropriate
more money for renewable energy than it would have provided otherwise.
In
addition to guaranteeing loans for renewable-energy projects, the Energy
Department has been meting out grants from a separate, less-controversial
$33.7 billion appropriation it received as part of the 2009 economic
stimulus bill. So far, the department has given out $18.1 billion from
that fund, ranging from $44,295 to a Swarthmore College science program to
about $1.5 billion to clean up waste at the government’s Savannah River
nuclear site. Hundreds of millions have gone to companies trying to figure out
cheaper ways to capture carbon dioxide from coal plants, a priority for
coal-state lawmakers.
###