During today’s EPW Committee legislative hearing on the Marine Vessel Emissions Reduction Act of 2007 (S.1499), Chairman Boxer quoted from a letter in support of her bill by The National Association of Clean Air Agencies (formerly STAPPA and ALAPCO) purporting that the association speaks for all fifty states. Senator Boxer said at the hearing that it’s important to “take a close look at this letter” because the group “represents every state in the union.” Yet a closer look at the group reveals the claim that they represent all 50 states is simply false.
FACT: This association and its predecessors (STAPPA and ALAPCO) have a long history of speaking for a minority of States and refusing to make their decisions and votes publicly available. In the past they have had a minority of states present for votes, a vote on a position not be unanimous, and then try and speak on behalf of all fifty states.
- During development of the 8hr ozone standard, there was a huge disparity of opinion between states on the issue (some states are “downwind” states such as the Northeast and some are “upwind” states). Although it was close to an even split, the majority of States did not support the Northeast’s stringent position, but STAPPA adopted this position anyway.
- A large number of air administrators believe NSR is broken, but STAPPA would not modify the position. So a large number of States were forced to create a separate workgroup to develop alternative positions.
- During the sulfur in gasoline debate in 1999, STAPPA’s official position was based on one meeting where fewer than 25 states showed up, the vote was not unanimous, yet as an organization they claimed to speak for all 50 states.
- STAPPA took a very aggressive position on mercury, but a majority of States wanted to control mercury in a more cost-effective manner. STAPPA took the most stringent position held by the minority of States and discouraged the inclusion of the views of these more moderate States from being presented during EPA’s Clean Air Act Advisory Committee proceedings.
- An even larger number were considering pulling out of STAPPA and creating a separate group to represent them. The problem is that creating a new group is time consuming and States are continually having Administrations turn-over, which created a significant barrier to the new group’s creation.
It’s quite understandable that Chairman Boxer would want the group that supports her bill to represent all 50 states, but the facts tell a very different story.