The Oklahoman: Senate Climate Bill Would Place U.S. on Wrong Path
SINCE spring, Washington’s political oddsmakers have figured climate change legislation had two chances in the U.S. Senate: slim and none. While a similar bill got through the House of Representatives, consensus was that legislation built on carbon emissions caps, effectively creating a national energy tax, would stall in the Senate.
MultimediaPhotoview all photos Still, when liberal Democratic Sens. Barbara Boxer of California and John Kerry of Massachusetts launched their global warming bill three weeks ago, they got the endorsement of conservative Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina – reportedly lured to the bill by provisions calling for new nuclear power plant construction. Might cap and trade rally in the Senate?
Let’s hope not. As Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Tulsa, noted recently, Boxer-Kerry is still a bad idea at its core. Tacking on a few nuclear power provisions, which are needed, “doesn’t cancel out or eliminate a national energy tax,” Inhofe said.
Indeed, Boxer-Kerry would dramatically change life in America – as would the House-passed bill – if it became law.
The bill’s chief feature would mandate a 20 percent reduction in U.S. greenhouse gas emissions by 2020. Kerry said the bill is a “pollution reduction bill,” resisting the cap-and-trade label that refers to the government setting limits on emissions of carbon dioxide. Generally, businesses and industries that are under the caps can sell or trade their excess to those that are over the caps.
* * MEDIA ADVISORY * * Senators Hutchison & Bond to Join a Family Farmer & Trucker to Release Report
Media Contacts: Charles Chamberlayne (BOND) 202.224.7627 Courtney Sanders (HUTCHISON) 202.224.5520 * * MEDIA ADVISORY * * CAP & TRADE = $3.6 TRILLION GAS TAX FOR AMERICAN FAMILIES AND SMALL BUSINESSES Senators Hutchison & Bond to Join a Family Farmer & Trucker to Release Report WASHINGTON, D.C. – On WEDNESDAY, October 21, 2009 […]
Does Nuclear Fit The Bill? – Inhofe Response
The talk of the Beltway climate change debate these days is nuclear power. Suddenly a potential compromise has emerged to couple cap-and-trade legislation with provisions to advance construction of new nuclear power plants. But is it real, or just another mirage concocted by the industry’s fiercest opponents? As of now, one can only speculate. But if last year’s debate on Lieberman-Warner is any guide, one should expect little of anything that matters for nuclear. During the debate, former Sen. John Warner (R-Va.) said, “We’re going to have a nuclear provision, I can assure you of that.” Democratic opposition assured that the final bill was nuclear-free.
Such opposition, of course, is unsurprising. Consider that some of the same senators who now talk of nuclear compromise have plainly identified themselves as staunchly anti-nuclear. During the debate on the McCain-Lieberman bill in 2005, for example, Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) said, “Nuclear power is not the solution to climate change, and it is not ‘clean.'”
But let’s assume that the industry’s opponents have a “road-to-Damascus” conversion, and agree to support provisions that can encourage construction of new nuclear power plants, including, to name a few, further streamlining the regulatory process, support for reprocessing, and loan guarantees for new plants. These are steps that Congress can and should take. But we can’t forget the essential point: attaching them to a national energy tax doesn’t cancel out or eliminate a national energy tax.
Inhofe: Climate Bill Is a Costly Non-Solution (Roll Call Op-Ed)
No matter how many times Congress debates it, and no matter how environmentalists couch it, cap-and-trade will do virtually nothing to stop global warming, and cap-and-trade, as Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.) said, “is a tax, and a great big one.” These are the fundamentals in the cap-and-trade debate, and Republicans must refocus on them.
We need to remind the American public, for example, that the 1,400-page Waxman-Markey monstrosity is a monument to big government that will make food, gasoline and electricity more expensive, increase mandates on small businesses, and increase the size and reach of the federal bureaucracy – all while doing nothing to affect climate change.
THE TAILOR’S EMPTY SUIT
Buried in the 416-page preamble of its greenhouse gas “tailoring” rule, EPA makes plain that the owner of the local Dunkin Donuts should be very concerned. While EPA proposes to exempt such a facility from draconian greenhouse gas permitting obligations under the Clean Air Act, it also notes that this GHG exemption does not apply at the state level. Furthermore, the exemption is only temporary; EPA says that after studying the issue for 5 years, it could very well devise a regulatory scheme that covers greenhouse gas emissions from pizza parlors, nursing homes, and apartment buildings.
