In Case You Missed It… The Calgary Herald
Climate debate full of hot air By Tim Ball November 22, 2005
If Canadians think they’ve already heard too much about Kyoto and climate change, they’d better batten down the hatches — the real deluge is about to begin. Delegations from 189 countries, and thousands of political leaders, government officials, scientists, businesspeople and environmentalists will gather soon for the Nov. 28 to Dec. 9 Montreal Conference on Climate. Canadian environmentalists are giddy with anticipation. Leading the activist charge to pressure the federal government into acquiescing to yet another impossible climate-change treaty is the ubiquitous David Suzuki, now wrapping up a cross-Canada speaking tour with two talks in Calgary on Wednesday and Thursday. He has been pushing hard in recent weeks for scientists to speak out about climate change, admonishing us for not “correcting misleading information in the media,” more often. However, only those who agree with official doctrine are welcome to participate. Suzuki labels those of us who explain what the latest research really tells us about climate change as merely “rogue scientists” who advocate “the opposite of the prevailing scientific opinion.” He expands the criticism to include newspaper editors who dare publish what we are saying: “Even though there is no debate about climate change in scientific circles, you still see one being played out in the editorial pages of newspapers.” We “rogues” are simply trying to practise real science — creating hypotheses, testing them, then telling society what we find. Suzuki apparently prefers to cherry-pick science that supports the social engineering he feels Canada needs. He wrongly assumes that, because he is pushing a political agenda, any other scientist who is quoted in the press also has a political agenda. Ian Clark, a professor at the University of Ottawa, admonishes the activist: “Suzuki must accept that if scientists should be advocates, they will not all advocate what he believes. He cannot chastise us for keeping quiet, and then dismiss us when we speak out in a manner contrary to his beliefs. That is irrational.” Suzuki will undoubtedly give Calgarians more of the same this week. Audiences must not be afraid to publicly contest such a fundamentally anti-science stance. After all, the concept that human emissions of carbon dioxide are a major driver of global climate is merely a hypothesis. … Albert Einstein once said of science, “In the realm of the seekers of the truth, there is no human authority. Whoever attempts to play the magistrate there founders on the laughter of the gods.” Canadians must hold extremists to account, and ask why they seek to play magistrate, and exclude legitimate climate scientists from the debate. Do they consider themselves gods? Or is it just that their stance is so weak they fear a truly open discussion? Tim Ball is a Victoria-based environmental consultant. He was the first climatology PhD in Canada and worked as a professor of climatology at the University of Winnipeg for 28 years. Click here for the full text of the op-ed. (subscription required)

Climate debate full of hot air