Strassel: Carbon Caps Through the Backdoor
Copenhagen was a flop. Congress’s cap-and-trade bill is stalled. The EPA has delayed its climate rules. If you think this means American business is escaping the threat of carbon restraints, think again.
Most of the climate debate focuses on Washington. This misses a more clever and committed force-environmental groups that impose their agenda on companies via pressure, legal threat and sympathetic regulators. A textbook example has been quietly unfolding in the insurance sector. The question is whether governors will stand by to let green activists effectively regulate their businesses.
Since the beginning of the climate debate, environmental lobbies such as Ceres (a coalition of activists and investors that pressures companies to go green) have expressed particular interest in insurers. Rather than nitpick every company to adopt climate-change policies, these organizations realized it would be more efficient to target a gatekeeper. Everybody needs insurance. If insurers could be bludgeoned into requiring policyholders adopt carbon-mitigation practices as a requirement for insurance, the activists would have imposed their will widely and quickly.
Barrasso Releases Report Detailing Majority’s Failure to Investigate Administration Actions Undermining Transparency and Sound Science
WASHINGTON, DC – Today, US Senator John Barrasso, Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Oversight in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, released a report detailing the Subcommittee’s lack of oversight on a number of key Administration activities that undermine transparency and sound science. Barrasso discussed the report on the floor of the U.S. Senate while speaking about Mr. Arthur Elkins’ nomination to serve as Inspector General of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
“Mr. President, I rise today because the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee will soon be meeting to discuss the nomination of Mr. Arthur Elkins to be Inspector General at the Environmental Protection Agency.
“I support Mr. Elkin’s moving out of the committee. To date he has truthfully answered the questions that I have posed to him.
“Before the full Senate vote, I do have some additional questions based on a report that I am releasing today.
“Mr. President, as Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Oversight in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, I care a great deal about ensuring oversight over the agencies within our jurisdiction, the most important of which is the EPA.
Washington Times: Editorial: Global warming winners
The greatest scandal connected to global warming is not exaggeration, fraud or destruction of data to conceal the weakness of the argument. It is those who are personally profiting from promoting this fantasy at the expense of the rest of us.
Al Gore is the most visible beneficiary. The world’s greatest climate-change fear-monger has amassed millions in book sales and speaking fees. His science-fiction movie, “An Inconvenient Truth,” won an Academy Award for best documentary and 21 other film awards. He was co-recipient of the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize for his “efforts to build up and disseminate greater knowledge about man-made climate change, and to lay the foundations for the measures that are needed to counteract such change.”
Meanwhile, Mr. Gore was laying his own foundations. As he was whipping up hysteria over climate change, he cannily invested in “green” firms that stood to profit in the hundreds of millions of dollars (if not more) from increased government regulations and sweetheart deals from connected politicians and bureaucrats. The multimillionaire climate dilettante was given a free pass by reporters, who refused to ask him hard questions about the degree to which he was profiting from the panic he was causing.
With the global-warming story line unraveling, the New York Times allowed Mr. Gore to run what amounted to an unpaid advertisement for his brand of climate-change hysteria. This screed, published Saturday, reiterated his claim that the world faces an “unimaginable calamity requiring large-scale, preventive measures to protect human civilization as we know it.” That’s pretty good rhetoric for the person with the largest carbon footprint in the world.
CONSENSUS EXPOSED, PART 3: ‘HIDE THE DECLINE’
In our last excerpt from the Senate EPW Minority Report on the CRU controversy, we provide our take on the infamous “hide the decline” email. As one can see, the story behind that email is not an innocent one; in fact, it shows deliberate efforts to massage data to fit a preconceived conclusion about climate change.
From Section 1, “Inside the Email Trail” (pages 15 to 18):
Perhaps the most infamous example of this comes from the “hide the decline” email. This email initially garnered widespread media attention, as well as significant disagreement over its implications. In our view, the email, as well as the contextual history behind it, appears to show several scientists eager to present a particular viewpoint-that anthropogenic emissions are largely responsible for global warming-even when the data showed something different. Here is the email as written in 1999 by the CRU’s Jones:
Graham’s remarks appear to be more political than substantive
Is cap and trade really “dead”?
After all, didn’t Sen. Lindsey Graham say so? The South Carolina Republican’s recent remarks — or snippets of them — have ricocheted around Capitol Hill and beyond in recent weeks, lending momentum to the notion that the congressional effort he is helping lead no longer plans to implement a system that requires companies to buy and sell emission credits.
But Graham’s remarks appear to be more political than substantive. Indeed, cap and trade remains very much a part of the debate on what legislation will look like when the closed-door negotiations are finished.
Graham was quoted Saturday in The Washington Post telling environmentalists “cap-and-trade is dead.” The New York Times carried a similar quote in January that the senator later clarified, explaining he was referring to the large-scale, House-passed climate bill and a Senate counterpart approved by the Environment and Public Works Committee (Greenwire, Jan. 27).
