Posted by:Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@inhofe.senate.gov (202)224-9797   

    

EPW Policy Beat: THE ACID RAIN MYTH 

 

 

As the Senate debates the merits of using budget reconciliation to advance climate change legislation, EPW Policy Beat found an enlightening article discussing the frequently invoked, yet inapt, comparison between cap-and-trade for greenhouse gases and the 1990 cap-and-trade program to reduce acid rain.  Authors Laurie Williams and Allen Zabel, career employees of the Environmental Protection Agency who support instituting a carbon fee to address climate change, examine what they call the “Acid Rain Myth.”  As the authors explain, “those who champion using cap-and-trade to address climate change claim that it has been ‘proven’ to work in the U.S. Acid Rain program.  However, this assertion ignores crucial distinctions between the challenges we faced in 1990 with Acid Rain and the challenges we face today with global warming.”  The Williams and Zabel study on this apples-and-oranges comparison, and the flaws of applying cap and trade to address climate change, can be found here: Link 

As the following highlights from the study make abundantly clear, the experience of the Acid Rain program simply cannot be compared to cap and trade for GHG:   

 

 

 

 

 

 

Another essential difference is the size of the two programs—for Acid Rain, cap-and-trade covered a limited number of sources only in the utility sector, while under a GHG cap, according to Bill Fang of EEI, “you are talking about literally millions of sources.”  Link

 Previous EPW Policy Beat                         

                                                    ###