Lifting the Veil
of Secrecy
Following
the nomination hearing for Gina McCarthy to lead the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), the EPW Republican Senators reiterated five concerns
they have with the agency and the expected responses, in order to ensure that
transparency is more than a buzzword. The Senators hope to restore public
confidence that EPA will stop undermining public trust behind a veil of
secrecy.
EPA’s
Inconsistent E-mail Practices and Policies
Transparency Request #2: Release exchanges in which private
e-mail accounts were used to conduct official business
Thus
far, EPA officials have responded to the Senators’
request
piece-by-piece, which demonstrates a necessary first-step for the Agency to
move toward appropriate and consistent e-mail practices and policies.
The Committee has demonstrated that EPA
officials routinely and repeatedly violate internal policy that forbids the use
of non-official e-mail accounts to conduct official agency business. This
practice has serious consequences as such behavior increases the likelihood
that the Agency and its employees violate the Federal Records Act and the
Freedom of Information Act. The medium used to communicate is
inconsequential to these transparency statutes – if the content of the email
qualifies as a federal record, then the email is a federal record and should be
treated and preserved as such. The law similarly applies to all
communications regardless of whether the communication occurred on a government
email account, a private account, in a text message or through instant
messaging. However, because EPA officials use their non-official email
accounts to conduct agency business, EPA officials responsible for ensuring
that all employees comply with the law experience much more difficulty ensuring
such compliance. Moreover, private email accounts do not have the same
security features as government accounts, so the information is not necessarily
protected if sent or received on a private account.
EPA has been on notice that they are on
the verge of federal records violations since 2008. After reviewing EPA’s
records management practices in 2008, the GAO informed EPA that the Agency
needed to develop clear and consistent guidance with regard to nongovernmental
email use.[1] Such a policy is necessary to
ensure that any covered agency activity would still be properly
preserved. In response, EPA stated that it, "has not provided formal
instructions to staff on the use of secondary accounts to conduct Agency
business, rather, EPA has a clear and consistent policy framework against the
use of nongovernmental e-mail systems for official EPA business.[2] This policy is contained in several
documents; including briefings to high-level staff when they are hired,[3] email communications reminding employees
to not use their private accounts to conduct agency business,[4] as well as the Agency’s "Frequent
Questions about E-Mail and Records" webpage.[5]
Yet, despite the law and EPA’s policy
against using private email, the Committee has demonstrated that high-level
employees use their private email for work purposes, possibly to evade federal
transparency laws. The most flagrant example uncovered by the Committee
was the practice of former Region 8 Administrator James B. Martin.[6] When the Committee first
questioned Martin on his use of his personal email account, EPA quickly
responded with a denial: "As detailed in public
filings, the regional administrator does not use his personal mail account to
conduct official business….That Mr. Martin responded to one email sent to his
personal email account to confirm a meeting that appears on his official
government calendar does not alter that fact."[7]
Contrary to EPA’s defense of Mr.
Martin’s email practices, the Committee revealed that Mr. Martin regularly
corresponded with individuals and groups outside EPA regarding agency
business. For example, Mr. Martin communicated with General Counsel of
the Environmental Defense Fund, Vickie Patton about Agency activity.[8] However, despite EPA’s original
denial, it appears that EPA officials had knowledge of Mr. Martin’s use of
personal email to conduct agency business. On April 11, 2012, Mr. Martin
forwarded Jose Lozano, EPA’s Deputy Chief of Staff, an email containing a
conversation between Martin and Alan Salazar, Chief Strategy Officer for
Governor Hickenlooper, seeking to arrange an event for Administrator Jackson.[9] Accordingly, EPA’s failure to
develop a comprehensive and effective policy on email use has created a means
of conducting business where EPA employees can collude with their allies off
line and avoid the transparency requirements of the law.
