In Case You Missed It… The Wall Street Journal Commentary Kyoto? Mamma Mia!
By ANTONIO MARTINO October 7, 2005; Page A16 Mr. Martino is Italy’s defense minister. ROME — The devastating hurricanes that hit the U.S. recently offered “eco-doomsayers” — who like to blame human activities, preferably of the industrial kind, for all sorts of natural disasters — yet another chance to lash out at the Bush administration. America’s “failure” to ratify the Kyoto Protocol — regularly held responsible for extreme weather conditions around the globe — was quickly found guilty of the destruction brought about by Katrina and Rita. As usual, the eco-doomsayers care very little for the small fact that their sweeping accusations have absolutely no basis in modern science. First of all, it is not true that President George W. Bush is alone in opposing the Kyoto agreements that his predecessor Bill Clinton signed. … Second, there is no scientifically sound link between rising global temperatures and an increase in the frequency and intensity of hurricanes. Nor are the events of the recent weeks unprecedented: As Max Mayfield, Director of the National Hurricane Center, pointed out, a comparable series of hurricanes of similar intensity has already been observed in 1915. Third, and most important, while a scientific consensus about the true nature of climate change is still lacking, we know for certain that the impact of Kyoto on the average global temperature will be negligible at best. The U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change forecasts that without the ratification of Kyoto, the average global temperature will rise about one degree Celsius by 2050. The same panel predicts that after the implementation of Kyoto, the temperature will still rise 0.94 degrees. In other words, the benefits from Kyoto amount to about 0.06 degrees in half a century. Remarkably, this is even the most optimistic estimate: S. Fred Singer — the climatologist who developed the method for measuring the ozone layer — reckons that it may be as small as 0.02 degrees. This is a difference so minuscule that our available instruments wouldn’t even be able to notice it! … Those countries, such as Italy, that for decades steered clear of building new power plants and gave up on nuclear power — the cleanest, safest and cheapest energy source available today — will need to face up to a harsh reality: Compliance with the Kyoto Protocol will punish even the existing energy-producing capacity by capping emissions. The cost of energy in Italy, already higher than the European average, let alone that in the U.S., will go up even more. Given the country’s lack of competitiveness, that can only be described as a self-inflicted wound. Perhaps the problems of our times are manmade, after all. But rather than being caused by those “neocons” in Washington, they stem from the noble intentions of environmentalists so bent on “saving nature” that in the process they wage an unremitting war against mankind and its endeavors. Click here for the full text of the op-ed (subscription required).