Sen.
David Vitter (R-La.), top Republican on the Environment and Public Works (EPW)
Committee, has launched the second phase of his investigation into the
collusion between environmental activists, lawyers and lobbyists, billionaires
and their supporting foundations who use large sums of money to influence
environmental public policy.
From
farmers to miners to rig workers to manufacturers and fishermen, EPW
Republicans have been examining how the jobs in those industries and their way
of life are being targeted by well-funded environmental activists whose primary
goal is maximizing government control, particularly over the land, water, and
resources utilized by private industries and individuals. Today’s focus
is on farming.
American
farmers have been a dependable source of food and jobs throughout our nation’s
history.[1] Their entrepreneurship,
ingenuity, and good old-fashioned hard work have given rise to a reliable food
supply.[2] As the world experiences
significant population growth and the global demand for food increases, farmers
in the United States will play an integral role in keeping the world well-fed.[3]
However,
endless litigation and regulation threaten the long-term viability of the
American family farm.[4]
Hostile environmental groups are teaming up with regulatory agencies under the
guise of environmentalism, stewardship, and conservation. Yet the reality
is that these efforts are an unprecedented regulatory assault to impair the
agriculture industry, directed and controlled by the far-left political agenda
of the Billionaire’s Club.
Litigation
Nation
Far-left
environmental organizations are using litigation as a key strategy to target
farmers. They use the courts to shut down water supply, to diminish
property rights, and to limit the use of crop protectors.
In
California, these groups have made serious drought conditions worse by
fostering a regulatory drought that pits farmers against fish.[5] The Natural Resources Defense
Council (NRDC) has repeatedly invoked the Endangered Species Act (ESA) to shut
down water deliveries to Central Valley farmers with claims[6]
that a two-inch bait fish known as the delta smelt must take priority
over the needs of humans and irrigated agriculture. Forced
by this litigation to locate alternative water supplies, farmers have turned to
groundwater. Unfortunately, the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s
Association, Environmental Law Foundation, and the Institute for Fisheries
Resources have banded together[7] to
encumber access to groundwater, leaving California farmers with few options for
water delivery.[8]
The
battle against American family farmers spans across the U.S. In Maryland,
the Waterkeeper Alliance, an entity funded by the Billionaire’s Club, sued a
family-run chicken farm over disposal of
chicken manure,
threatening the farmers with exorbitant fines and penalties under the Clean
Water Act (CWA). As the ultimately unsuccessful litigation proceeded, it
became clear that Waterkeeper’s motivation behind the lawsuit was to use the
CWA to force poultry farmers "to seriously alter if not abandon their
operations on the Eastern Shore." [9]
The lawsuit made clear that "an elite, New York-based group that regularly held
fund-raisers at ski resorts and counted Kennedy-friendly celebrities among its
membership"[10] would go to great
lengths to shut down a hard-working family farm.
NRDC
and Waterkeeper Alliance are heavily beholden to the Billionaire’s Club.
NRDC depends on millions of dollars in grants that flow from Climateworks
Foundation, David and Lucile Packard Foundation, Energy Foundation, Gordon and
Betty Moore Foundation, Marisla Foundation, Park Foundation, Rockefeller
Brothers Fund, Rockefeller Family Fund, Schmidt Foundation, Sea Change
Foundation, William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, and Tides Foundation.[11] In recent years, Waterkeeper
Alliance received support from Park Foundation, Energy Foundation, and the
Marisla Foundation.[12]
Allies
in the Administration
Far-left
environmental groups also count on allies in the Obama Administration to
implement regulations that devastate the agricultural community. EPA’s
regulation of agricultural activities has spiked since President Obama took
office.[13] What’s more, this trend of
aggressive EPA regulation shows no signs of slowing.
The
EPA’s proposed Waters of the United States rule would greatly expand the scope
of the federal government’s authority over farmers and other land users under
the Clean Water Act. It increases federal permitting requirements and
exposes American farmers to costly citizen suit liability. As such, it’s not
surprising that the proposal has support from the NRDC, Sierra Club, the
Waterkeeper Alliance, and Organizing for
Action.
