Floor Statement of U.S. Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa on S.3036, the Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Bill

Mr. President. On April 24th of this year, the Senate Finance Committee held a hearing on tax aspects of a cap and trade program. The Director of the Congressional Budget Office, Peter Orszag, testified about the economic impact of a cap and trade system. Robert Greenstein of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities testified on the impact of a cap and trade system on low-income families. I would like to share some relevant information with my colleagues who may not have had an opportunity to review the testimony from the hearing. Mr. Greenstein, who is often pointed to by members on the other side regarding economic issues, expressed support for policies to address climate change, but pointed out that, “Significant increases in the prices of energy and energy-related products will necessarily occur as a result of the enactment of effective policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.”

Statement of Senator Enzi on the Lieberman Warner Bill

Mr. President, I have an important message for everyone listening to me right now. This bill will cost you money! It will make your gasoline more expensive. It will increase your electric bills – dramatically. It will take hard earned money out of your pockets. Companies don’t pay the cost of higher energy – they pass it to you, the customer. You need to think about what you want to pay for your gas and electricity in 2013 when this bill has its full effect on you.

Boxer Climate Tax – ‘Cap-and-Destroy’ – ‘Unprecedented Control’ By Gov’t – Round Up

The American Spectator: Cap and Destroy – June 3, 2008
Excerpt: Yesterday the U.S. Senate began what it insists on calling “debate” (more like serial dopey speeches designed for home consumption) on the worst piece of legislation introduced into that body in the new century. Perhaps worse than anything in the last century as well. There’s nothing good to be said about the disingenuously named Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act of 2008. A better name would be the Let’s Destroy the Economy by Turning it Over to Left-Geek Bureaucrats in 2008 Act. The heart of Lieberman-Warner is a cap and trade system that would turn decisions on how much and what kind of energy to use in the private sector over to government. This is the approach, you’ll recall, that worked so well in the Soviet Union that that dismal country’s first five-year plan lasted 74 years before the whole sorry business caved-in on its own command and control butt. If adopted, this would be the most fundamental change in the nature of this country in the country’s history. […] THE REASON A CAP and trade system is such a horrible idea, other than the fact that it would turn America’s dynamic and complex economy over to the kind of folks who directed the Katrina relief effort, is that it sets very low levels of use of fossil fuels, the only relatively inexpensive, reliable, and available energy we have in large amounts. The boutique sources of energy like wind, solar, and biomass, the ones that excite environmentalists, just aren’t available in more than trifling amounts. And aren’t likely to be for years. Restricting the use of fossil fuels for energy would drive the price of everything — not just gasoline or power to light homes, everything — up dramatically. We’ve already seen increases in the price of food thanks to our insane policy of trying to grow our fuel through ethanol and other bio-fuels. If we’re daft enough to cap our use of fossil fuels, as environmentalists and their political enablers want us to, we’ll first see increased prices, then severe shortages, and finally unavailability of everything else as well. Choking off the use of carbon-based fuels could and would make an utter dog’s breakfast of the American economy, which has been the most powerful engine of wealth the world has ever seen. […] WE’VE REACHED the “Do something even if it’s wrong” phase. The Senate is seriously considering (seriously as these things are measured in Washington) creating a Department of Not Using Energy and saddling a dynamic and remarkably clean economy with it.

Oklahoma Farm Bureau: Farmers Concerned about Climate Change Bill

Oklahoma agricultural producers are concerned proposed climate change legislation now being debated in the U.S. Senate could increase their cost of production. The Climate Security Act, authored by Senators Joe Lieberman, D-CT, and John Warner, R-VA, would impose significant increases in production costs through higher fertilizer and energy prices. “We believe this legislation unfairly penalizes farmers by forcing them to comply with climate change regulations and makes it more difficult for them to compete in the global market,” said Mike Spradling, president of the Oklahoma Farm Bureau.

