Posted by Katie Brown Katie_Brown@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It…
The Oklahoman
Op-Ed: Regional haze rule about looks, not health
BY SCOTT PRUITT
June 5, 2011
I don’t often refer to Gen. George Patton when it comes to issues facing Oklahomans, but his wisdom is a great illustration of what President Obama ought to abide by when it comes to reining in his administration at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
Patton said great leaders tell people what to do, then let them figure out a way to do it. Unfortunately for Oklahomans, the EPA shuns this principle and the rule of law with its latest misguided implementation of the Clean Air Act.
The challenge before our state is the implementation of the Regional Haze Rule of the Clean Air Act, which refers to the aesthetic visibility of air in national parks and wildlife refuges like our beautiful Wichita Mountains Wildlife Refuge. It is not about public health.
According to the rule, state and federal agencies must work together to improve visibility at national parks and wilderness areas by 2064. Oklahoma stakeholders spent months creating a State Implementation Plan, and submitted it to the EPA more than a year ago.
The state plan would reduce emissions from the state’s coal plants by switching to natural gas or by installing scrubbers.
In March, EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson informed Oklahoma the federal government planned to implement its own regional haze plan. Why? Not because Oklahoma’s plan didn’t meet the requirements of the Regional Haze Rule, but because Oklahoma’s plan didn’t meet the EPA administrator’s new and arbitrary deadline.
The federal plan not only usurps the legal authority of the state to comply with the Regional Haze Rule, but will result in utility rates for some Oklahoma consumers to increase up to 20 percent over three years. This is not acceptable. The state plan will keep those rates affordable and still succeed in reaching the goal of improved visibility.
As Oklahoma attorney general, it is not my job to formulate or implement Oklahoma’s plan; but it is my job to preserve Oklahoma’s right to do so – particularly when the Clean Air Act so clearly recognizes that Oklahomans, and not federal bureaucrats, are best situated to determine Oklahoma energy and environmental policies.
Unfortunately, this has been a pattern of behavior for the EPA, so acquiescing or agreeing to its demands now would be shortsighted and only make it more difficult to challenge their authority on other issues such as regulating greenhouse gases or defeating their baseless assault on hydraulic fracturing.
Having given Jackson and the EPA the required 60-day notice, we have sued the EPA to challenge its authority to issue an implementation plan in the manner in which it did, and noting the agency’s failure to follow the SIP approval process.
I will continue to advocate for preservation of our rights at every turn. I applaud the efforts of U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, Gov. Mary Fallin and the Oklahoma Corporation Commission as well as many other state leaders, who also are working to combat this overreaching intrusion.
Pruitt is attorney general of Oklahoma.
###