Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

The Oklahoman Editorial

Warming Debate Simmers as Obama Poses in Europe

Published: July 10, 2009

Link to Editorial

You’ve got to hand it to Greenpeace. It takes moxie to scale Mount Rushmore and unfurl a global warming banner the size of Abe Lincoln’s granite head — all before the National Park Service moves in to make arrests.

The group’s South Dakota stunt offered a snappier message than one from the Group of 8 in Italy this week that aims at cutting global carbon emissions. Sort of.

The Italian communique — calling for a 50 percent cut by 2050, hoping to keep the world’s temperature from rising more than 3.6 degrees — fell short of the hard pledge climate change groups like Greenpeace demand.

It also lacked interim targets for 2020 and funding. The meeting did produce a cheesy photo of the heads of state, lined up tall (President Barack Obama) to small (Russia’s Dmitry Medvedev). Fitting, because the climate change act is so much stagecraft.

Al Gore and others have dragged the planet’s governments this far by declaring human-caused warming an established fact. But it isn’t — part of the reason cap-and-trade legislation is getting a chilly reception in the U.S. Senate.

Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Tulsa, says the bill is dead because of scientific uncertainty and because, even if the science was concrete solid, efforts to reduce emissions don’t include two of the biggest emitters: China and India.

During the next few weeks, lots of hot air will be emitted in the Senate chamber on legislation the White House knows is probably doomed. But it will look good to the Europeans, allowing administration officials to attend the next big climate change conference in December with heads held high.

There’s too much dissent from earlier, dire forecasts to risk wrecking the U.S. economy with carbon emissions legislation. Inhofe, who’s as authoritative on this as one can be without a white lab coat, says more than 700 scientists now refute the claim that people are the key cause of warming.

It gives a "ready, fire, aim” quality to the Italy summit and the Obama Team’s push to use taxes to force U.S. emissions reductions — best illustrated by the treatment of Environmental Protection Agency analyst Alan Carlin, who earlier this year wrote a report questioning the science underlying climate policy objectives. Carlin was told to be quiet and go away.

It’s a foolish and potentially dangerous approach. The science isn’t settled, and an emerging Senate majority is right to oppose cap and trade.

The administration better listen. Otherwise, it’s going to have a bigger problem than a bunch of kooks with a banner running rings around the rangers at Mount Rushmore. 

###