Inhofe seconds Democrats’ call for look at ozone decision
Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov In the News… Greenwire Inhofe seconds Democrats’ call for look at ozone decision Jean Chemnick, E&E reporter Published: Wednesday, October 26, 2011 Link to article The top Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee today urged the panel’s Democratic leaders to make good on their promise to hold […]
Senate Sitting Out Solyndra Saga (National Journal)
But the Democratic-controlled Senate has not held a Solyndra hearing and has no plans to.
Some Republican senators, including Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky and Budget Committee ranking member Jeff Sessions of Alabama, have cited Solyndra when claiming that President Obama’s green-jobs agenda hurt the economy and wasted taxpayer money. But floor speeches do not carry the same weight as a Senate hearing.
Energy and Natural Resources Chairman Jeff Bingaman, D-N.M., seems less than enthusiastic about probing the company’s loan guarantee and the administration’s role in the saga.
Republicans challenge W.H. on science
Three key GOP lawmakers on Wednesday charged in a letter to the White House that the administration has manipulated science to develop economically harmful policies, including the Yucca Mountain shutdown and last year’s deepwater drilling moratorium.
Sens. David Vitter of Louisiana and Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma, along with Rep. Darrell Issa of California, asked John Holdren, the White House’s director of science and technology policy, for “an accounting of your activities in response to serious questions raised about the quality of science utilized by this administration,” the letter says.
In particular, the three are looking for a detailed assessment of how the administration dealt with several “major scientific issues that have had, and will continue to have, significant implications on our struggling economy.”
Inhofe tries to gather reinforcements for blockade of Commerce nominee
Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) is trying to rally members of his party to oppose the confirmation of President Obama’s pick for Commerce secretary, John Bryson.
Inhofe spoke out against the environmentalist and businessman yesterday at the weekly Senate GOP caucus luncheon. The lawmaker’s efforts come as the Senate prepares for a potential vote on the long-stalled nomination.
Obama named Bryson as his pick to lead the Commerce Department in May, but his confirmation was put on hold when senators declined to move any Commerce nominees until the Obama administration sent to Congress three free-trade agreements. The approval of those agreements last week opened the door for the Commerce nominees.
Senate leadership sent out a “hotline” on the nomination yesterday morning to see if they could approve Bryson without debate or objection. But multiple senators said they would block the nominee, according to Democratic and GOP aides. Inhofe has been the most vocal opponent of Bryson.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) told reporters yesterday that he had hoped to expedite Bryson’s nomination but would instead have to file cloture, which would set a timeline for debate before voting on the nominee. That also means Reid would have to gather at least 60 votes to advance the nomination.
The Daily Caller: Harry Reid to force Tuesday vote on Obama commerce secretary
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid is expected to pull a procedural move Tuesday afternoon to sneak President Obama’s Commerce Secretary nominee John Bryson through Senate confirmation, The Daily Caller has learned.
The highly unusual maneuver will permit Reid to bypass the permanent Senate floor “hold” placed on Bryson’s nomination by Oklahoma GOP Sen. James Inhofe – a step he took because he objects to Bryson’s connection with a solar energy firm that received a $1.6 billion loan guarantee from the federal government.
Reid’s chosen procedural maneuver, called a “time agreement,” circumvents the normal committee process by which presidential nominations are vetted. Should he succeed, Inhofe would no longer be able to stop Bryson’s confirmation.
If Reid is able to move forward procedurally, Bryson’s confirmation could reach the Senate floor on Tuesday afternoon. In that case, a simple 50-vote majority would confirm Bryson’s nomination – meaning Democrats could simply slip him through.
Inhofe calls for reopening carbon finding in light of IG report (E&E News)
One of the Senate’s top foes of U.S. EPA climate regulations said yesterday that a report last week by the agency’s inspector general was reason to reopen EPA’s finding that greenhouse gas emissions endanger public health.
