Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In the News…
E&E News
Landrieu proposes compromise on liability
(07/29/2010)
Katie Howell, E&E reporter
Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.) is drawing up an oil spill liability proposal that she says could be a compromise on an issue that has polarized lawmakers.
But Democratic leaders may be unlikely to swap out liability language already in Majority Leader Harry Reid’s (D-Nev.) energy package slated for floor debate next week.
Asked about the chances for Landrieu’s proposal making it into the energy and spill package, Reid spokesman Jim Manley said, "I think we have our own bill."
Reid’s measure would eliminate the $75 million liability cap altogether, but Republicans and some Democrats are staunchly opposed to that language, saying it would prevent all but the largest oil companies from operating offshore.
Landrieu’s proposal would raise the initial liability cap for companies involved in a spill from $75 million to $250 million, an aide said. If damages exceed $250 million, then a $10 billion mutual insurance fund fed by industry would kick in. And if the economic damages associated with the spill maxed out that fund, payment responsibility would return to the company responsible for the spill with no limit on liability.
The fund would be fed by all companies operating offshore, paying into it based on how much oil and gas they produced and through fees associated with the amount of the bonus bids paid for each offshore lease, the aide said.
"We want to make sure, first of all, that taxpayers never have to pay a dime when a big spill happens," Landrieu said."So we want to try to set up a process where large and small companies contribute appropriately to a fund, so that that doesn’t happen."
Landrieu strongly opposes Reid’s measure.
"We want to make sure that the industry can still be vibrant and grow," she said. "Some people up here want the industry to collapse — they want to kill it — and that is what I am strongly objecting to, and we will not let them do that through the disguise of unlimited liability."
Republicans have offered their own alternative language that would use an industry-friendly spill liability formula based on a number of criteria, including a company’s safety record and the risk associated with the project.
It remains uncertain whether Landrieu’s proposed compromise will gain traction with offshore drilling opponents, like Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), who crafted the language in the Democrats’ bill. But he has said he is open to working with Landrieu on a compromise.
Landrieu has also discussed the measure with Reid and Sens. Mark Begich (D-Alaska) and Mark Pryor (D-Ark.), the aide said. But she has not yet floated the idea with Republicans.
"No, we haven’t gotten that far because there’s so many other problems with the bill, but we’re hoping that maybe that will work out," she said, adding that the discussions she has had with Democrats are "actually getting very good reviews."
Some Republicans today said they would be willing to consider such a compromise.
"I’d be willing to look at that," Sen. Judd Gregg (R-N.H.) said.
Democratic leaders have indicated they might be willing to compromise.
"We’re trying to talk through what a reasonable proposal is," said Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-N.D.), chairman of the Democratic Policy Committee. "I don’t know yet what that’s going to be."
Until then, Landrieu will continue pushing her compromise language, the aide said, and will continue those discussions into September if the current legislation does not pass before the end of next week.
At issue is the amount of money companies involved in a spill would have to pay toward economic damages. Companies are legally required to pay all the cleanup and containment costs associated with a spill. But Congress has currently capped companies’ liability for economic damages — people put out of work by the spill, fishermen who cannot fish, empty hotel rooms on the beach at high season — at $75 million.
Reporter Robin Bravender contributed.
###