Senate and House Conferees Begin Work on Highway Bill Completion Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), Chairman of the Environment & Public Works Committee and Vice Chairman of the Safe Accountable, Flexible, and Efficient Transportation Equity Act (SAFETEA) conference committee, marked the beginning of the conference committee’s work with opening remarks yesterday: “We only have 20 days left until the current extension expires – I want to encourage those who are working with the White House on the overall number to continue their work. The Safe, Accountable, Flexible, and Efficient Transportation Equity Act of 2005 or ‘SAFETEA,’ as passed by the Senate last month contains a higher level of funding than that proposed by the House or that requested by the White House. As one of the most fiscally conservative members of Congress, I can tell you that I have no hesitation to endorse what Senators Chuck Grassley and Max Baucus produced.” The Senate version of the legislation will provide $295 billion to address the nation’s surface transportation needs over the next 5 years. Business Meeting: Wednesday, June 8, 2005 The following legislation was approved in Wednesday’s mark-up: – H.R. 483, to designate a United States courthouse in Brownsville, Texas, as the "Reynaldo G. Garza and Filemon B. Vela United States Courthouse" – S. 260, Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program – S. 864, Nuclear Security – S. 865, Price Anderson – S. 858, NRC Fees/Reform Bill – S. 1017, to reauthorize grants for the water resources research and technology institutes established under the Water Resources Research Act of 1984 – S. 1140, to designate the State Route 1 Bridge in the State of Delaware as the ‘Senator William V. Roth, Jr. Bridge’. Resolutions: – To authorize alteration of the James L. King Federal Justice Building in Miami, Florida – To authorize a lease prospectus for the General Services Administration headquarters Protecting Americans From Higher Energy Costs Associated With Reducing Carbon Emissions Senator Inhofe introduced legislation Wednesday that will protect disadvantaged individuals from the costs inherent in reducing carbon dioxide emissions from utilities. Disadvantaged Americans rely on stable and affordable energy prices to heat, cool and light their homes, and research that has shown that these individuals are negatively impacted by energy rate increases due to climate change-related expenses. The Ratepayers Protection Act of 2005 prevents those costs from being passed down to energy consumers. Political Science A number of politically-charged statements regarding climate change accompanied the arrival of British Prime Minister Tony Blair in Washington this week. The media was quick to point out the differences between President Bush and Prime Minister Blair on the topic, but failed to report on the strong partnerships the two have forged to address the issue despite the differences in approach. The joint science academies statement on global climate change response clearly served a political more than a scientific purpose – released the very morning of Prime Minister Blair’s arrival in a weak and obvious attempt to leverage President Bush. Senator James M. Inhofe, chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, dismissed the statement: “There is nothing new in this statement. It touts a 4-year-old Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [IPCC] report that has been roundly criticized and dismissed by a number of climate experts, and then essentially endorses the variety of actions the Bush Administration has already been taking.” The IPCC’s Third Assessment Report, published in 2001, relied on the hockey stick graph, recently repudiated by a peer-reviewed study that exposed mathematical errors and improper methodologies. The hockey stick was alleged to have shown a relationship between anthropogenic emissions and rising temperatures, and had been the foundation of claims by climate change alarmists. The National Academy of Sciences, in signing the statement, contradicted its own 2001 conclusions that dismissed any scientific consensus on causation, specifically calling attention to the uncertainties in current climate modeling. Blowing the Whistle on the “Whistle-blower” Finally, The New York Times’ Andrew Revkin kept to his schedule and launched another June climate barrage at the Bush Administration, this time suggesting that the Administration has no right to conduct an appropriate interagency review as part of its policymaking process. The allegations were actually presented by Rick Piltz, a disgruntled former career employee at the Climate Change Science Program who began his work under the Clinton Administration and once served as a senior Democrat staff member in the House Science Committee. Mr. Piltz, a political scientist by training – not a climate scientist – according to biographical information available online, apparently disagreed with the Bush Administration’s approach to climate change and upon resigning, sought to make a political statement against it under the guise of a “whistle-blower.” Considering there was no wrongdoing, and that every White House has had – and will have – the obligation to exert authority over its cabinet departments and agencies, Mr. Piltz can hardly claim “whistle-blower” status. Interestingly, the White House “edits” in question cited by The New York Times actually reflect the sense of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) study released in 2001. That report, Climate Change Science: An Analysis of Some Key Questions, reported numerous uncertainties in the science and called for more study: – Revkin, 6/8/05: “The dozens of changes, while sometimes as subtle as the insertion of the phrase ‘significant and fundamental’ before the word ‘uncertainties,’ tend to produce an air of doubt about findings that most climate experts say are robust.” (emphasis added) – NAS, Climate Change Science: An Analysis of Some Key Questions, 2001: “Making progress in reducing the large uncertainties in projections of future climate will require addressing a number of fundamental scientific questions relating to the buildup of greenhouses gases in the atmosphere and the behavior of the climate system.” (Summary, page 5, emphasis added) A Manufactured Consensus Would you believe the Clinton State Department requested that a chapter in an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report be watered down to dismiss scientific uncertainties regarding causation? It happened. In June 1998, Steve Milloy wrote that Dr. Benjamin Santer, atmospheric scientist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, “admitted to altering Chapter 8 of the most recent UN-IPCC report, deleting phrases that suggested scientific doubts about human influences on climate. According to the journal Nature, the changes were made to make the report conform to the IPCC Policymakers Summary, a political document. Nature editors said that the U.S. State Department had urged the head of the UN science advisory group to prevail upon chapter authors to make such changes. Santer also edited a crucial graph in Chapter 8 (Fig. 8.10) from his original published version, leading readers to believe that human influence is present and increasing with time … .” (http://www.junkscience.com/news2/singer40.htm, emphasis added) Also recall the case of Dr. Benny Peiser, a senior lecturer at Liverpool John Moores University, who conducted a review of 1,000 papers about climate change and concluded that only one third of them supported a “consensus view” on the alleged link between anthropogenic emissions and rising temperatures. Dr. Peiser sought to have his findings published in Science, but was denied. Why? Probably because earlier, Science published a paper, based on the same 1,000 papers, that claimed to have shown a consensus, not only that “global warming” is real, but that human beings are the cause. Exclusions such as this and selective publication of certain hypotheses only undermine sound science and perpetuate a manufactured consensus on climate change causation. Who has really been politicizing the science?