I want to begin by thanking Chairman Boxer and Chairman Harkin for convening this hearing today. The chemical industry is incredibly important not only to my home state of Louisiana but to our nation as a whole. Before I continue on with my statement I would like to note that today Senator Inhofe and I sent a letter to our EPA witness on this very subject, and I would like to enter it into the record. [Click here to read the letter.]

When tragic accidents like the explosions in Geismar or Donaldsonville, LA, take place, it is critically important that they are thoroughly and expeditiously investigated. Genuine effort must be put forth to understand their causes, and we must strive to prevent similar accidents in the future.

Immediately following the explosion in Geismar, I requested the Chemical Safety Board dispatch a team to Louisiana, and I have appreciated their work and updates on the investigation.

It is no secret that chemical manufacturers spend billions of dollars annually in safety, health, environmental, and security programs through initiatives like American Chemistry Council’s Responsible Care. Others in the regulated community have initiatives like the fertilizer industry which just this week launched their ResponsibleAg program aimed at improving safety and security within their industry.

Despite these important initiatives, nothing comes without risk, and accidents unfortunately happen. Whenever these tragic incidents occur, it reminds us all that we must collaborate to achieve real improvements that will better protect our local communities, citizens, and workers.

Today we are here to discuss President Obama’s Executive Order 13650, "Improving Chemical Facility Safety and Security." Unfortunately, I believe that many of the actions being contemplated as part of this order may actually result in outcomes contrary to our collective goals, and more specifically may result in less compliance with the law and less safety at these already highly regulated facilities.

To quote a previous Committee witness who testified on this very issue, Rick Webre from the Ascension Parish Office of Homeland Security, "I cannot emphasize enough that all disasters are initially local." In Louisiana, we are fortunate to have robust Local Emergency Planning Committees which Mr. Webre called "the most critical function that a community can perform to prevent, mitigate, and respond to and recover from an industrial accident."

I believe that before we rush to create new complicated federal mandates, which in many cases can create more problems than they fix, we need to better understand what problems we are trying to solve and make sure we are giving folks within local communities the tools to ensure local safety.

Given that a great deal of our Committee discussions have centered around ammonium nitrate, I want to reference a May report from the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office on chemical safety which made clear unless OSHA takes additional action to "promote awareness of how to comply with its regulations, fertilizer facilities may not know whether their practices are in compliance with OSHA’s existing ammonium nitrate storage regulations."

The report goes on to say that although OSHA already has requirements for safely storing ammonium nitrate, "OSHA has done little to ensure that the fertilizer industry, which is one of the primary users of ammonium nitrate, understands how to comply with its existing regulations."

Today we see a stark contrast in the way the two Agencies testifying before us are carrying out their respective rulemakings pursuant to the President’s Order. While OSHA is taking a deliberative approach, allowing reasonable time for input, and planning to convene a panel to comprehend their rules on small business, EPA’s process is noticeably different. EPA set an arbitrarily short deadline on itself, asked for responses to close to 400 complex questions in an unreasonably short period of time, and denied an extension request seeking a more appropriate timeframe. EPA also does not appear to be willing or interested in a small business review, seeking advice through a Clean Air Act Advisory Committee panel, or convening a committee of experts under the Federal Advisory Committee Act. These differences are particularly troubling when you consider the agencies and their rules are directed by the Executive Order to coordinate and be harmonized.

Ensuring the citizens, workers, and communities across Louisiana and the nation are protected from industrial accidents of all kinds should always be a top priority and based on considerate information from what we’ve learned, and I hope today this hearing helps us take a positive step in the right direction. Thank you again to both Chairmen for holding this important hearing, and I look forward to hearing from the witnesses.

 

-30-