Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

EPW POLICY BEAT: PROTESTING TOO MUCH

Player Queen: Both here and hence pursue me lasting strife,

If once I be a widow, ever I be a wife!

Player King: ‘Tis deeply sworn. Sweet, leave me here a while,

My spirits grow dull, and fain I would beguile

The tedious day with sleep.

Player Queen: Sleep rock thy brain,

And never come mischance between us twain!

Hamlet: Madam, how like you this play?

Queen: The lady doth protest too much, methinks.

Shakespeare: Hamlet, Act 3, Scene 2

As its authors are quick to note, the Kerry-Boxer bill is about jobs.  It’s about putting "millions of people back to work," as one sponsor claimed.  It will "create good-paying jobs in every region of the country."  And it will create, according to one study, 1.9 million new jobs.  Such elaborate claims, repeated at every turn, raise suspicion: why are the authors of a massive new energy tax obsessed with jobs?  Why are they, in a word, "protesting too much"?  One need only read Kerry-Boxer to find the answer.

In Section 311, titled "Climate Change Worker Adjustment Assistance," the authors clearly admit the bill will put people out of work.  The bill provides "adjustment assistance" to workers who have been "adversely affected" by the bill’s mandates, which will cause higher energy prices, fewer jobs, and slow the economy.  In other words, we’ll sack your job, and then put you on green welfare.  Not exactly the best recipe for putting "millions of people back to work."  

Under the bill, workers from the "energy-intensive manufacturing" sector, among many others, can get federal assistance if the Secretary of Labor determines that "a significant number or proportion of the workers in such workers’ employment site have become totally or partially separated, or are threatened to become totally or partially separated from employment" because of Kerry-Boxer.  Workers can also get handouts if "sales, production, or delivery of goods or services have decreased" as a result of "any requirement" of Kerry-Boxer. 

Kerry-Boxer’s victims can get up to 2 years of assistance, which includes 70 percent of a worker’s average weekly wage (which cannot "exceed the average weekly wage for all workers in the state where the adversely affected worker resides").  One would think it better to maintain industrial manufacturing jobs, and create more of them through affordable energy and strong economic growth-neither of which, incidentally, would happen under cap-and-trade.

A lot of workers will be eligible for Kerry-Boxer’s job killing largesse.  The National Black Chamber of Commerce found that Waxman-Markey, similar in many respects to Kerry-Boxer (in fact, it’s fair to say Kerry-Boxer is more stringent than Waxman-Markey), would destroy over 2 million jobs. 

So all the jobs talk reveals what Kerry-Boxer supporters seem to know: their bill will destroy jobs, as the bill itself proves, yet they insist "green jobs" will make up the difference.  But the National Black Chamber of Commerce is clear on this point: cap-and-trade would lead to "green jobs" in energy efficiency and renewable energy,  yet "any calculation of jobs created in these activities is incomplete if not supplemented with a calculation of the reduced employment in other industries and the decline in the average salary that would result from the associated higher energy costs and lower overall productivity in the economy."  Thus, "even after accounting for green jobs, there is a substantial and long-term net reduction in total labor earnings and employment. "

The Black Chamber finds that this is an "unintended but predictable consequence" of cap-and-trade.  Creating green jobs through the private sector is fine, indeed good, but we can create them without a massive new tax on the economy.  That’s what Kerry-Boxer is.  So the next time you hear Kerry-Boxer supporters talking about jobs, which you inevitably will, remember: they need to talk about jobs because their bill destroys them.

Related:

Link to Study from National Black Chamber of Commerce

Wash. Post – In Michigan, A Yellow Light For Green Jobs

Inhofe-Bond Issue Warning on Green Jobs

Boxer Says Goal is to "Soften the Blow"

EPW POLICY BEAT: BROKEN WINDOWS AND GREEN JOBS

CBO Report on Cap-and-Tax Bill: Higher Taxes, Lost Jobs, Lower Wages

EPW FACT OF THE DAY: GREEN DYSTOPIA

###