Posted by Matt Dempsey matthew_dempsey@epw.senate.gov 6:26pm ET
WELCOME GLENN BECK
VIEWERS!
Do you want to keep up to date
on Senator Inhofe’s efforts to combat global warming alarmism? Be sure to
read the Inhofe
EPW Press Blog or subscribe to the Inhofe
EPW Press email list. See also the U.S. Senate Report released
December 20, 2007, “Over 400 Prominent Scientists Disputed Man-Made Global
Warming Claims in 2007” – LINK
Senator James Inhofe was a guest on Glenn Beck’s television show tonight
discussing the possible listing of the polar bear under the Endangered Species
Act (ESA). Liberal special interests are working hard to turn the ESA into
global warming law, which one former Reagan appointee
in charge of ESA listings said would cause ESA to become a “regulatory
monster” and what Senator John Barrasso (R-WY) said would cause “legal
chaos.”
Here is what Senator Inhofe wants you to know – and what
liberals don’t – about the polar bear.
Polar Bear stats:
-
Worldwide
polar bear population numbers are at or near all-time highs -
The
Fish and Wildlife Service estimates that there are currently 20,000 to
25,000 polar bears. -
In
the 1950s and 1960s, estimates were as low as 5,000-10,000 bears. -
According
to Canadian scientists 11 of the 13 bear populations are stable, some are
increasing. -
Canada is
home to 2/3 of the world’s polar bears -
Like
all species, polar bears have and can adapt to habitat changes -
Researchers
discovered an ancient polar bear jaw that dates back more than 100,000
years, to a time far warmer than the present.
The Polar Bear is Already Protected
Under the::
-
Marine
Mammal Protection Act -
Several
international conservation treaties including the 1973 Agreement on the
Conservation of Polar Bears and the US-Russia Polar Bear Conservation and
Management Act of 2006 -
As
well as conservation, education and outreach agreement with native
peoples.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions Regulation:
-
This
is not about the bears. Special interests are trying to use the ESA to
achieve global warming policy that they can’t achieve through the
legislative process. -
But
the ESA cannot reverse climate change.
-
If
you want to regulate greenhouse gas emissions in the name of reversing
climate change, then be up front about it.
Let’s go to the Senate floor and have a debate, take votes on a
climate change bill -
Don’t
sneak in through the back door through litigation-driven ESA listings and
try to turn the Fish and Wildlife Service into air pollution regulators. -
But
this is what these groups want to do -
At
the hearing on Tuesday, the Center for Biological Diversity essentially
stated that they want to use Section 7 of the ESA to regulate greenhouse
gases wherever they occur -
These
groups also made it clear they want to use the polar bear to stop oil and
natural gas production, not only in Alaska
but wherever it occurs
More
Information:
U.S.
Senate Minority Report Debunks Polar Bear Extinction Fears
The United States Fish and Wildlife Service is considering
listing the polar bear a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act.
This report details the scientists debunking polar bear endangerment fears and
features a sampling of the latest peer-reviewed science detailing the natural
causes of recent Arctic ice changes. The U.S. Fish & Wildlife
Service estimates that the polar bear population is currently at 20,000 to
25,000 bears, up from as low as 5,000-10,000 bears in the 1950s and
1960s. A 2002 U.S. Geological Survey of wildlife in the Arctic Refuge
Coastal Plain noted that the polar bear populations “may now be near historic
highs.” The alarm about the future of polar bear decline is based on
speculative computer model predictions many decades in the future. And the
methodology of these computer models is being challenged by many scientists and
forecasting experts. (LINK)
Impact:
New York Times Features EPW
Polar Bear Report
The New York Times reported this week on the U.S.
Senate Environment and Public Works Committee (EPW) Minority report debunking
fears of polar bear extinction. John Tierney’s January 31 article, titled
"Polar Bears and Seer Suckers," called the EPW Minority’s
report "persuasive at debunking the predictions of polar bears going
extinct this century."
Tierney noted that polar bear extinction fears are
"being stoked to build support in the U.S. for listing them as a
‘threatened’ or ‘endangered’ species even though it’s not clear that their
overall numbers are declining." (LINK)
Tierney noted that the EPW Minority’s polar bear report featured "one very
hard piece of evidence that casts doubt on the doomsday predictions: a polar
bear jawbone that appears to be at least 110,000 years old, meaning that polar
bears have survived eras with considerably warmer temperatures than today."
[Note: For more on the discovery of an ancient jaw bone which
"confirms the polar bear was a morphologically distinct species at least
100,000 years ago" and thus survived past warming periods, see – LINK]
Polar
Bear Pandering By Debra Saunders (San Francisco Chronicle)
Sunday, November 4, 2007
Sen. Barbara Boxer of California
delivered a speech in the Senate last week in which she linked global warming
to the San Diego wildfires, Darfur, the imminent
loss of the world’s polar bears and even a poor 14-year-old boy who died from
"an infection caused after swimming in Lake Havasu,"
because its water is warmer. Forget arson. Forget genocide. Forget nature.
