Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
In the News…
The Journal Record
Inhofe opposes proposed EPA rule
By D. Ray Tuttle
Tuesday, September 28, 2010
TULSA – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, the top Republican on a Senate environmental panel, released a blistering report Tuesday targeting the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s new proposed rule on cleaning up boilers and proposed ozone levels.
The report said the rule would devastate America’s manufacturing base and threaten hundreds of thousands of jobs nationwide without providing any real public health or environmental benefits.
In June, the EPA issued a proposal that would force industrial, commercial and institutional boilers and heaters to use maximum achievable control technology to reduce harmful emissions that erode air quality and pose a public health risk.
The proposed rule covers industrial boilers used in manufacturing, processing, mining and refining and commercial boilers used in malls, laundries, apartments, restaurants and hotels, according to the report.
The new standards for commercial and industrial boilers put 798,250 jobs at risk, the report said.
The Inhofe report also targets the EPA’s proposal to reduce the national primary ozone standard to 60 parts per billion from 75 ppb. In a separate report, the American Petroleum Institute said it would devastate the economy by forcing most of the country to meet stringent standards that are imposed in its most heavily populated areas.
"We all know that EPA cannot consider economics in considering standards," said Howard Feldman, API’s director of regulatory and scientific affairs. "But it cannot ignore them. There’s a real cost and real significance to this."
The EPA estimates that setting the primary standard, or the eight-hour "primary" ozone standard, within the range of 60 to 70 parts ppb would cost $19 billion to $90 billion.
"Put another way, the ozone revision could be the most expensive EPA regulation ever proposed," the Inhofe report said.
The proposal comes on the heels of the revised 2008 ozone standard, which was lowered significantly from 84 ppb to 75 ppb.
Tulsa, Oklahoma City and the state are within the current limits at 75 ppb.
"The EPA will announce a new ozone standard by Oct. 31," said Dave Bary, EPA public information officer. "The new standard will be between 0.60 and 0.70."
That standard would place both cities on the so-called "dirty-air list."
In a separate study released earlier this month, the Manufacturers Alliance predicted that if the EPA adopts the proposal, U.S. gross domestic product would be reduced by an estimated $676.8 billion in 2020, or 3.6 percent, and job losses would climb to 7.3 billion, or 4.3 percent, of the projected domestic labor force that year.
The API and the National Association of Manufacturers co-sponsored that study.
The Inhofe report, taking aim at the revised National Ambient Air Quality Standard for ozone, said the upcoming revision in October would create "severe restrictions on job creation and business expansion in hundreds of counties nationwide."
On Jan. 6, for the second time in less than two years, the EPA proposed to tighten the national ambient air quality standards for ground-level ozone. The pollutant is formed when emissions of nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds from cars, trucks, power plants and other sources react with sunlight.
Making changes at this stage creates uncertainty, as states and businesses grapple with existing standards and prepare for even more stringent standards in the near future, the Inhofe report said.
"There is no good reason for this, as EPA’s proposal is based on the same scientific and technical record used in the March 2008 ozone review," the Inhofe report said.
The EPA has conceded it is not relying on any new ozone studies published since the science assessment supporting the 2008 review was completed in 2006.
The EPA is using scientific studies that are at least four years old, according to the Inhofe report.
"Thus EPA is, by definition, not relying on the ‘latest scientific knowledge,’ as the Clean Air Act requires," the Inhofe report said.
The EPA is required to finalize a proposal by Dec. 16. The agency has argued that implementing the rule would prevent 1,900 to 4,800 premature deaths in 2013 by reducing pollutants like dioxin, mercury and carbon monoxide, which are known or suspected to cause cancer and other serious health and environmental effects.
Also, the EPA said other benefits include reduced cases of asthma, bronchitis, heart attacks, fewer hospital visits and lost workdays. The agency said the value of the benefits ranges from $17 billion to $41 billion in 2013 alone – outweighing the costs of implementing the new rule by at least $14 billion.
###