Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

What They Are Saying About Obama Commerce Nominee Bryson

WATCH: FOX Business: Inhofe Discusses Opposition to Commerce Nomination – John Bryson  – Senator Inhofe was on Fox Business Wed night discussing concerns regarding President Obama’s nomination of John Byrson to head the Department of Commerce. Read Inhofe’s statement on Bryson here.

WATCH: Fox News: Tough Road Ahead for Commerce Nominee Bryson

Reuters: Republican criticism of commerce nominee mounts – A top Senate Republican said on Tuesday he would fight President Barack Obama’s choice for commerce secretary, former energy executive John Bryson, whom he called an "environmental extremist." "The president has appointed someone who is going to make it harder and more expensive for the private sector to create jobs," said Senator John Barrasso, a member of the Senate Republican leadership. "Instead of appointing an economic leader, he has appointed an environmental extremist," Barrasso said.  He cited Bryson’s support for climate change legislation that failed to clear the Senate and his role in the founding of the National Resource Defense Council, a leading environmental group.

E &E News: Obama’s Commerce nominee draws flak over fisheries policy – East Coast lawmakers are questioning President Obama’s nomination of John Bryson for Commerce secretary, raising concerns that the former utility executive and environmental official will jeopardize efforts to improve what they say is the overregulation of the fishing industry. In a joint statement last week, Massachusetts Democratic Reps. Barney Frank and John Tierney pointed to Bryson’s ties to the Natural Resources Defense Council, the environmental nonprofit he helped found in 1970. The group, they said, "has reflexively attacked the fishing industry inaccurately and without any real environmental basis." "For the President to nominate someone for the position of Secretary of Commerce, without consultation with those of us most concerned with fairness for fishing, and for the NRDC membership to be listed as one of his major qualifications is troubling," they said.

Gloucester Times: Commerce pick raises fishing concerns – President Obama’s choice of an energy industry leader and founder of an environmental group active on fishing issues as his next U.S. Commerce Secretary was made without any consultation with fishing industry advocates, Congressmen John Tierney and Barney Frank say. And the two congressmen – who represent the core Massachusetts fishing ports of Gloucester and New Bedford, respectively – have urged Sens. John Kerry, Scott Brown and others not to confirm Bryson’s appointment "without … getting commitments that the fishing industry has a right to expect that they will be treated fairly if he is the secretary." In a statement released jointly last week, after Obama named John Bryson to succeed Gary Locke as head of Commerce Department, Democrats Tierney and Frank said they found the process disappointing. And they said citing Bryson’s background as a founder of the Natural Resources Defense Council as a qualification is "troubling."

Washington Examiner: Crony capitalist Bryson should be rejected at Commerce – Several weeks ago, determined Senate Republicans united with conscientious Democrats to defeat President Obama’s nomination of Berkeley Law School professor Goodwin Liu to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. As the first Obama judicial nominee to be defeated, the Liu confirmation battle could prove to be the high-water mark of Obama’s campaign to put radical left-wing activists in charge of as many federal courts, departments and agencies as possible. Liu failed because senators examined the professor’s writing and concluded that he would use the legal system whenever possible to expand federal authority into every nook and cranny of American life. Enough senators were sufficiently disturbed by the prospect that Liu fell eight votes short of the 60 required for confirmation. Now comes John Bryson, chairman, president and CEO of BrightSource Inc. and Obama’s pick to head the U.S. Department of Commerce. Despite White House efforts to portray Bryson as an innovative, creative business executive, he is actually, as The Washington Examiner’s Tim Carney made clear in yesterday’s edition, another in the long list of crony capitalists who share Obama’s belief that government should pick winners and losers in the economy. Success in the Obama-Bryson world doesn’t come from profitably providing needed goods and services to consumers at affordable prices. Rather, crony capitalists make it by cultivating the right political connections and manipulating government regulations to guarantee profits and limit competition. […] Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Okla., has vowed to block Bryson. His Senate colleagues would be wise to follow the Oklahoman’s lead.  

IBD: A Disaster At Commerce – The nominee for commerce secretary founded an anti-energy group and believes in redistribution of wealth to help poorer nations. At this rate, we’ll be one of them. If personnel is policy, there can be no better choice to help implement President Obama’s anti-growth energy policy and redistribution of wealth plans than his choice to be the next secretary of commerce, John Bryson. One would think that the former CEO of power company Edison International would have a more practical view of energy development and management. But he’s earned Rep. Darrell Issa’s description of him as a "green evangelist." Bryson also spent time as an environmental lawyer and co-founder of the National Resources Defense Council, perhaps the most anti-energy, anti-growth progressive group on the planet. He has served as an adviser on energy and climate issues to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon at a time when the U.N. was pushing anti-growth climate change treaties based on fraudulent and doctored data.

Wall Street Journal: Secretary of Subsidy – Fortunately for BrightSource, its efforts are sustained by an impressive array of federal, state and local subsidies, including a $1.6 billion loan guarantee from the Department of Energy, one of the largest solar guarantees on record. The company notes federal provisions providing solar projects with a 30% investment tax credit through 2016, as well as accelerated depreciations of capital costs for solar entities, among other goodies. The risk is that the subsidy spigot could someday be turned off as voters get wise to the high costs, economic inefficiencies and unintended environmental side-effects of renewables. That’s a possibility the filing acknowledges, though it adds brightly that it expects demand to "continue to increase as a result of regulatory policies and incentives put in place to reduce carbon dioxide emissions and improve energy security." As an example, it points to California legislation requiring retail energy sellers to "derive 33% of the energy they supply from renewable energy sources by 2020."  Which brings us back to the President’s praise for Mr. Bryson as an innovator. All technologies-including those connected to renewables-involve risk, and entrepreneurship means taking chances on innovation. But a core conceit of this Administration’s economic policy is that it can achieve better results if government allocates capital to favored companies rather than letting private markets do the job. The results so far have been as underwhelming as the current economic recovery. In nominating Mr. Bryson, Mr. Obama has chosen a man who would appear to believe wholeheartedly in this model of politicized investment. Senators might want to ask the nominee whether he represents a vision of "commerce" that bears any relation to what is supposed to happen in a free market.