There is no tragedy that cannot be placed at the doorstep of global-warming
skeptics. Oh, and there’s no need to acknowledge that the regulations or taxes
necessary to curb emissions by a substantial degree might damage economic
growth. According to Boxer, laws to curb greenhouse gases – this country would
have to cut its greenhouse gas emissions in half over 12 years to meet the
latest international community goals – will do good things for the American
economy and create lots of jobs. It’s Nostradamus Science wedded to Santa Claus
economics. It is rhetoric such as Boxer’s – an odd combination of
the-end-is-near hysteria and overly rosy economic scenarios – that keep me in
the agnostic/skeptic global-warming camp. Boxer and Sen. James Inhofe, the
ranking Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee that
Boxer chairs, have been engaging in a running debate on global warming. Last
month, Inhofe took on the Al Gore suggestion that polar bears are in peril
because of global warming. Inhofe pointed to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services
estimates that show the polar bear population at about 20,000 to 25,000 bears –
up from the estimated 5,000 to 10,000 polar bears in the 1950s and 1960s.
Tuesday, March 06, 2007
Their status ranges from a "vulnerable" to
"endangered" and could be declared "threatened" if the U.S. decides
the polar bear is collateral damage of climate change.
Nobody talks about "overpopulated" when discussing
the bears’ outlook.Yet despite the Canadian government ‘s $150-million
commitment last week to fund 44 International Polar Year research projects, a
key question is not up for detailed scientific assessment: If the polar bear is
the 650-kilogram canary in the climate change coal mine, why are its numbers
INCREASING?
Many
Agree Polar Bears Should Not Be Listed As Threatened Under ESA
EPW FACT OF THE DAY February 7, 2007
FACT: Many Canadian indigenous peoples, international
governments and conservation groups clearly agree with Dr
Foote’s position that the polar bear should not be listed. The following
comments below were submitted by groups during the US Fish and Wildlife Service
petition process regarding the listing of the polar bear: Inuvialuit
Game Council (Represents the collective Inuvialuit interest in wildlife and
wildlife habitat) "Sound polar bear populations all overlap
the ISR ("Inuvialuit Settlement Region"). These populations of polar
bears have helped sustain the Inuvialuit for generations to do so. Currently,
these populations are healthy and thriving … we can see no justification for
up-listing polar bears to ‘threatened status’ under the U.S. Endangered Species
Act … "at this point in time, there is not enough information to say that
polar bears are in danger of becoming extinct due to predicted shift in climate
… Due to our close relationship with these populations, we, along with other
user groups, would be the first to see signs of trouble and we would make sure,
through the co-management system, that appropriate management actions are taken
to ensure the sustainability of these populations."
INHOFE
SPEECH ON POLAR BEARS AND GLOBAL WARMING
January 4, 2007
Mr. President, I rise today to address the U.S. Fish &
Wildlife Service’s recent action to begin formal consideration of whether to
list the polar bear as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act
(ESA). Over the next year, the Fish and Wildlife Service will examine
scientific and commercial data regarding the health of the polar bear
population and evaluate the presence of any threats to its existence. The
question that the Fish and Wildlife Service must answer is: Is there
clear, scientific evidence that current worldwide polar bear populations are in
trouble and facing possible extinction in the foreseeable future? As the
Fish and Wildlife Service reviews the issue over the next year, I feel
confident they will conclude as I have, that listing the polar bear is
unwarranted. In the proposal, the Fish and Wildlife Service acknowledges that
for seven of the 19 worldwide polar bear populations, the Service has no
population trend data of any kind. Other data suggest that for an
additional five polar bear populations, the number of bears is not declining
and is stable. Two more of the bear populations showed reduced numbers in
the past due to over hunting, but these two populations are now increasing
because of hunting restrictions.
POLAR
BEAR POLITICS (THE WALL STREET JOURNAL EDITORIAL) JANUARY 3, 2007;
PAGE A12
Unless you’ve been hibernating for the winter, you have no
doubt heard the many alarms about global warming. Now even the Bush
Administration is getting into the act, at least judging from last week’s
decision by Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne to recommend that the majestic
polar bear be listed as "threatened" under the Endangered Species
Act. The closer you inspect this decision, however, the more it looks like the
triumph of politics over science. "We are concerned," said Mr.
Kempthorne, that "the polar bears’ habitat may literally be melting"
due to warmer Arctic temperatures. However, when we called Interior spokesman
Hugh Vickery for some elaboration, he was a lot less categorical, even a tad
defensive. The "endangered" designation is based less on the actual
number of bears in Alaska
than on "projections into the future," Mr. Vickery said, adding that
these "projection models" are "tricky business."
Related:
INHOFE
DISCUSSES NUCLEAR ENERGY WITH GLENN BECK (October 25, 2007)
INHOFE
DISCUSSES LOST, GLOBAL WARMING, and WRDA WITH GLENN BECK (October 17,
2007)