NYT: Scientists Taking Steps to Defend Work on Climate
WASHINGTON – For months, climate scientists have taken a vicious beating in the media and on the Internet, accused of hiding data, covering up errors and suppressing alternate views. Their response until now has been largely to assert the legitimacy of the vast body of climate science and to mock their critics as cranks and know-nothings.
But the volume of criticism and the depth of doubt have only grown, and many scientists now realize they are facing a crisis of public confidence and have to fight back. Tentatively and grudgingly, they are beginning to engage their critics, admit mistakes, open up their data and reshape the way they conduct their work.
The unauthorized release last fall of hundreds of e-mail messages from a major climate research center in England, and more recent revelations of a handful of errors in a supposedly authoritative United Nations report on climate change, have created what a number of top scientists say is a major breach of faith in their research. They say the uproar threatens to undermine decades of work and has badly damaged public trust in the scientific enterprise.
Listen / Read: Tulsa World: Senate breaks impasse
WASHINGTON – The U.S. Senate broke a days-long impasse Tuesday and easily approved a bill temporarily restoring federal funds to road projects in Oklahoma and other states as well as unemployment benefits and other programs.
The vote was 78-19, and President Barack Obama signed it into law late Tuesday.
Oklahoma’s two Republican senators split their votes, with Jim Inhofe voting for the bill and Tom Coburn voting against it.
Funds for the programs expired over the weekend after U.S. Sen. Jim Bunning, R-Ky., repeatedly blocked a vote on the short-term funding legislation because its costs were not offset with cuts elsewhere.
That led to a furlough of nearly 2,000 federal transportation employees, halted jobless benefits, allowed a cut in Medicare payments to doctors to kick in and threatened eventually to shut down road projects.
Bunning, a Baseball Hall of Fame pitcher who is not running for re-election, had stuck to his objection as Democrats took turns hammering him over the pain he was causing unemployed Americans.
CONSENSUS EXPOSED, PART 2
The following is Part 2 in our series of excerpts from the Senate EPW Minority Report, titled, “‘Consensus’ Exposed: The CRU Controversy.” Here the excerpts focus on two points from the report. First is the distinction made between “utterly politicized scientists,” such as those at the center of the CRU controversy, and scientists committed to disinterested, objective science in the field of climatology (and all other fields), who deserve praise and support. It points to the importance of openness and transparency in practicing good science-and shows how those principles were, at times, ignored or flouted. Second, it shows how the EPA relied heavily on the IPCC’s Fourth Assessment Report to make its endangerment finding for greenhouse gases. The IPCC’s report was marred by errors and exaggerations. EPA failed to do its own independent review of the IPCC’s science, so its finding is flawed, and EPA should dispense with it and start over again.
Human Events: Inhofe Blasts Gore Over Climategate
Former vice president Al Gore made his first public remarks since the Climategate scandal broke in a very lengthy New York Times op-ed published on Saturday. Gore, a green technology hawker and, as a result, the first reported green technology billionaire, appeared completely out of touch with the reality of the magnitude of the worldwide climate hoax scandals.
I caught up with Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), top Republican on the Senate Environment & Public Works Committee yesterday for an exclusive chat about Gore’s new diatribe and the EPA endangerment finding.
SEN. JIM INHOFE: In a way, it’s kind of humorous. And yet, you have to feel a little bit sorry for Al Gore. He’s not been available ever since the first Climategate took place. And that was before Copenhagen. And he’s still in denial. … He has played it down. It’s something that is just a misunderstanding or a miscommunication. And it just seems like, this article that he wrote, if you dissect it, everything in there is stuff that has been refuted. And he can’t deny it. Although he’s in denial, so he is denying it.”
I asked Inhofe a series of questions keyed to Gore’s claims in the NYT piece.
Blizzard of Lies – A Perfect Storm – The Edifice Falls
Washington Post: Senators to propose abandoning cap-and-trade – Three key senators are engaged in a radical behind-the-scenes overhaul of climate legislation, preparing to jettison the broad “cap-and-trade” approach that has defined the legislative debate for close to a decade. The sharp change of direction demonstrates the extent to which the cap-and-trade strategy — allowing facilities to buy and sell pollution credits in order to meet a national limit on greenhouse gas emissions — has become political poison. In a private meeting with several environmental leaders on Wednesday, according to participants, Sen. Lindsey O. Graham (R-S.C.), declared, “Cap-and-trade is dead.” Graham and Sens. John F. Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joseph I. Lieberman (I-Conn.) have worked for months to develop an alternative to cap-and-trade, which the House approved eight months ago.
The Hill: Senators rebrand, recast climate bill as ‘cap and trade’ becomes politically toxic – Senators trying to salvage a climate bill hope to put plenty of distance between themselves and cap-and-trade. It’s an acknowledgment that the term cap and trade has itself become a political liability.”Cap-and-trade in conservative circles is widely considered a dirty phrase, right up there with abortion on demand,” said Frank O’Donnell, president of the advocacy group Clean Air Watch.