Climate Bill Sponsors Oppose Open, Transparent Committee Process

Greenwire reports this morning that the sponsors of a new climate effort in the Senate want to skip the open, transparent committee process and craft a new gas tax behind closed doors. As the story makes clear, their ploy is meeting growing, bipartisan opposition.

Lieberman: In an effort to keep the bill in Reid’s hands, the sponsors — Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) won’t officially introduce the bill in the Senate when they unveil it to the public next week. “If we introduce it, it’ll get referred to committees,” Lieberman said. “We want him to be able to work with it and bring it out onto the floor as a leader whenever he’s ready.”

Bipartisan Opposition:

Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.): Already, some senators also are raising red flags about the committee process, which they warn may be circumvented if the Kerry-Graham-Lieberman proposal moves directly into Reid’s office.”These bills need to go through committee,” said Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.). “If you’re talking about making major deals on energy policy, it needs to go through the Energy Committee. If you’re making major deals on tax policy, it needs to go through the Finance Committee. I mean, if you want to get it done.”

Human Events: Reid to Backroom National Energy Tax Bill

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) is set to take charge of new legislation aimed at imposing a national energy tax on all Americans, according to Greenwire, the news service for all things environment (article available on the Senate Republican Environment and Public Works “EPW” Press Blog here.)

Called “cap-and-trade” or “climate change” or “global warming” legislation, the new attempt to place a crippling national tax on America’s energy resources is being cobbled together by Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.). According to the new report, the trio will not formally introduce the bill in the Senate when it’s unveiled next week.

E&E News: Reid set to take command of cap-and-trade bill

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) is about to take over as stage manager in the uphill push to pass comprehensive climate and energy legislation.

Next week, Reid will be handed the reins of the bill to cap greenhouse gas emissions while expanding domestic oil, gas and nuclear power production. His challenge could not be tougher. Along with the climate measure, he must juggle a packed Senate agenda that includes Wall Street reform, a Supreme Court nomination and more economic recovery plans. Reid is also facing perhaps the toughest re-election campaign of his career this fall.

AMBIENT ERROR

Establishing a national ambient air quality standard (NAAQS) for CO2 is feared possibly more than any other potential greenhouse gas regulation under the Clean Air Act (CAA). A CO2 NAAQS would twist the CAA into knots and spread EPA’s regulatory tentacles into every corner of the economy. And according to a recent report, there’s no avoiding it.

EPA and some environmental activists say a GHG NAAQS won’t happen, because EPA possesses the legal flexibility to avoid it. EPA has discretion, they believe, to craft greenhouse gas (GHG) regulations in the most cost-effective and rational manner. But as Nathan Richardson of Resources for the Future argues in a December 2009 study, EPA “likely lacks much of this claimed flexibility, and will probably be forced by interconnections and statutory triggers built into the CAA to set national ambient air quality standards (NAAQS)” for GHGs.

In “Greenhouse Gas Regulation Under the Clean Air Act: Does Chevron v. EPA Set the EPA Free?,” Richardson explains that the “interpretation of CAA language on which the EPA relies for the flexibility it claims” was “explicitly rejected in federal court more than 30 years ago in NRDC v. Train.” The legal basis for EPA’s belief that “a court would decide the issue differently now…is likely insufficient.”

Tulsa World: Home renovations may hit a wall

WASHINGTON – Oklahomans hoping to have older homes remodeled or even worked on could see projects come to a standstill or even be canceled because of a federal rule designed to protect children from lead poisoning.

That’s the warning from state homebuilders.

They blame the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for failing to get the word out on a rule that takes effect next week requiring lead-safe practices to be used for renovations of pre-1978 homes, child-care facilities and school buildings.

They also claim the EPA has not even certified one trainer for the entire state of Oklahoma.

An EPA spokesman dismissed such concerns, saying local firms have had two years to get ready for the new rule.

EPA Spokesman Dale Kemery said the Oklahoma Association of Community Action Agencies in Oklahoma City is a training provider based in the state.

But a spokesman for that organization said its trainer has been certified for less than a month.

IBD Editorial: Backdoor Energy Tax

Pollution Control: From cars to coal mines, the imposition of economy-killing restrictions is under way. Are the new EPA regulations on auto emissions the precursor to regulating carbon dioxide by executive order?

In announcing the Environmental Protection Agency’s first regulations on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from cars, Administrator Lisa Jackson has promised they won’t be the last such rules stemming from the EPA’s “endangerment finding” that carbon dioxide, six pounds of which every human being exhales every day, is a dangerous pollutant.

“These are the first regulations that cover greenhouse gas emissions in the United States,” Jackson told reporters in a conference call last Thursday. She underscored the fact that additional regulations would be forthcoming since “the Clean Air Act talks about additional regulation needed once greenhouse gas pollution is acknowledged to be exactly that.”

