Posted by matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News… 

E&E News 

Oklahomans warn FWS director about impact of prairie chicken listing

Phil Taylor, E&E reporter

Published: Thursday, September 8, 2011

Link to Article

Oklahomans applauded Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe for coming to their state this week to hear concerns over a potential federal listing of the lesser prairie chicken, an iconic species that roams five states in the region.

But Jim Reese, the state’s secretary of agriculture, yesterday had a wry warning: "I pray this isn’t the kiss on the cheek before you stab us in the gut," he told the Oklahoma Farm Report.

Ashe’s visit yesterday to Woodward and today to Edmond fulfils a promise he made to Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) during his spring confirmation, which was delayed for more than a half-year by holds from three Republican senators. Two of those holds were for reasons unrelated to the role of FWS.

Inhofe today thanked Ashe but reiterated his concerns that an Endangered Species Act listing for the bird could have devastating effects on Oklahoma’s economy, including agriculture, highway infrastructure and wind farms.

"I call on Director Ashe to do the right thing and allow the voluntary efforts already underway in Oklahoma to produce positive results before going through with a listing that could be so detrimental to the state’s well-being," he said in a statement.

Gary Sherrer, Oklahoma’s secretary of environment, said conservation efforts in his state need more time to allow the bird’s population to multiply.

"We’ve worked with the state Legislature, we’ve worked with the Oklahoma wildlife department, Nature Conservancy and a lot of other groups that have an interest in getting the number of these birds up so there will not be the need to list," he said. "Give us more time."

Ashe at yesterday’s hearing lauded the state’s efforts to conserve the bird’s shrinking habitat but said his agency is obligated by law to issue a decision on the bird within a year.

Chris Tollefson, a spokesman for the agency, said the Endangered Species Act offers tools to allow local traditional land uses to continue. Renewable energy development would be "compatible" with a listing.

"We’re looking at ways to manage renewable energy development and its impacts on species at risk," Tollefson said. "We recognize that it’s important for the future of this country to develop these resources."

Sparring over economic impacts
Under the law, FWS is not allowed to consider economic harm when determining listing decisions. But economic trade-offs would be considered for determining critical habitat for the bird if a listing is made, he said.

The colorful bird, which sports a bright yellow eye band and bulbous "air sacs" in males, was included in a landmark settlement with environmental groups that requires FWS to issue final listing decisions on hundreds of "candidate" species (E&ENews PM, July 12).

The bird has been on the candidate list — known as "purgatory" by some environmental groups — for more than a decade. FWS lists grazing, tree encroachment, conversion of rangeland to crop and nonnative forage, energy development and increased disturbance as primary causes of the bird’s decline.

Randy Bolles, manager of regulatory affairs for Oklahoma-based Devon Energy’s Western division, warned that a federal listing would be premature until more scientific information emerges about the bird’s habitat, population and distribution.

"Listing the lesser prairie chicken would halt economic development in the region and hurt job-creation efforts," he said in prepared remarks today in Edmond. "However, continuing collaborative conservation efforts would provide the best opportunity to restore the lesser prairie chicken and protect the local economy."

But Noah Greenwald, endangered species program director for Center for Biological Diversity, said such warnings are "grossly overstated."

"Instead, what [a listing] will do is create reasonable habitat protections to ensure development doesn’t drive the prairie chicken to extinction," Greenwald said.

Wind developers will be forced to develop sites away from prairie chicken habitat, and federal agencies will need to ensure that permitting decisions do not jeopardize the bird’s survival, he said.