Despite calls from some in the environmental community to tighten particulate matter air quality standards under the Clean Air Act, a Congressional Research Service Report (CRS) from December 2005 stated that the EPA administrator has clear discretion in setting air quality standards.
FACT: In reviewing these standards, the Clean Air Act requires the EPA to review the science and set health standards at a level that ensures “an adequate margin of safety” requisite to protect human health. While individual studies vary, studies show that since 1997, when the last review was conducted by the Clinton administration, the health risk “point estimate” associated with particulate matter has decreased.
From page 4 of the December 30, 2005 CRS Report:
“…the [EPA] Administrator is given clear discretion; the requirements are conditioned by the phrase ‘in the judgment of the Administrator.”
Many have the impression that that EPA must or routinely strengthens air quality standards.
According to the 2005 CRS study, the EPA has only strengthened the standards twice out of the eleven times that they were reviewed since 1971 (including relaxing or revoking a standard on three occasions.)
From page 5 of the December 30, 2005 CRS Report:
“EPA has conducted multiple reviews of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards since their establishment in 1971. The primary (health based) standards have been strengthened twice, retained 6 times, and relaxed or revoked on 3 occasions.”