The IG report did not cast doubt on the science EPA used to support the endangerment finding, but it did question EPA’s process for reviewing that science. EPA says it followed established procedure to the letter when preparing its finding.
The endangerment finding, finalized in 2009, forms the basis for all of EPA’s climate-related regulations, for both stationary sources and vehicles.
In his remarks yesterday on the Senate floor, Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) in particular questioned the agency’s use of data from the U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change to support the endangerment finding.
“EPA’s findings rest in large measure on the IPCC assessments, and EPA appears to have accepted them wholesale,” said Inhofe, who serves as top Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee.
Sen. Inhofe: Obama’s EPA Waging War on Fossil Fuels
Job creation has been all over President Obama’s lips in the past few weeks, but GOP opponents say his Environmental Protection Agency’s regulatory war on fossil fuels is costing the economy far more than the estimated $447 billion price tag of his jobs proposal.
“The President of the United States wants to destroy American energy,” said Oklahoma GOP Sen. James Inhofe, the ranking member of the Senate Energy and Public Works Committee. “His intention is to kill fossil fuels, which we rely on for 99% of the energy in America.
“All of this killing of our energy supply is not by accident. It’s on purpose.”
According to Inhofe, the administration’s proposed CO2/greenhouse gas-emission regulations-due out in November-could chop $300 billion to $400 billion alone off the nation’s gross domestic product (GDP) each year. Estimates from the Senate Energy and Public Works Committee’s Republican staff estimates this regulation could cost in excess of the 2 million jobs that would have been lost as a result of Waxman-Markey Climate Change Bill.
Other estimates suggest that the EPA’s Utility MACT and Transport Rule could cost $184 billion and 1.4 million jobs. Statistics Inhofe provided suggest the rule could shutter hundreds of coal-fired power plants around the country-equaling as much as 20% of the nation’s total energy output.
The Utility MACT rule would increase the technology requirements imposed on utility companies for removing pollutants such as mercury from the emissions from their coal-fired power plants. It could necessitate the retrofitting of as many as 600 scrubber units across the country, according to industry estimates.
Impact of EPA IG Report: EPA Cut Corners – Scolded on Review Process – Report with Wide Reaching Implications
AP: “Obama Administration Cut Corners”: The Obama administration cut corners when it produced a key scientific document underpinning its decision to regulate climate-changing pollution, an internal government watchdog said Wednesday.The inspector general’s report says the Environmental Protection Agency should have followed a more robust review process for a technical paper supporting its determination that greenhouse gases posed dangers to human health and welfare, a finding that ultimately compelled it to issue costly and controversial regulations to control greenhouse gases for the first time…The Obama administration has made a big deal about the importance of peer review. Six weeks after taking office in 2009, Obama issued a memo that said: “When scientific or technological information is considered in policy decisions, the information should be subject to well-established scientific processes, including peer review where appropriate, and each agency should appropriately and accurately reflect that information in complying with and applying relevant statutory standards.” A year later, the president’s science adviser, John Holdren, emphasized the “particular importance” of outside review by scientists.
DOWJONES: EPA Criticized Over Greenhouse-Gas Findings: WASHINGTON-Internal investigators at the Environmental Protection Agency said the agency failed to follow peer-review guidelines when developing a key scientific document that underpins its greenhouse-gas regulations. The findings are likely to stoke Republican opposition to the EPA’s efforts to regulate greenhouse gases and could arm industry groups that are fighting the regulations in court. One prominent Republican is already calling for congressional hearings on the issue. The document in question was developed by the EPA and used to support its 2009 “endangerment finding.” That finding concluded that greenhouse gases-including carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide-pose a threat to public health. It paved the way for the EPA to begin developing greenhouse-gas standards for refiners, power plants and other large emitters. In a report released Wednesday, the EPA’s inspector general said the agency didn’t follow federal guidelines for peer review when developing a 200-page scientific document to support its findings.
REUTERS: “EPA Took a Shortcut”: The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency took a shortcut in laying the groundwork to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, a government watchdog said on Wednesday in a report that could fuel Republican efforts to block the agency’s new rules on climate.
