Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It…
E&E News
GOP questions timing of NRC chairman’s Yucca vote
(11/08/2010)
Katherine Ling, E&E reporter
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission chairman is the lone unaccounted-for vote in a commission decision over the Energy Department’s authority to withdraw its license application for a waste repository at Yucca Mountain, Nev.
Chairman Gregory Jaczko has failed to respond to a question from Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), ranking member of the Environment and Public Works Committee, about if and when the NRC commissioners voted to uphold a lower board’s ruling in June that only Congress has the authority to withdraw the DOE Yucca license application (Greenwire, Nov. 2).
Inhofe requested responses by Friday. Three of the four commissioners sent their responses last week. Democratic Commissioner George Apostolakis has recused himself from the case because of previous work on the license.
An NRC spokesman said Jaczko’s office will provide a public response by the end of today.
Republican Commissioners William Ostendorff and Kristine Svinicki voted on the question at the end of August and Democratic Commissioner William Magwood voted on Sept. 15, according to the letters sent to Inhofe’s office. Under NRC procedures, the nature of a vote is not made public until a staff guidance is developed based on the votes and the commission passes a final order.
It is likely the Republican commissioners have voted to uphold the lower board’s ruling and that Magwood has ruled against it, as Jaczko is likely to do, as well, according to a lobbyist working on the Yucca issue. A 2-2 tie would mean the lower court’s ruling is upheld.
While NRC’s ruling on the lower board’s decision has remained undecided, Jaczko has come under fire from Republicans, including Ostendorff and Svinicki, for directing staff to start an "orderly closure" of the license review under guidance on how to implement the "continuing resolution" that Congress passed at the end of September for funding the government through December. Congress has failed to pass any of the fiscal 2011 appropriations bills and hopes to pass an omnibus appropriations bill during the lame-duck session.
But given the timing of the other three votes, if it turns out Jaczko has voted or knew he was facing a tie vote but held the vote open and directed staff to stop work on the Yucca review, "that is pretty significant," a Republican aide for the Environment and Public Works Committee said.
Several prominent House Republicans, including four ranking members — and perspective committee leaders when the GOP takes control of the House next year — with jurisdiction on the issue, have lambasted Jaczko for the action and have promised strong oversight of the matter next Congress (E&ENews PM, Nov. 2).
Alex Flint, senior vice president of government affairs for the Nuclear Energy Institute, said the industry is "frustrated at the lack of transparency and lack of predictability" in the commission’s Yucca decision.
"We would like that regulatory process to be predictable and transparent in all matters, so it is of some concern that this issue is not being resolved predictably," Flint said.
But Flint said NEI would not be weighing in on the issue in Congress. Appropriators are likely going to have to resolve the question, he said, about whether Jaczko has the authority to shut down the review under the continuing resolution in either the continuing resolution or the omnibus appropriations bill for the rest of fiscal 2011.
Flint added that NEI wants NRC to continue reviewing the DOE license and that more than likely, the issue would be resolved in the courts.
The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia currently has a stay on cases filed by Washington state, South Carolina, the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners and others pending NRC’s decision about DOE’s authority to withdraw from the Yucca project. NARUC and the states filed another motion to lift the court’s stay last month in light of the agency’s moves to close down the review.
Click here to read the responses.
###