Washington Examiner: Carney: At Commerce, A Private Hand in the Public Glove – President Obama’s choice to lead the Commerce Department is a revolving-door former regulator who has spent his private-sector career earning millions from government-granted monopolies that depend on subsidies for their profits. John Bryson was CEO of Southern California Edison; he’s a director at Boeing, Disney, and electric-car maker Coda Automotive; and he’s chairman of the board at solar energy giant BrightSource.  All of these businesses rely heavily on government subsidies and government protection. This is a virtue in the eyes of Obama, who said Bryson has "the expertise that will help us create new jobs and make America more competitive in the global economy." Bryson began his career by creating an environmental litigation group, the Natural Resources Defense Council. He parlayed this gig of suing governments and businesses into top appointments in the late 1970s from Gov. Jerry Brown. After a three-year stint as president of California’s Public Utility Commission, Bryson cashed out in 1984 to California’s largest public utility, Edison International, parent company of Southern California Edison. Edison’s CEO, Howard Allen, had handpicked Bryson, grooming him to take over the company, which he did in 1990. Running a regulated utility is pretty different from running any other sort of business: Bryson was operating a monopoly, protected by the government from competition, and with rates set by the government. Southern California Edison didn’t need to win over customers by improving its product or lowering prices. Instead, the company’s profits depended on its ability to persuade politicians and bureaucrats to approve its rate increases — not easy, for sure, but hardly the stuff of enterprise. Bryson’s other employers aren’t government-enforced monopolies, but they are clients of the corporate-welfare state.

ACU: Bryson Nomination Should Be Stopped  – The American Conservative Union called on conservatives in the Senate to oppose the nomination of John Bryson as Secretary of Commerce. ACU Chairman Al Cardenas said  it is "outrageous that a leading proponent of the job-killing cap and trade bill be put in charge of the agency tasked with helping American business create jobs." "The Natural Resources Defense Council, which Bryson co-founded, has worked for 40 years to impose mandates, expand government regulation and impose a national energy tax that has hurt small business and stifled job creation," Cardenas said.  "Putting John Bryson in charge of the Commerce Department is the dictionary definition of putting the fox in charge of the hen house." Cardenas also urged the Senate to look into Bryson’s revolving door career moves, including his stint as President of one of the California Public Utilities Commission, then leaving to become an executive and later CEO of the largest utilities under his jurisdiction, Southern California Edison, which later became Edison International. Cardenas praised Senator Jim Inhofe for publicly opposing the Bryson nomination and said ACU will activate its grassroots and social media networks to urge other Senate conservatives to join Inhofe to block confirmation.

Economist: Treehugging and Internationalism  – The choice of John Bryson to be Barack Obama’s second commerce secretary has not gone down well with a certain sort of Republican senator, who notes that he embodies two of their pet hates: tree hugging and internationalism. Not only did he co-found the Natural Resources Defence Council, a green lobby group, he sits on an anti-climate-change committee of the, shudder, United Nations. This may make even tougher what was shaping up to be a tricky Senate approval, given earlier talk that Republicans would try to block any appointment as commerce secretary until three agreed bilateral trade deals currently becalmed in Congress are ratified.

Daily Caller: Obama’s Commerce Nominee Comes with Green Past  – President Obama’s nominee for Commerce secretary, John Bryson, is good news for the environmental community and his nomination could foreshadow a renewed White House push for cap and trade. Bryson has a long history in the environmental community. He was one of the original co-founders of the Natural Resources Defense Council. From 1976 6o 1979, Bryson was chairman of the California State Water Resources Control Board. Then, from 1979 to 1982, he was president of the California Public Utilities Commission. After that, Bryson led the electric utility company Edison International, until his retirement in 2008. He was at the helm of the company when an energy crisis struck the state of California from 2000-2003. The crisis not only forced competitor PG&E into bankruptcy, it created a slew of political troubles for then-Democratic Gov. Gray Davis. Bryson was also present during the 2006 global warming meeting between then-Republican California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and then-British Prime Minister Tony Blair. The two leaders signed a deal to agree to work together to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and combat global warming.

NewsBusters: Obama’s Commerce Nominee: Cap and Trade Good for ‘Hiding’ Carbon Taxes  – John Bryson, President Obama’s nominee to head the Commerce Department, told a University of California Berkeley audience in 2010 that a cap and trade system was a good way to hide a carbon tax from the public. Bryson, formerly the CEO of Edison International, said that a carbon tax was the new "third rail" of politics because politicians wouldn’t want to tax energy directly. "I think it’s still unlikely there’ll be a carbon tax bill because I think in the end a very high percentage of the members of Congress think it’s kind of the third rail to support a tax, even if it’s a carbon tax," Bryson said. "Greenhouse gas legislation, either with a tax or with cap and trade – which is a more complicated way of getting at it but it has the advantage of politically sort of hiding the fact that you have a tax – but that’s what you’re trying to do," he added. Bryson said that carbon taxes – whether open or hidden in a cap and trade regime – were still not the best way to reduce energy consumption and greenhouse gasses. The best way, he said, was a robust system of regulations that penalized energy producers for producing more energy than the government deemed necessary. "In the great debate between economists and others about whether we ought to be proceeding primarily with market signals or regulatory steps, I believe we ought to do both," He said. "But the regulatory steps act right now [with] immediate requirements."

###