Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News…

E&E News  

Drillers ‘talking out of both sides of their mouths’ — DeGette

(07/29/2010)

By Mike Soraghan, E&E reporter

Link to Article

The author of legislation that would order public disclosure of hydraulic fracturing chemicals yesterday said she felt betrayed when some of the drillers she had been negotiating with publicly rejected her provision Tuesday.

"A lot of these companies want to say publicly ‘We support disclosure.’ But then they try to kill it behind the scenes," DeGette said. "This is something that is going to happen. I wish industry would work with us instead of talking out of both sides of their mouths."

The stakes are high. DeGette’s proposal is part of Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid’s energy bill, and debate is set to start this week. It will be the first bill with fracturing provisions to hit the floor of either chamber since Congress exempted the process from federal regulation in a 2005 energy bill.

But it is not clear that the disclosure proposal would have any effect on Reid’s quest to secure the 60 votes he needs to pass the bill. The critics and supporters of drilling are more focused on revenue sharing and oil spill liability. "It’s probably a wash," said a senior Democratic aide.

America’s Natural Gas Alliance, which lobbies for some of the larger independent drilling companies, released a statement Tuesday opposing the disclosure provision, citing concerns that the program would be overseen by U.S. EPA, and saying fracturing should be regulated at the state level. ANGA, as it is called, is considered the gas lobby group most amenable to some sort of disclosure regulation.

But DeGette was most angered to learn that Range Resources Corp., which has been out front among drillers on the disclosure issue, opposes her measure (Greenwire, July 15).

"We support disclosure, which is why we’ve implemented our voluntary disclosure initiative," said Matt Pitzarella, spokesman for Range, which is a major player in Pennsylvania’s shale boom. "However, we believe that should be the decision and duty of the individual states, not the federal government."

In an interview, DeGette cited Range as a company that supported her proposal. After Pitzarella’s statement was read to her, she said, "That’s a backtrack from where they were before."

"I’m shocked these companies are telling you that," DeGette added. "These companies have been working with us from day one."

Reid (D-Nev.) included the DeGette language in his bill after a last-minute plea Tuesday from Pennsylvania Democratic Sens. Bob Casey and Arlen Specter. Drilling is expanding rapidly in their state from discoveries in the Marcellus Shale. Drilling has brought economic benefits but there have also been high-profile accidents that fouled rivers and drinking water.

Casey and Specter argued to Reid that he should balance incentives in the bill for natural gas vehicles with increased disclosure of the chemicals used in drilling.

Reid agreed. The fracturing language was not included in summaries his office distributed during the day Tuesday and was not discussed in briefings on the bill. The language did not surface until bill language was released late Tuesday night.

DeGette’s fellow Colorado Democrats, Sens. Mark Udall and Michael Bennet, have also pressed the case for public disclosure.

The bill would require states to post well-by-well information on the chemicals used in fracturing wells in their state. If a state did not do that, companies themselves would be required to post the information.
Companies that do not comply would be subject to fines of up to $10,000 from EPA.

Enforcement by EPA is a key sticking point. Industry has vehemently fought regulation by the agency under the Safe Drinking Water Act, saying EPA might shut down drilling for months or years while it develops a regulatory program (Greenwire, June 21).

In negotiations with industry, DeGette proposed a compromise. EPA would enforce public disclosure, but under the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, which requires companies to disclose information about the chemicals they are using. But that was still too much EPA involvement for industry.

"We have been unable to reach a consensus with congressional advocates on how this program would be overseen by the federal government," ANGA said in a statement Tuesday. "Therefore, we cannot support this language."

In addition, industry lawyer Jason Hutt of Bracewell & Giuliani, said DeGette’s language lacks sufficient protection for proprietary information, which would actually hinder efforts to make fracturing more environment-friendly.

"If you can’t ensure adequate protection of proprietary information, the fracking service companies won’t have sufficient incentive to continue the R&D needed to find greener solutions," Hutt said.

DeGette said industry lobbyists had walked away from the table after House leadership stripped onshore drilling provisions, including fracturing disclosure on public lands, from an oil spill response bill. But she still thought she had support from companies like Range and Chesapeake Energy Corp. (E&E Daily, July 27).

After that, she said she stepped up her efforts to get the measure added to the Senate bill, working with Casey’s office. Casey was the Senate sponsor of DeGette’s legislation to require disclosure and lift the industry’s Safe Drinking Water Act exemption (E&ENews PM, July 20).

DeGette said the Energy and Commerce Committee, of which she is vice chairwoman, will hold hearings on fracturing in September as part of the investigation into the process that it launched earlier this year.

She is also considering introducing a free-standing public disclosure bill in connection with those hearings.

The growth of fracturing

In fracturing, crews inject tanker-loads of water and sand into gas wells to blow apart the rock formation and release gas. A small fraction of that concoction is a mixture of chemicals as mundane as ice cream thickener and as toxic as diesel fuel. The 2005 exemption from the Safe Drinking Water Act headed off an appellate court ruling that had found the law should cover fracturing.

Since then, fears have grown among environmentalists, community groups and some Democratic lawmakers that injecting chemicals underground at high pressure could contaminate groundwater.

But in that time, fracturing has become even more vital to U.S. natural gas production. Vast shale formations under Pennsylvania, Texas and Louisiana have doubled U.S. gas reserves by some measures — but they can be tapped only with fracturing. By providing a stable, long-term supply of natural gas, shale gas could push a transformative switch from coal to gas in power plants and other energy uses. That would reduce greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants.

Gas producers say fracturing is safe and state regulation is sufficient. They maintain that there has never been a proven case of groundwater contamination from the injection process.

One industry source indicated that companies might be more likely to go along with the disclosure legislation if the bill included incentives for power plants to convert from coal to gas.

Such a provision was in the climate bill sponsored by Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.). But it died along with restrictions on greenhouse gas emissions when Reid determined he did not have enough votes to pass a broader climate bill.

Reid went instead with the natural gas vehicle incentives that Casey and Specter asked him to balance with the disclosure language. But those incentives generate much less support from drillers.

###