Sen.
David Vitter (R-La.), top Republican on the Environment and Public Works (EPW)
Committee, has launched the second phase of his investigation into the
collusion between environmental activists, lawyers and lobbyists, billionaires
and their supporting foundations who use large sums of money to influence
environmental public policy.
From
farmers to miners to rig workers to manufacturers and fishermen, EPW
Republicans have been examining how the jobs in those industries and their way
of life are being targeted by well-funded environmental activists whose primary
goal is maximizing government control, particularly over the land, water, and
resources utilized by private industries and individuals. Today’s focus is on
manufacturing.
The
U.S. manufacturing industry supports over 17 million jobs in the United States,
and taken alone it would be the 10th largest economy in the world.[1] American manufacturing is tied
closely to the health of the middle class, providing high-paying jobs in the
areas of the country that need them most. [2]
Unfortunately, since 2000, American manufacturing has lost 5.8 million jobs.[3] While members across the
political spectrum agree that a reinvigorated manufacturing sector would help
the middle class, there is a major disconnect between this goal and the
policies of the Obama Administration and far-left environmental groups that
make it more difficult to secure better paying and more middle class jobs.[4] A Louisiana petroleum engineer
recently summed up this intellectual discrepancy, explaining, "There’s a huge
disconnect between quality of life and opposition to the oil and gas industry."[5]
Since
2010, the manufacturing industry has only been able to hire back 526,000
employees,[6] many of which are directly
attributable to the shale gas revolution.[7]
Despite the vast economic and job creation benefits of shale gas, those on the
far-left view cheap natural gas as a threat to their policy goals of limiting
fossil fuel production and forcing an increase in the use of their preferred
and more expensive energy sources, like solar and wind. Harvard Professor
Samuel Myers, a close contemporary of former EPA regional administrator James
Martin and other far-left environmentalists, made this anti-natural gas
sentiment clear when he stated, "I suspect that cheap gas is just what we don’t
want because it will make it very hard for renewables to compete and then the
entirely wrong price signal to anyone thinking in alternative energy
technologies. I think what we want is expensive gas and a ban on coal
fired power."[8]
Choosing
Climate Policy Over Economic Growth
"Responding
to climate change requires that we break every rule in the free-market playbook
and that we do so with great urgency. We will need to rebuild the public
sphere, reverse privatizations, relocalize large parts of economies, scale back
overconsumption, bring back long-term planning, heavily regulate and tax
corporations, maybe even nationalize some of them, cut military spending and
recognize our debts to the global South."[9] – Naomi Klein, 2011.
Working
hand-in-glove with the Obama Administration, far-left environmental
organizations are laboring to implement policies that obstruct growth of the
manufacturing sector, block domestic natural gas production, and shrink the
economy,[10] while simultaneously
expanding federal government control. According to Naomi Klein, a poster
child of the far-left environmental movement and frequent recipient of grants
from the Billionaire’s Club,[11] we must choose between a strong
economy and combating climate change. In 2011 she said, "There is a
growing body of economic research on the conflict between economic growth and
sound climate policy." Referring to attendees of the Heartland Institute’s
Sixth International Conference on Climate Change, she drove the point home: "So
when the Heartlanders react to evidence of human-induced climate change as if
capitalism itself were coming under threat, it’s not because they are paranoid.
It’s because they are paying attention."[12]
These views were recently echoed in a 350.org video, which promotes the idea of
"planet before profit."[13]
Expanding
Federal Authority with Over-Regulation
One
of the principal tools intended to be utilized to shut down the manufacturing
industry is regulation via the Clean Air Act (CAA). The CAA is
responsible for the many successes we have seen in the last forty years,
including major reductions in dangerous pollutants.[14] Despite these broadly
supported successes, the EPA is now attempting to dramatically expand its
regulatory authority with increasingly superficial benefits claims, while
ignoring significant costs.[15] The
climate benefits in EPA’s CO2 regulations (as called for in the President’s
Climate Action Plan) are calculated using the Social Cost of Carbon estimates
that were developed behind closed doors by a select group of unelected
Washington bureaucrats at the urging of the environmental left.[16] Outside groups, like the
Energy Foundation and Merck Family Fund – both members of the Billionaire’s
Club, use their resources to support EPA’s absurd "benefits" in analytic
reports and national lobbying campaigns.[17]
Another
tactic to expand federal regulation is known as the "sue and settle"
method. A precedential "sue and settle" arrangement occurred between the
EPA and the American Lung Association (ALA) over the 1990 Amendments of the
Clean Air Act.[18] The settlement
agreement led to expediting the first particulate (PM) and ozone standards,
which make manufacturing more expensive. Since the initial standard was
put in place, the supposed benefits of that standard have been used to justify
the multitude of additional air regulations over the past twenty years.[19] Unfortunately, EPA continues
to refuse to make the underlying data public,[20]
and so there is no way to independently verify the benefits claims.[21]
The
potential impacts of a lower ozone standard include a reduction in GDP of $270
billion per year and lost jobs averaging 2.9 million per year. In
addition, a lower ozone standard will result in increased natural gas and
electricity costs for manufacturers and American families.[22] In close coordination with the
EPA, the ALA has helped coordinate EPA’s rollout of PM benefits claims as well
as responses to litigation in an effort to clamp down on energy production.[23] The many regulations that are
now set to shut down coal fired power plants[24]
go well beyond the EPA’s original claims.[25]
In spite of all these negative consequences of EPA’s activities, the looming
ozone standards are likely to have the most significant impact on
manufacturing.[26]
Targeting
Successful Technologies
Despite
the significant headwinds of EPA’s regulatory prowess and the persistent
litigation by wealthy environmental activists, advances in two drilling
technologies have significantly undermined their anti-manufacturing agenda.[27] Hydraulic fracturing and
horizontal drilling have made it possible to advance access to abundant
domestic energy resources that were otherwise inaccessible just a few years
ago.[28] Accordingly, the United States
is seeing a resource boom that is working to lower domestic fossil energy
prices, which benefits manufacturing. In addition to lower energy prices,
domestic fossil fuel production is providing an abundance of the base materials
that are needed to manufacture every important product that our modern society
makes and utilizes. Every iPad, computer, television, and automobile in
use today and every piece of advanced medical equipment that is saving lives is
made from materials that are mined, refined, and/or manufactured from or
utilizing fossil resources.[29]
Even solar panels and wind turbines include products made from fossil fuels.[30]
At
the end of the day, the EPA and their environmental allies[31] recognize the success of these
technologies and have big plans for over-regulation and limiting access to the
domestic oil and gas resources that fuel the manufacturing sector.
