Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
EPW Policy Beat came across an interesting perspective on climate change legislation—this time from three Pennsylvania utility commissioners. In a May 7 letter to the Pennsylvania Congressional delegation, Tyrone Christy, Kim Pizzingrilli, and Robert Powelson, all of whom, incidentally, were nominated by Gov. Ed Rendell (D), wrote that climate legislation, “[l]eft unexamined and unchecked,” will have “a profound adverse impact on the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.” How so? For one thing, as the commissioners note, Pennsylvania gets 58 percent of its electricity from coal, and is the nation’s 4th largest coal producer, distributing over “75 million tons of coal” each year. “However,” the commissioners warn, “if the Waxman-Markey bill were to pass, Pennsylvania is looking at a bleak scenario by 2020: a net loss of as many as 66,000 jobs, a sizeable hike in the electric bills of residential customers, an increase in natural gas prices, and significant downward pressure on our gross state product.”
As such, “Pennsylvania and other coal-reliant states will be severely and disproportionately harmed by carbon legislation.” As numerous economic reports have shown, this fact is undeniable. The commissioners also rightly point out that carbon legislation poses serious reliability challenges: “It will be impossible for these states to rapidly or immediately stop using power generated at existing coal-fired or natural gas-fired power plants without causing severe and protracted reliability problems.” Getting a good bill versus an economically disastrous one boils down to, in the commissioners’ words, “common sense.” What, then, is to be done? “Is Pennsylvania ready to acquiesce behind federal legislation that will choke off our economy by displacing thousands of jobs and increasing utility bills for residential ratepayers?” Their answer, directed at the Pennsylvania Congressional delegation, was clear and simple: “We hope not.”
###