WASHINGTON TIMES: “didn’t treat the finding as seriously as the situation required”: The Environmental Protection Agency’s internal watchdog said Wednesday the Obama administration cut corners in evaluating the science it used to back up its finding that carbon is a dangerous pollutant that can be regulated under existing federal law. The report by the EPA’s inspector general is certain to be used in court by those seeking to overturn EPA’s claim that it can write global-warming rules under existing law and doesn’t need new authority from Congress. Investigators did not evaluate the scientific conclusions. The report said EPA did follow basic rules but didn’t treat the finding as seriously as the situation required, and failed to meet administration guidelines for peer review of such a major issue.
WASHINGTON POST: “EPA should have conducted a more detailed scientific review”: The Environmental Protection Agency should have conducted a more detailed scientific review before determining two years ago that greenhouse-gas emissions pose a threat to public health and welfare, according to a report issued Wednesday by the agency’s Office of Inspector General. “This review did not meet all [Office of Management and Budget] requirements for peer review of a highly influential scientific assessment primarily because the review results and EPA’s response were not publicly reported, and because 1 of the 12 reviewers was an EPA employee,” the study said… Beyond the court case, House oversight committee Chairman Darrell Issa (R-Calif.) indicated that he might hold hearings. “This report raises serious questions that our committee and staff will further review,” he said in a statement.
LA TIMES: EPA scolded on greenhouse gas report review process: The EPA is quibbling with its own inspector general, based on a bureaucratic but important distinction. Scientific documents that are considered “highly influential” have to meet review requirements set by the White House’s Office of Management and Budget. The inspector general said the document in question was “highly influential,” while the EPA hierarchy disagrees. The inspector general said the EPA’s technical support document had a high influence on the agency’s eventual decision because the agency “weighed the strength of available science by its choices of information, data, studies and conclusions included in and excluded from” the technical support document.
NATIONAL JOURNAL: Report “does give fresh ammunition to vocal EPA critics.” An Environmental Protection Agency inspector general report released Wednesday faults the agency for not properly reviewing technical data that underpins its authority to control greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate change. The 99-page report found no fault with the EPA’s data, but it criticized EPA’s method of assessing the so-called “endangerment finding” — in particular, for relying on existing peer-viewed studies rather than conducting a fresh scientific review when issuing the finding. EPA’s review of data from the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change also did not meet the White House Office of Management and Budget’s own requirements “because the review results and EPA’s response were not publicly reported, and because 1 of the 12 reviewers was an EPA employee,” the IG report said. While the report is not expected to stop EPA’s rollout of the climate change rules, it does give fresh ammunition to vocal EPA critics. Senate Environment and Public Works ranking member James Inhofe, R-Okla., who made the report public on Wednesday, said it raises questions about the EPA’s veracity, an explosive charge as environmental regulations have become a central issue in the presidential campaign.
THE HILL: EPA IG – “document should have undergone a “more rigorous” peer review.” Inspector General Arthur A. Elkins Jr. said in a statement Wednesday that the technical support document should have undergone a “more rigorous” peer review. The report also finds that EPA should improve its procedures for vetting outside scientific data. The IG’s opinion disputes both the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and EPA. Calling it a “highly influential scientific assessment” under OMB’s peer-review guidelines, Elkins said EPA’s review didn’t meet the standards for such a consequential document.
GREENWIRE: “Report with Wide-Reaching Implications”: In a report with wide-reaching political implications, U.S. EPA’s inspector general has found that the scientific assessment backing U.S. EPA’s finding that greenhouse gases are dangerous did not go through sufficient peer review for a document of its importance. The new report, released today, examines only federal requirements for EPA’s “technical support document” and not the accuracy of the scientific studies included within it. But its conclusions have nevertheless reinvigorated GOP criticism of EPA’s endangerment finding, which enabled the agency to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act. “This report confirms that the endangerment finding, the very foundation of President Obama’s job-destroying regulatory agenda, was rushed, biased, and flawed,” Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) said in a statement. “It calls the scientific integrity of EPA’s decision-making process into question and undermines the credibility of the endangerment finding.”
