Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

Colorado: "Cap and Trade is Wrong Solution" – Denver Post

Round-up of Recent Headlines on Waxman-Markey from Colorado

DENVER POST EDITORIAL: Cap and trade is wrong solution – The U.S. needs to cut its greenhouse emissions, but legislation expected to be taken up today isn’t the way to go about it: But Waxman-Markey isn’t the solution. Fashioned to avoid appearing like a new tax, the measure nevertheless would work like one, as the higher costs of meeting the caps get passed on to consumers. The measure risks hurting our competitiveness globally without effectively lowering global greenhouse gases. Congress should instead consider a simpler carbon tax, creating a "nuclear-arms race" to harness atomic power to replace fossil fuels and provide incentives to speed new-energy innovation.

Denver Post: Warming bill dicey for Dems – Salazar opposed the bill early on, particularly the impact its central component, restrictions on emissions of greenhouse gases, could have on energy costs. His spokesman said this week that Salazar has not decided whether recent compromises to the bill are enough to change his mind. But the vote is an especially dicey one for Markey, who has yet to take a public position. A first-term Democrat in a moderate district, Markey is likely to be one of the GOP’s biggest targets in 2010, and they would love nothing more than to see her vote "yes." Environmental groups also hope Markey supports the bill. Defenders of Wildlife Action Fund poured $1.5 million into her campaign – the group’s biggest push for any House candidate in the country – and they expected her to be a key supporter in the push for a global warming bill. But as late as Thursday afternoon, Markey spokeswoman Ben Marter said his boss was still pondering the vote. "She’s looking at it through an economic lens," he said.

Grand Junction Sentinel: Salazar undecided on climate legislation – Other concerns, however, include questions about the effect of the measure on utility bills, especially "when I feel the economy is just starting to stabilize across the state." Grand Valley Power in Grand Junction earlier this month sent letters to customers saying the measure could dramatically increase their bills."I hope we wind up with a bill I can support, but we’re not there yet," Salazar said. If the measure wins House approval, it will go to the Senate, where opposition is generally considered to be stronger.

Colorado Springs Gazette: What is wrong with this bill? Almost too many things to count. – The House of Representatives is preparing to vote on a massive "cap and trade" bill today purportedly designed to address global warming – though they call it "climate change" now since the globe hasn’t warmed in the past few years – that probably will not be finished until minutes before voting begins. The reason is that proponents are still buying votes from moderate Democrats with special-interest favors and sweetheart deals. Not only will this bill do little or nothing to curb global warming – it’s all pain and no gain – it has become a Christmas tree for politically connected industries and lobbyists. Last week, HR 2454 was 946 pages long. As of Wednesday morning it had burgeoned to 1,201 pages, as various constituencies made backroom deals with House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Henry Waxman and his cohorts. That blatant vote-buying and sweetheart deal-making is why environmental groups such as Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, and the open-government organization the Sunlight Foundation have come out against the bill. What is wrong with this bill? Almost too many things to count.

David Harsanyi: Cap and trade: It’s an economic catastrophe –  If you have even a basic grasp of cap-and-trade policy, you’re one in a million. According to a recent Rasmussen poll, given a choice of three options, only 24 percent of voters could even identify that cap-and-trade policies had anything to do with environmental issues. A higher number believed that it was about regulating Wall Street. A plurality had no idea what it was at all. Who can blame them? It’s preposterously convoluted. And that’s precisely the kind confusion the backers of cap-and-trade schemes are counting on. When it comes to environmental policy, politicians will rely on your good intentions on the issue and not much else. With cap-and-trade, however, the economic tradeoffs are so damaging, the environmental benefits so negligible and the plan such a clutter, that selling it – even to Democrats – is turning out to be difficult.

Carroll: Make-believe world of cap and trade – How could a hurried-up makeover of the energy economy not significantly hike consumer prices or penalize some states compared to others? If cap and trade doesn’t do those things, in fact, it’s hard to see the point. Isn’t the program supposed to prod consumers and industry to alter their use of energy, as well as spur innovation? Admittedly, that prospect involves what Robert Samuelson calls "much economic make-believe" – the conviction, for example, that "new supplies of ‘clean energy’ magically materialize" as needed. Cheerleaders of climate legislation know they’re playing with fire. Who knows how voters will react if they’re told the truth? The last thing politicians want is for Americans to read articles whose opening lines are like those that appeared in last Thursday’s New York Times: "With climate legislation knocking at the door, American factory workers have every right to be shaking in their work boots . . . . A price on carbon would put even more pressure on manufacturers, some of the biggest energy users in the country." The article explained how a coalition of "industry, union and environmentalist stakeholders" propose to save industrial jobs by offering manufacturers (in steel, paper and chemicals, for example) free emission permits until they can "devise new technologies" that would allow them to compete with their global rivals. More economic make-believe? Don’t dare say it. After all, this is cost-free legislation.

###