Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
With the Obama Administration announcing yesterday that it will adopt California’s greenhouse gas emissions standard for cars, it will effectively impose California’s climate change policy on the entire nation. We are also seeing California’s influence in Congress, where Rep. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.) is pushing his climate law through the Energy and Commerce Committee.
Some think the Administration’s adoption of California’s environmental policy will produce progress, innovation, and growth. California bureaucrats said exactly that in its own economic analysis of California’s climate law, A.B. 32. In the “Scoping Plan” for A.B. 32, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) proudly boasted: “The economic analysis of this plan indicates that implementation of the recommended strategies to address global warming will create jobs and save individual households money.” CARB further stated: “The economic analysis indicates that implementation of that forward-looking approach also creates more jobs and saves individual households more money than if California stood by and pursued an unacceptable course of doing nothing at all to address our unbridled reliance on fossil fuels.”
The only problem with CARB’s conclusions is that they have no basis in fact. In a peer review of CARB’s analysis, Harvard University’s Robert Stavins reached the “inescapable conclusion that the economic analysis is terribly deficient in critical ways and should not be used by the State government or the public for the purpose of assessing the likely costs of CARB’s plans.” “I say this with some sadness,” he continued, “because I was hopeful that CARB would produce sensible policy proposals analyzed with sound scientific and economic analysis.” The analysis is “severely flawed,” Stavins said, and “hence not useful for the purpose for which it was intended.”
These are tough words. As one of six economists who analyzed CARB’s work, Stavins said claims that greenhouse gas mandates will be cost-free as “inconsistent with decades of economic analysis on this important challenge.” Further, he stated, “Even if one accepts the cost estimates that CARB produces, which I believe are significant understatements of the true costs…the estimates are still useless for identifying a cost-effective portfolio of policies to achieve the ambitious objectives of AB 32.”
Stavins concludes with this admonition: “Because of the magnitude of the challenge and the significant costs of addressing [climate change]…sound economic analyses are essential if sensible public policies are to be designed and implemented.”
Such judgments should give pause to those who claim global warming mandates, especially those crafted in California, will mean more jobs, greater economic growth, and more energy security. When judged on the merits, such claims are, as Stavins said, “useless.”
###