Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News…

The Wall Street Journal

Editorial: Here Comes the Regulatory Flood

Costly rules held up
for the election are about to roll over the economy.

Link to Editorial

President Obama’s hyperactive regulators went on hiatus in
2011 to get through Election Day. Now with his second term secure, they’re
about to make up for lost time and then some.

The government defines "economically significant"
rules as those that impose annual costs of $100 million or more, and the Bush,
Clinton and Bush Administrations each ended up finalizing about 45 major rules
per year. The average over Mr. Obama’s first two years was 63 but then plunged
to 44 for 2011 and 2012 so far. The bureaucracies didn’t slow down. They merely
postponed and built up a backlog that is about to hit the Federal Register.

We’d report the costs of the major-rule pipeline if we had
current data. But the White House budget office document known as the unified
agenda that reveals the regulations under development hasn’t been published
since fall 2011. The delay violates multiple federal laws and executive orders
that require an agenda every six months, so we thought readers might like a
rough guide to the regulatory flood that is about to roll through the economy.

• Health care. It begins with the Affordable Care Act, which
has been in hibernation because it was the largest campaign liability. Since
Election Day, the Health and Human Services Department has submitted a raft of
key health rules for White House review that it has been sitting on for months.

Hiding the details paid off politically but also undermined
ObamaCare’s already slim prospects for success. Ahead of the law’s go-live date
of October 2013, states and industries will have less than a year to prepare to
meet the new mandates.

Three of the rules were released right before Thanksgiving,
so insurers are only now about to learn how they’ll design and price coverage,
since one new rule defines "essential benefits" they must include.
Another deals with limits on how premiums can vary from person to person based
on risk.

The most important void is ObamaCare’s
"exchanges," the clearinghouses where millions of individuals and
small business will receive subsidized coverage. HHS hasn’t said how they must
be set up and function in practice, with the exception of "guidance"
documents that make vague suggestions but don’t have the force of law and are
likely to be revoked. HHS is all but begging states to run the exchanges but
hasn’t clarified what they’d be signing up for.

Amid opposition from most of the 30 Republican Governors,
many of whom are telling the feds to run an exchange on their behalf, HHS also
hasn’t laid out how this federal fallback will work. Other complex rule-makings
will decide who is eligible for the exchanges, how Medicaid rules will change
after the Supreme Court’s ObamaCare ruling, and the future of Medicare
Advantage’s private coverage options.

• Financial services. According to a Davis-Polk analysis,
only 133 or 33.4% of the 398 rule-makings the law firm estimates Dodd-Frank
requires have been finalized. The law is ambiguous and other reviews suggest
the figure could be closer to 500. As of November 1, some 132 rules haven’t
even been proposed, while the government has failed to meet 61% (or 144) of
Dodd-Frank’s legal deadlines.

Regulators are now finalizing rules on bank stress testing
and capital and margin rules for the swaps markets, but there are still many
costly items on the to-do list. Major uncertainty comes from the rolling
exercise to determine which businesses are "systemically important,"
aside from the largest banks that have already been designated as too big to
fail. This review never ends.

Also on the docket is an effort to define "qualified
mortgages," which will change lending and capital standards. Elizabeth Warren’s
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, having been invested with unaccountable
powers, will now decide what financial products and services are
"abusive," a political term of art with no legal meaning. Then there
is the pending Volcker Rule to limit proprietary trading at big banks, whose
draft ran to 298 pages and asked 1,347 questions.

• Energy. In the lead-up to November, the Environmental
Protection Agency stood down under White House pressure, delaying rules for
ozone air quality and industrial boilers, and deferring carbon standards. Now
EPA chief Lisa Jackson has the run of the place.

She will resume the Administration’s anti-carbon agenda
through "new source performance standards," which will set greenhouse
gas emissions for new power plants so low as to prevent their construction.
Look for this early in 2013.

She’ll follow with standards for "existing"
sources that make coal-fired plants uneconomic to run. Inside of a decade, Ms.
Jackson may wipe out what used to make up more than half of U.S. power
generation. Environmentalists will write books about it, even if her agenda has
received almost no public scrutiny or debate.

The oil and gas industry is also targeted, hydraulic
fracturing (fracking) in particular. The EPA has already issued a rule on shale
production emissions and has one coming on diesel fuel in fracking. The
Interior Department is promulgating rules on fracking on federal lands, and
other rules can’t be far behind, probably using the pretext of drinking water
under the Clean Water Act.

The EPA’s sleeper issue is the National Enforcement
Initiatives agenda, which is designed to use the agency’s existing legal powers
for inspections, requests for information, penalties and so forth to make new
de facto rules. The EPA now blackmails businesses into "super
compliance," or settlements far more stringent than the law requires, or
else risk years of expensive litigation.

• Economic potpourri. The National Labor Relations Board,
the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Occupational Safety and Health
Administration and the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs are
teaming up to rewrite employment, labor and workplace law. The FCC and the FTC
are doing the same for the tech industry and Silicon Valley via investigations,
audits and "oversight." The Agriculture Department is going after
"illegally harvested plants." The Consumer Product Safety Commission
has its eyes on . . . table saws.

***

Having come close to losing re-election because of a weak
economy, Mr. Obama now keeps saying "our top priority has to be jobs and
growth." This new regulatory flood will increase costs and uncertainty and
make that priority that much harder to achieve.