In
addition to Mr. Martin, the Committee has also obtained evidence that Region 9
Administrator Jared Blumenfeld has used his private email account (@Comcast.net)
for work purposes.[10] Ranking
Member Vitter and Chairman Issa sent Mr. Blumenfeld a letter asking for his
cooperation in identifying federal records from his private account.[11] Instead of cooperating with
this request, EPA headquarters replied on Mr. Blumenfeld’s behalf, once again
indicating that there was no problem with Mr. Blumenfeld’s behavior.[12] In fact – when the media
questioned EPA about Mr. Blumenfeld’s email practices, EPA responded that, "There’s
nothing wrong with this."[13]
Moreover,
in review of the limited document production released pursuant to the Richard
Windsor FOIA request, the Committee has discovered that Acting Administrator Perciasepe,
Associate Administrator Arvin Ganeson and former Deputy General Counsel Tseming
Yang have also used their private email for work purposes.
Finally, it has
recently come to the Committee’s attention that EPA encourages the use of
instant messaging via platforms like "Sametime Connect," "G-Chat," and, AOL
Instant Messenger to communicate with individuals outside the agency.[14] While EPA policy
explicitly states that content on IM’s can be considered federal records[15], the Committee is not aware of a
single circumstance where EPA has released such a message in response to a FOIA
or Congressional request. While Acting Administrator Perciasepe has
encourage the Inspector General to focus on potential problems relating to
EPA’s treatment of IM’s[16],
this merely acknowledges the problem, but provides no solution.
Without the
dedicated cooperation of EPA, it is impossible to determine the scope of these
record keeping problems. We know that EPA employees are using their
private email accounts and IM’s to conduct Agency business. However, we
don’t know how this information is being captured or preserved.
Therefore, it is imperative that EPA recognize the consequences of such
practices and that they must take corrective steps to ensure all Agency
business in conducted in compliance with the letter of the law.
-30-
[1]
June 2008 GAO Report Federal Records: National Archives and Selected
Agencies Need to Strengthen E-Mail Management, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[2]
Id., appendix III (2008 GAO Report on EPA Records Management)
[3]
2009 Powerpoint EPA Records and ECMS Briefing: EPA Incoming Political
Appointees, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[4]
NRMP Alert: Do Not Use Outside Email Systems to Conduct Agency Business,
https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[5]
EPA Website FAQ about E-Mail and Records, http://www.epa.gov/records/faqs/email.htm#q1
[6]
January 29, 2013 Press Release: Vitter, Issa Investigate EPA’s Transparency
Problem, More Suspicious E-mail Accounts, http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=872aba41-b894-3fb4-45da-a85dc30a87b3
[7]
CJ Ciaramella, EPA Official Resigns, WASHINGTON FREE BEACON (Feb. 19,
2013, 3:30 PM), http://freebeacon.com/epa-official-resigns/.
[8]
May 2012 Emails between Vicki Patton and Regional Administrator James Martin, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[9]
April 2012 Emails between Jose Lozano and Regional Administrator James Martin, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[10]
March 19, 2013, Press Release: Vitter, Issa Question EPA Region 9
Administrator on Personal Email Use, http://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/press-releases-all?ID=8311f916-0582-7f13-d6ff-ece347aed24e
[11]
March 18, 2013, Letter from Sen. Vitter, Rep. Issa to Region 9 Administrator, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[12]
April 9, 2013, EPA response to Sen. Vitter, Rep. Issa March 18, 2013 letter, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[13] Erica Martinson, EPA
on Vitter, Issa email probe: This is how email works, Politico Pro (Mar. 19, 2013, 12:17:47
PM), https://www.politicopro.com/tipsheet/energy/?id=4130;
see e.g. CJ Ciaramella, Windsor Knot Tightens Another EPA official
using private email, The Washington
Free Beacon (Feb. 26, 2013), http://freebeacon.com/windsor-knot-tightens/.
[14]
2010 EPA Powerpoint Web Collaboration Tools WWG 2010, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf
[15]
National Archives FAQ about Instant Messaging, http://www.archives.gov/records-mgmt/initiatives/im-faq.html
[16]
April 2013 EPA Acting Administrator Perciasepe letter to EPA employees, https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/R8_JoseLozano.pdf