Politico: IG raps EPA for procedural issues with endangerment finding: EPA and Office of Management and Budget staff said they did not designate the data as highly influential “because it only summarized existing findings and conclusions and provided no new findings or conclusions.” The IG came to a different conclusion. “In our opinion, the TSD [technical support document] was a highly influential scientific assessment because EPA weighed the strength of the available science by its choices of information, data, studies and conclusions included in and excluded from the TSD,” the report says. (Highly influential assessments are defined by the OMB as having a potential impact of more than $500 million in one year or being “novel, controversial or precedent-setting.”) In its initial response in the IG’s report, the EPA defended its actions, arguing that “the TSD does not meet the OMB definition of a scientific assessment in that no weighing of information, data and studies occurred in the TSD.” Instead, the agency says, the TSD was merely a compilation of previous research used as background material. The report also found that the EPA violated OMB policy when a panel of 12 federal climate scientists who reviewed the document included one who worked at the EPA. The IG recommends establishing minimum requirements for evaluating data from outside organizations; altering the EPA’s peer review guidelines to accurately reflect OMB requirements; and specifying whether future rules are backed by highly influential assessments or merely influential assessments.
DAILY CALLER: “Inhofe Lambasted the EPA for its failure”: Inhofe lambasted the EPA for its failure to adhere to its own rules, outsourcing the science to the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – and refusing to conduct its own analysis of the science – in the period leading up to its final endangerment finding. “The endangerment finding is no small matter: Global warming regulations imposed by the Obama-EPA under the Clean Air Act will cost American consumers $300 to $400 billion a year, significantly raise energy prices, and destroy hundreds of thousands of jobs. This is not to mention the ‘absurd result’ that EPA will need to hire 230,000 additional employees and spend an additional $21 billion to implement its [green house gas] regime. And all of this economic pain is for nothing: As EPA Administrator [Lisa] Jackson also admitted before the Environmental and Public Works] committee, these regulations will have no affect on the climate.”
Note to Liberal Media: It is True – Even EPA Says So
Is the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) “asking for taxpayers to shoulder the burden of up to 230,000 new bureaucrats – at a cost of $21 billion – to attempt to implement the rules”?
In a strangely timed late night article, Politico, building off a blog post by the liberal site Media Matters, called out The Daily Caller and others who Media Matters doesn’t like, for including that line in a story about the far reaching implications of the Obama-EPA’s global warming regulations.
Politico writes:
“The hated Environmental Protection Agency is looking to spend $21 billion per year to hire an additional 230,000 people to enforce greenhouse gas regulations. One problem: It’s not true. Patient zero for this story is The Daily Caller, which on Monday wrote that the EPA is ‘asking for taxpayers to shoulder the burden of up to 230,000 new bureaucrats – at a cost of $21 billion – to attempt to implement the rules.’
Our take: It’s actually worse – EPA never asked the American taxpayers. EPA is already well on its way to imposing these regulations and the financial burdens that come with them. Never mind the fact that Congress has repeatedly rejected this cap-and-trade approach over the past decade.
All sides agree that the debate boils down to something called the tailoring rule. While EPA moves forward imposing its greenhouse gas regime, which the Agency readily admits will be even more devastating to our economy than cap-and-trade, it claims that these regulations will only hit the largest sources, because smaller sources, such as farms, churches, schools, hospitals and small businesses, would be exempt through the tailoring rule-but this is not the case.
Inside EPA: Republicans Reiterate Call For EPA To Suspend Key Chemical Studies
Top Republicans on the Senate environment committee are reiterating their recent call to EPA’s research chief Paul Anastas to suspend all Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS) chemical assessments “where serious concerns have been raised,” following Anastas’ recent assertion to Inside EPA that the IRIS program has not been halted.