Fact of the Day: Tuesday, September 13, 2005 The Myths and Facts of the Mercury Regulation Health Effects Senator Leahy (9/12): “Do we allow this new rule to allow toxic mercury? So everyone understands what we are talking about, this does not just make the skies darker. This is a substance so harmful that it causes birth defects, IQ loss, and mental retardation. Do we continue to let it poison children and pregnant women, while costing taxpayers billions in health care costs?” Fact: Eating fish rich in Omega-3 fatty acids is beneficial to human health, especially to pregnant women and their unborn children. No woman in the United States who has tested for mercury exposure has levels known to be unsafe. While a small percentage are testing above the ultra-conservative level that incorporates a ten-fold ‘fudge factor’ or ‘safety factor,’ not a single woman has tested anywhere near the level that is considered unsafe or ‘dangerous’ — that is, the lowest level where an observed effect was detected in even one study. Furthermore, according to government studies, 80% of the fish consumed by Americans originates overseas. Since mercury emissions from U.S. coal-fired power plants make up less than 1% of the worldwide total, even a complete elimination of those emissions would have no measurable impact on the amount of mercury found in most fish. SOURCE: 04/20/2005 – DPC Mercury “Hearing” EPA Inspector General’s Report Senator Leahy (9/12): “Should we allow this rule to move forward, the Bush administration’s own inspector general says it does not comply with EPA Executive order requirements. Their own inspector general says it does not comply. The Government Accountability Office has said there are major shortcomings in the economic analysis. Or should we uphold the bipartisan work of Republicans and Democrats alike that produced the Clean Air Act, thus protecting the health of pregnant women and children?” Fact: The report released … by the EPA Office of Inspector General [IG] is another example of how [Clinton-appointee] Nikki Tinsley has politicized the office. The report titled Additional Analyses of Mercury Emissions Needed Before EPA Finalizes Rules for Coal-Fired Electric Utilities was conducted by employees without sufficient technical, scientific, or regulatory experience to properly evaluate the regulatory-setting process -and it shows in the poor quality of the report. For example, that the report asserts that the mercury Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT) number was not based on the top twelve percent of performing plants, but on the co-benefits level achieved from installing other pollution control equipment — and that it set a performance standard instead of a technology standard. That is not how the law is constructed. Not a single plant in the database upon which this standard is being set uses mercury specific technology. Controls at the best twelve percent of plants achieve mercury reductions as a “co-benefit” of controlling other sources. So achieving a “co-benefit” level at the best plants is what the law requires. In addition, the report asserts that some federal advisory committee members advising EPA on setting the mercury standard considered the job unfinished. But this advisory group met for almost two years and had more than a dozen meetings and many dozens of sub-group meetings. Few clean air advisory groups in history have ever met so frequently or produced so much work for EPA to consider. What the IG fails to report is that most members of the FACA process believed that the issue was discussed thoroughly and it was not until after the conclusion that a minority of members wanted to reopen the process – a fact she would have discovered if she had polled the members, which she did not. Clearly, this politicized office is not fit to evaluate the quality of policies developed by regulators in the Office of Air and Radiation, who unlike the IG’s office, have the necessary training and expertise in the rule-making process SOURCE: 02/03/2005 – INHOFE CRITICIZES EPA IG’S REPORT ON MERCURY EMISSIONS Mercury Reductions and Court Delays Senator Leahy (9/12): “This rule is going to allow more mercury into our environment than even the current law. If we leave the current law alone, there would be less mercury in our environment. Instead, the rule gives more pollution for longer than the Clean Air Act allows. Fact: Until implementation of the Clean Air Mercury Rule earlier this year, there was no law or regulation on the books controlling mercury emissions from power plants. The Administration’s rule is the first-ever regulation. The Clean Air Act is already marred by extensive litigation, and the Democrat approach only serves as a further invitation to lawyers and prolonged litigation. The magazine Economist warns the Democrat Party “is in danger of becoming associated with ‘command and control’ legislation that is hard to enforce and subject to time-wasting litigation.” Opponents apparently prefer to put more money in the pockets of trial lawyers and attempt to sue their way to cleaner air. Recently, however, this strategy has begun to unravel. Three court decisions within the last month, one even by a Clinton-appointed judge, have upheld key portions of the Bush Administration’s clean air reforms and rejected challenges associated with the 1999 Clinton New Source Review (NSR) enforcement initiative. Failing litigation aside, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) itself is having difficulty in meeting its own obligations under the current Clean Air Act structure. According to the GAO’s new report, Clean Air Act: EPA Has Completed Most of the Actions Required by the 1990 Amendments, but Many Were Completed Late: · “EPA had completed 404 of the 452 actions required to meet the objectives of Titles I, III, and IV of the Clean Air Act Amendments 1990.” “Of the 338 requirements that had statutory deadlines prior to April 2005, EPA completed 256 late: – many (162) 2 years or less after the required date, but others (94) more than 2 years after their deadlines.” (source: GAO highlights document) GAO also notes that, “Consequently, improvements in air quality associated with some of these requirements may have been delayed.” Greg Easterbrook with the Brookings Institute noting the success of cap-and –trade programs writes in an op-ed piece in the New York Times, “In practice, cap-and-trade systems have proved faster, cheaper and less vulnerable to legal stalling tactics than the ‘command and control’ premise of most of the Clean Air Act.” SOURCE: 06/28/2005 – Out With the Hot Air and In With the Clean, 03/07/2005 – Cap-and-Trade vs. “Command and Control” Controlling Mercury Emissions Senator Leahy (9/12): “Now they have revoked an earlier EPA finding that is necessary and appropriate to require these power plants apply technology to reduce mercury emissions. By revoking the earlier EPA finding and deciding instead to coddle the biggest mercury polluters, the administration is saying it is no longer necessary or appropriate to adequately control mercury emissions. It is an audacious disregard for the health of the American people.” Fact: A report by the Energy Information Administration provides compelling proof that mercury control technologies are not commercially available and that a 90 percent standard by 2008 is highly impractical, unrealistic, and excessively costly. In the 60-plus-page report, titled Analysis of Mercury Control Strategies, EIA notes the significant uncertainty associated with mercury removal. “At this time,” EIA wrote, “there is significant uncertainty about the degree to which mercury can be removed from some coals,” and “it could be several years before these technologies are fully commercialized.” What of the “achievable” 90 percent reduction by 2008? Not quite: “Whether current ACI [activated carbon injection] systems for coal plants would meet the analysis request requirement for a ‘commercially demonstrated technology’ for deployment in the 2008 timeframe, particularly if 90-percent removal is required, is unclear.” When asked if mercury removal technology is currently commercially available to achieve a guaranteed, long-term 90 percent reduction on all coal types, the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) responded, “No, not across the board or at the high removal levels needed on a day-to-day basis to ensure compliance with a 90% limit. Test results available to EPRI from its own projects and those cofunded by the Department of Energy over the past 1-2 years have shown that some mercury removal processes have achieved 90% mercury reductions at some plants during tests ranging from a few days up to one month. However, in numerous other cases, plants have not been able to achieve more than 60-75% mercury capture.” (Source: EPRI) Is a 90 percent, command-and-control standard by 2008 “not every expensive”? Seems it is expensive: in 2010, electricity and natural gas prices would be 22 percent 26 percent higher, respectively. And resource costs could reach $358 billion, or nearly 7 times the cost of implementing Clear Skies, which would reduce mercury, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen oxides for $52 billion. Source: 02/02/2005 – Mercury Mystery Revealed