Senator DeMint’s Blog: Lieberman-Warner Unlikely to Reduce Global Temperatures, Cap & Trade Scheme INCREASING Emissions in Europe

Following up on yesterday’s release on how Lieberman-Warner will destroy jobs and hike gasoline prices, please see this post from Senator DeMint’s blog . Supporters of the $7 Trillion Lieberman-Warner Climate Tax (S. 2191 / S.3036) assure us the bill is necessary to combat global warming, even though the bill would kill 3-4 million American jobs and double gasoline & home energy prices. However, according to numerous experts, the Lieberman-Warner Climate Tax bill would not measurably reduce global temperatures: Dr. Anne E. Smith, CRA International: “It is worth asking however, the question of how much change in global greenhouse gas emissions would be achieved by S.2191, relative to the growth expected from sources other than the United States… None of these scenarios [under Lieberman-Warner] are sufficient to prevent global emissions from continuing to increase through 2050, due to the unchecked growth of emissions from developing countries, principally China and India.”

Senator Voinovich Speaks out on Climate Change

Today, I rise to address the legislative proposal introduced by Senators Lieberman and Mr. Warner to address global climate change. Like many of my colleagues, I share the desire to take proactive steps to address this important global environmental challenge. That said, I have serious reservations about this proposal: I feel that is both overly aggressive – vastly outpacing what technology can provide and thus ensuring enormous economic pain on the country; and, it is overly bureaucratic and cumbersome in its implementation – representing an unprecedented expansion of government power and a massive bureaucratic intrusion into Americans lives that will have a profound impact on businesses, communities and families. EPA has stated this program will take between 350 and 400 people to implement.

Senator Cornyn Statement on Climate Change and Energy Prices

Mr. President, I heard the distinguished Majority Leader criticize the Republicans for wanting to have a debate on this piece of legislation. Frankly, we would be remiss in our duties if we didn’t discuss this important piece of legislation. as complex and difficult a topic as it is, and frankly, ask questions that I know our constituents would ask of us were we to vote for or against this particular piece of legislation. So I, for one, would make no apologies for doing what I consider to be my duty, and I think all of us would do well to ask questions about this legislation which proposes a $6.7 trillion price tag. That’s trillion, not billion, not million; but trillion. $6.7 trillion dollars.

Senator Sessions discusses the Lieberman-Warner Bill

Mr. President, I don’t think, with all due respect to my good friend, the majority leader, who decided to bring up this bill, that discussing one of the most massive bills we have seen is a waste of time. I don’t think 30 hours is too long. The Wall Street Journal, which he dismisses–I don’t dismiss it–said: This is easily the largest income redistribution scheme since the income tax. That was today’s Wall Street Journal editorial. I wish to say, this is not a matter that should be lightly dealt with. Thirty hours is not enough. We need to spend a lot of time talking about what the provisions are in this legislation, what we can do, as the majority leader says–and I agree, there are a lot of things we can do and we can do now–but what we ought not to.

Inhofe: “We Don’t Need a Climate Tax on the Poor” – Wall Street Journal

With average gas prices across the country approaching $4 a gallon, it may be hard to believe, but the U.S. Senate is considering legislation this week that will further drive up the cost at the pump. The Senate is debating a global warming bill that will create the largest expansion of the federal government since FDR’s New Deal, complete with a brand new, unelected bureaucracy. The Lieberman-Warner bill (America’s Climate Security Act) represents the largest tax increase in U.S. history and the biggest pork bill ever contemplated with trillions of dollars in giveaways. Well-heeled lobbyists are already plotting how to divide up the federal largesse. The handouts offered by the sponsors of this bill come straight from the pockets of families and workers in the form of lost jobs, higher gas, power and heating bills, and more expensive consumer goods.

Boxer Claims Recession is Best Time to Raise Energy Costs

Senator Barbara Boxer (D-CA), the chairman of the Environment & Public Works Committee, declared in her opening floor speech today that a “recession is the precise time to” enact the Lieberman-Warner global warming cap-and-trade bill because it “brings us hope.”

The Lieberman-Warner global warming bill would have many consequences, but “hope” is not among them. The Cleveland Plain Dealer editorialized on June 1, that the bill “will just bore new holes into an already battered economy.”