Looming regulations coming from EPA and litigation by its allies are clearly targeted
at undermining advanced drilling technologies, and as a consequence, our
manufacturing sector and middle class are in the cross hairs.
Accordingly, the coordinated war on hydraulic fracturing is also undermining
the U.S. manufacturing industry.[32]
EPW
Republicans have been detailing exactly how these coordinated efforts are
destroying jobs and punishing industries and families across America. Previous
editions include:
-
Collusion
& Coordination to Shut Down the Oil & Gas Industry -
Environmental
Collusion Attempts to Shutout Public Fishing -
Environmental
Litigation to Shut Down Forestry Projects -
Environmental
Lobbying to Shut Down One Nuclear Power Plant at a Time -
Environmental
Collusion to Block Mining: Sue Early, Often, and At Every Step -
Environmental
Attacks on American Family Farmers: The Dual Threat
-30-
[1] http://www.nam.org/~/media/AF4039988F9241C09218152A709CD06D.ashx
[2] http://www.manufacturing.net/articles/2014/03/manufacturing-the-decline-of-the-middle-class
[3] Id.
[4]
http://www.ajc.com/news/business/report-manufacturing-key-to-middle-class-health/ngK2r/
[5]
http://www.nola.com/politics/index.ssf/2014/07/helis_oil_talks_about_st_tamma.html
[6] Id.
[7] http://www.investing.com/analysis/u.s.-manufacturing-renaissance-finally-happening-227257
[8] https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/ALAemails.pdf
[9] http://www.thenation.com/article/164497/capitalism-vs-climate?page=0,0
[10] http://washingtonexaminer.com/how-camouflaged-activists-want-to-de-industrialize-the-west/article/2554201
[11]
Rockefeller Brothers Fund IRS Form 990, 2011; Wallace Global Fund IRS Form 990,
2011; Schmidt Family Foundation IRS Form 990, 2011, 2012.
[12] http://www.thenation.com/article/164497/capitalism-vs-climate?page=0,0
[13] http://350.org/a-new-economic-paradigm-is-not-only-possible-but-plausible/
[14] http://www.epa.gov/air/caa/progress.html
[15]
http://science.house.gov/press-release/icymi-tceq-criticism-epa-air-pollution-science;
http://www.regulations.gov/#%21documentDetail;D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2007-0492-9522
[16] http://www.nrdc.org/media/2012/120917.asp
[17] http://www.analysisgroup.com/uploadedFiles/Publishing/Articles/Analysis_Group_EPA_Clean_Power_Plan_Report.pdf
[18] http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=8C1A4F79-ECA0-F9D2-9636-B7286F3389A5
[19] https://www.uschamber.com/blog/these-9-charts-put-federal-regulations-different-light
[20] http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=28FBCAF8-BFE1-6D91-5EC8-DA554F9FA85F
[21] Id.
[22] http://www.nam.org/~/media/29876087653A4D74BFE191551FC024EC.ashx
[23] https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/ALAemails.pdf
[24] http://www.epa.gov/ttn/atw/utility/utilitypg.html
[25] http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-14-672
[26] http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=03ca1d5b-0f78-f77b-00d1-2dd279fc6db7&Region_id=&Issue_id=
[27] http://energyindepth.org/national/hydraulic-fracturing-good-news-for-americas-economy/
[28] http://www.ncsl.org/documents/energy/frackingguide_060512.pdf
[29] http://www-tc.pbs.org/independentlens/classroom/wwo/petroleum.pdf
[30] Id.
[31] http://washingtonexaminer.com/the-hidden-persuaders-of-the-environmental-elite/article/2551714
[32] http://capitolcityproject.com/meet-group-quietly-propelling-anti-fracking-movement/