Additionally,
in 2011, EPA issued a controversial regulation known as a "Total Maximum Daily
Load" (TMDL), which threatens farms throughout the Chesapeake Bay region by
allowing EPA to determine whether particular lands can be farmed or developed,
as well as the amount of fertilizer farmers can use.[14] EPA’s TMDL has strong support
from the Gulf Restoration Network.[15]
The
regulation could set a precedent allowing EPA to control land-use decisions
throughout the country.[16] The
Gulf Restoration Network, Sierra Club, NRDC, and again Waterkeeper Alliance,
have adopted a similar strategy to establish a TMDL for the Mississippi River
watershed – which covers 30 states.[17]
If the petition is successful, it would cripple agriculture through the
Mississippi River basin, putting farmers at the mercy of EPA-developed water
quality measures and ignoring the agriculture community’s actions to improve
the environment.[18]
The
cozy relationship between these far-left environmental groups and the Obama
Administration has also called into question the EPA’s interest and ability to
protect the private information of American farmers. In 2013, EPA
released confidential and private business information of animal feeding
operations to Earthjustice, Pew Charitable Trusts, and the NRDC.[19] Despite this breach of
privacy, Nancy Stoner, then-acting Assistant Administrator for EPA’s Office of
Water and former head of NRDC’s Water Program, defended the Agency, claiming
the information "released, was all publicly available, either through a
publicly accessible database or through a public records request to each
state."[20] The groups later claimed to
have returned farmers’ confidential and private business information to EPA,
although questions remain over the close relationship between EPA and friendly
environmental groups.[21]
Real
World Consequences
The
dual threat of litigation and regulation has taken a toll on the finances and morale
of American farmers and their surrounding communities. Implementation of
the Chesapeake Bay TMDL could cost taxpayers as much as $50 billion between
2010 and 2025.[22] The Waterkeeper
lawsuit
against the Maryland chicken farmer led to farmers "who now question any trust with environmental
organizations." And in California, years of misguided litigation and
regulation have jeopardized the livelihoods of thousands of farmworkers and the
viability of the farms they work on, and limited residents drinking water
supply.[23]
EPW
Republicans will continue detailing exactly how these coordinated efforts are
destroying jobs and punishing industries and families across America.
Previous editions include:
-
Collusion
& Coordination to Shut Down the Oil & Gas Industry -
Environmental
Collusion Attempts to Shutout Public Fishing -
Environmental
Litigation to Shut Down Forestry Projects -
Environmental
Lobbying to Shut Down One Nuclear Power Plant at a Time -
Environmental
Collusion to Block Mining: Sue Early, Often, and At Every Step
-30-
[1]
http://www.usda.gov/documents/timeline.pdf
[2]
http://farmfutures.com/story-resistance-contamination-concerns-forefront-biotech-crop-review-0-117752
[3]
http://www.fb.org/index.php?action=newsroom.news&year=2014&file=nr0113j.html
[4]
http://westernfarmpress.com/government/epa-regulations-suffocating-us-agriculture
[5]
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/369490/green-drought-charles-c-w-cooke/page/0/1
[6]
http://www.nrdc.org/media/2007/070526.asp
[7]
http://calwatchdog.com/2014/07/23/lawsuit-could-expand-state-control-of-groundwater/
[8]
http://www.envirolaw.org/documents/ScottPressRelease.pdf
[9]
http://cg.capitalgazette.com/news/environment/perdue-wins-high-stakes-poultry-lawsuit/article_79acc4a3-fca2-5845-9647-ac28078d3ca1.html?mode=jqm
[10]
http://www.bayjournal.com/article/wounds_from_suit_filed_by_waterkeepers_to_take_a_while_to_heal
[11]
Climateworks Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011; David and Lucile Packard
Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010; Energy Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011,
2012; Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011, 2012; Marisla
Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011, 2012; Park Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010,
2011, 2012; Rockefeller Family Fund IRS Form 990, 2010, 2012; Rockefeller
Brothers Fund IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011, 2012; Schmidt Family Foundation IRS
Form 990, 2010, 2012; Sea Change Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011; William
and Flora Hewlett Foundation IRS Form 990, 2010, 2011, 2012; Tides Foundation
IRS Form 990, 2011, 2012; Tides Foundation grants database 2013:
http://www.tides.org/fileadmin/user/pdf/Tides_List_of_2013_Grantees.pdf.
[12]
Park Foundation IRS Form 990, 2009, 2011; Energy Foundation grants database,
available at http://www.ef.org/grants-database/#!/keywords=waterkeeper; Marisla Foundation IRS Form
990, 2010, 2011, 2012.
[13]
http://regdata.org/?type=regulation_index&industry[]=11&industry[]=111&industry[]=112®ulator[]=111
[14] http://www.fb.org/legal/files/id_51/2014.01.27%20AFBF%20Joint%20Opening%20Brief.pdf
[15]
See American Farm Bureau v. EPA, Third Circuit No. 13-4079 (amicus
briefs filed in support of EPA).
[16]
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/CHRG-112hhrg65502/html/CHRG-112hhrg65502.htm
[17]
http://docs.nrdc.org/water/files/wat_12031401a.pdf
[18]
http://www.fb.org/legal/files/id_64/2012.05.10%20AFBF%20Joint%20Memorandum%20in%20Support%20of%20Motion%20to%20Intervene.pdf
[19]
http://www.eenews.net/greenwire/stories/1059976700
[20]
http://www.eenews.net/greenwire/stories/1059977391
[21]
http://www.eenews.net/eedaily/stories/1059979265/search?keyword=CAFO
[22]
http://www.chesapeakebay.net/channel_files/19062/660_–_environmental_workshop_report,_final,_spring_2012.pdf
[23]
http://smallbusiness.foxbusiness.com/entrepreneurs/2013/07/01/regulations-bleed-california-farmers-dry-as-record-drought-continues/