Under the new regulations, which begin in 2011, automakers would be required to reduce fleetwide GHG emissions each year, beginning at 295 grams of carbon dioxide per mile and culminating in a cap of no more than 250 grams per mile by the 2016 model year.

James Inhofe, R-Okla., ranking member of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, said Jackson was “imposing a backdoor energy tax on consumers created by the EPA” despite the fact that Jackson admitted to him that the regulation “won’t have any meaningful climate impacts.”

“This is the initial step in EPA’s regulatory barrage stemming from the endangerment finding,” Inhofe said.

As Inhofe related in an earlier YouTube video: “Jackson admitted to me publicly that EPA based its action today (the endangerment finding) in good measure on the findings of the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, or IPCC. She told me that EPA accepted those findings without any serious, independent analysis to see whether they were true.”

The finding is an environmental sword of Damocles held over our heads – a warning that if cap-and-trade legislation such as Waxman-Markey or Kerry-Boxer is not signed into law, the full regulatory fury of an unelected bureaucracy will be unleashed on the American people and the U.S. economy.

Inhofe Human Events Op-Ed: President’s Offshore Drilling Proposal is All Fluff, No Substance

Republicans, don’t be fooled: the President’s proposal on offshore drilling will not mean more jobs, more energy, and less imported oil. If it’s accepted, it certainly will mean more dependence on foreign oil, more taxes, and fewer jobs.

The proposal is clearly designed to curry favor with Republicans, and even many Democrats, who remain staunchly opposed to his global warming cap-and-trade legislation. As Senators Kerry, Graham, and Lieberman attempt to craft a cap-and-trade “compromise,” President Obama seems convinced that a less than half-hearted energy plan will win him votes. But the President hasn’t offered anything that’s worth accepting the largest tax increase in American history.

As the Institute for Energy Research (IER) has noted, the President’s policy “is not a step forward, but a huge leap backward.” IER explained that, prior to Obama’s announcement, the vast majority of areas in the Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) “were open for business.” But that is no longer the case.

For one, the President paid lip service to increased energy development in the Eastern Gulf, but he must obtain congressional approval to open it. There’s no sign he will seek it. He also talked about development in the Southern Atlantic, but he only proposed to study it. Then he announced that he would delay development off Virginia’s coast, and, what’s more, his Administration will lock up large offshore resources in Alaska.

And don’t forget that President Obama’s FY 2011 budget imposes $36 billion in new taxes on the oil and gas industry. According to IER, this “will discourage domestic production, especially in areas like the Southern Atlantic that have little to no existing infrastructure.”

With all of this, plus empty rhetorical support from President Obama on nuclear power, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) hopes to win over Republicans to the cap-and-trade bill he’s writing with Senators Kerry and Lieberman. Yet there’s a raw deal shaping up: Republicans would get essentially nothing in the way of more domestic energy production in exchange for a massive energy tax that will harm consumers, destroy jobs and weaken our energy security.

NYT: Among Weathercasters, Doubt on Warming

The debate over global warming has created predictable adversaries, pitting environmentalists against industry and coal-state Democrats against coastal liberals.

But it has also created tensions between two groups that might be expected to agree on the issue: climate scientists and meteorologists, especially those who serve as television weather forecasters.

Climatologists, who study weather patterns over time, almost universally endorse the view that the earth is warming and that humans have contributed to climate change. There is less of a consensus among meteorologists, who predict short-term weather patterns.

Chu sees natural gas and small nuclear reactors as part of a low-carbon future

The natural gas industry needs to police itself to ensure that there’s no pollution from fracturing, or “fracking,” a technique that uses water and chemicals to push apart rocks and release gas, Energy Secretary Steven Chu said in a talk at Georgetown University on Monday.

“Fracking can be polluting if done irresponsibly,” Chu said. “We are going to have some regulation going on that. It can be done, but the industry has to demonstrate to the public that it can be done responsibly,” he said.

Though fracking can pollute the water table, natural gas is one in a portfolio of energy sources that will be necessary in the coming oil-constrained world, he said. Oil will become more expensive as resources are depleted and production moves to more unconventional and energy-intensive sources such as tar sands, oil shales and resources buried under the deep ocean.

“We need a new industrial revolution that decreases our depe

PREEMPTION TIME

Preemption: it’s the issue everyone’s talking about. We see this as a welcome development, as policymakers are now asking: what is preemption? And if preemption is part of climate legislation, what, exactly, are we preempting?

To our minds, preemption means preventing the hijacking of environmental statutes either to force Congress’s hand to adopt cap-and-trade legislation or to achieve backdoor greenhouse gas regulations. These are statutes, of course, that were never designed nor intended to reduce greenhouse gases. Comprehensive preemption must also address state climate programs as well greenhouse gas “nuisance” lawsuits that benefit the green tort bar at the expense of jobs and consumers.