Fact of the Day: Wednesday, July 27, 2005 Summer Heat Fosters Warming Alarmism Once more, in the mid-summer heat, The New York Times editorialized yesterday on global warming (“A Few Degrees”). Citing high temperatures in the West and branding this summer the “summer of extremes,” the Times is attempting to capitalize on summer heat to frighten policymakers into action. Surprisingly, the Times actually admits there is no science to support its claims, only that there is no science to prove its views wrong: “It may not be possible to say that this heat wave or the drought that is afflicting Europe has been caused by global warming, especially when some of the records that fell recently were set many years ago. But it is also impossible to say that these temperature extremes are not part of the cumulative human impact on the climate.” Significant scientific uncertainties remain. Facts: Natural Cycles The latest heat wave in the West in not unusual and The New York Times is right to say there is no evidence to show global warming is occurring in the West. A Colorado state Climatologist Roger Pielke Sr. recently said in Denver’s Rocky Mountain News, “So we are in a heat wave right now, but we’re not in an unprecedented heat wave,” and “Denver is not getting hotter in the summer… .” In fact, a 2004 Times article, “Drought Settles In, Lake Shrinks and West’s Worries Grow,” essentially contradicts it’s own piece yesterday, stating “Those who worry most about the future of the West — politicians, scientists, business leaders, city planners and environmentalists — are increasingly realizing that a world of eternally blue skies and meager mountain snowpacks may not be a passing phenomenon but rather the return of a harsh climatic norm.” The Times also stated, “Continuing research into drought cycles over the last 800 years bears this out, strongly suggesting that the relatively wet weather across much of the West during the 20th century was a fluke. In other words, scientists who study tree rings and ocean temperatures say, the development of the modern urbanized West — one of the biggest growth spurts in the nation’s history — may have been based on a colossal miscalculation.” Natural climate cycles at work. Carbon Caps and Their Consequences The Times, even as it admits to the lack of science, still uses the most recent heat wave to scare the public and policymakers into capping carbon dioxide emissions. Ironically, it states that in times of severe temperatures, those who suffer most are the ones who cannot afford paying for energy resources. As they continue to push for mandatory caps on carbon dioxide emissions, the Times seems to forget the fact that it would be disadvantaged Americans, including senior citizens on fixed incomes, who would suffer the most from increased energy prices resulting from the costs associated with capping carbon emissions. As Senator Inhofe cautioned in June upon introducing his Ratepayers Protection Act, “We simply have to take into account the costs that are associated with efforts to reduce carbon emissions from the nation’s power plants.” Tom Mullen, president of Cleveland Catholic Charities, testified before the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee that the dramatic increases in energy prices resulting from carbon cap legislation would severely impact low-income families, especially poor children “as their moms are forced to make choices of whether to pay the rent or live in a shelter; pay the heating bill or see their child freeze; buy food or risk the availability of a hunger center.” A Few Hundredths of a Degree: All Cost and No Benefit The rejected McCain-Lieberman proposal would have cost American households an additional $810 a year, and more than one million jobs would have been lost. Electricity prices would have increased 20 percent. The Bingaman amendment, which was not introduced due to a lack of support from all sides, would have cost taxpayers $27 billion annually. Those proposals would have virtually no impact in reducing temperatures – not even by one-tenth of a degree. Assuming for the sake of argument that climate change alarmists are correct: – McCain-Lieberman would have averted only 0.029ºC in temperature. -The Bingaman proposal would have averted a miniscule 0.008oC.