Of course NRDC says not to worry-EPA only wants to “focus on the big stuff.” That is true, for now. In the tailoring preamble, EPA is clear that it will get your local pizza parlor eventually. “In addition,” EPA wrote, “EPA commits to propose and promulgate a rulemaking-informed by the study-within 6 years from the effective date of a final version of this rulemaking (i.e., 1 year from the completion of the study) that would establish the second phase, which would either reaffirm the GHG permitting thresholds, promulgate alternative thresholds, adopt other streamlining techniques, and/or take other action consistent with the goal of expeditiously meeting CAA requirements in light of the administrative burden that remains at that time.”
As the for the next five years, EPA explains that requirements for sources that emit less than 25,000 tons of greenhouse gases annually-farms and schools, for example-will not be “federally enforceable.” In other words, EPA will let facilities emit more than the 100 or 250 tons of per year of GHGs (limits that are clearly delineated in the Clean Air Act and which EPA is clearly traducing with the tailoring rule).
Crowds Pack Mining Hearings – Voices Ring out – Let us Work!
Thousands showed up Tuesday night to public hearings held by the Army Corps of Engineers in Pikeville, Kentucky; Charleston, West Virginia; and Knoxville, Tennessee to demonstrate their support for their jobs and energy security. Last night kicked off a series of six Corps hearings on the proposed suspension of the Nationwide Permit 21 (NWP 21) in the six state Appalachian region. Tomorrow, Thursday, October 15, the Corps will hold the remaining three hearings in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; Cambridge, Ohio; and Big Stone Gap, Virginia. The NWP 21 permit allows for environmentally responsible coal production while minimizing unnecessary bureaucratic delays. Maintaining the NWP 21 is essential to keeping thousands of high-paying jobs in the Appalachian region.
Congressional Budget Chief Says Climate Bill Would Cost Jobs
The head of the Congressional Budget Office on Wednesday countered Obama administration claims that a landmark climate bill would be a boost to the economy.
President Barack Obama and Senate Democrats championing the bill have said mandating greenhouse-gas caps, renewable energy and efficiency standards would be a boon to an ailing economy, creating new low-carbon industries. Millions of so-called green jobs would be created under the cap-and-trade legislation being considered in the Senate, Democrats say.
CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf warned a Senate energy panel that there would be “significant shifts” from emissions-intense sectors such as oil and refining firms to low-carbon businesses such as wind and solar power.
“The net effect of that we think would likely be some decline in employment during the transition because labor markets don’t move that fluidly,” Mr. Elmendorf said, testifying before the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee.
“The fact that jobs turn up somewhere else for some people does not mean there aren’t substantial costs borne by people, communities, firms and affected industries,” he said.
Saunders: The global warming consensus cools
“What happened to global warming?” read the headline – on BBC News on Oct. 9, no less. Consider it a cataclysmic event: Mainstream news organizations have begun reporting on scientific research that suggests that global warming may not be caused by man and may not be as dire and imminent as alarmists suggest.
Indeed, as the BBC’s climate correspondent Paul Hudson reported, the warmest year recorded globally “was not in 2008 or 2007, but 1998.” It’s true, he continued, “For the last 11 years, we have not observed any increase in global temperatures.”
At a London conference later this month, Hudson reported, solar scientist Piers Corbyn will present evidence that solar-charged particles have a big impact on global temperatures.
Western Washington University geologist Don J. Easterbrook presented research last year that suggests that the Pacific decadal oscillation (PDO) caused warmer temperatures in the 1980s and 1990s. With Pacific sea surface temperatures cooling, Easterbrook expects 30 years of global cooling.
EPA analyst Alan Carlin – an MIT-trained economist with a degree in physics – referred to “solar variability” and Easterbrook’s work in a document that warned that politics had prompted the Environmental Protection Agency and countries to pay “too little attention to the science of global warming” as partisans ignored the lack of global warming over the past 10 years. At first the EPA buried the paper, then it permitted Carlin to post it on his personal Web site.
Wall Street Journal: Apple, Nike and the U.S. Chamber
The recent corporate resignations from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce have played in the media as a case of enlightened corporate stewardship vs. blinkered old businesses. But there’s far more to this story-not least the way that Apple and Nike are putting green political correctness above the long-term interests of their own shareholders.
The Chamber needs “a more progressive stance on this issue” of climate change, declared Apple Vice President Catherine Novelli in a letter of resignation from the business lobby on October 5. Added Nike, announcing its resignation on September 30 from the Chamber board though retaining its membership: “US businesses must advocate for aggressive climate change.” Both decisions were ostentatiously leaked to the media.
The first point to understand is the role of Al Gore, who is a member of the Apple board and perhaps the leading supporter of President Obama’s cap-and-tax anticarbon legislation. Mr. Gore has also invested in renewable energy technologies that could make him even richer than he already is if new climate rules make renewables more competitive with carbon energy.
FACT SHEET: Appalachian Coal Mining: Enhancing Our Nation’s Energy Security
Link to FACT SHEET on Appalachian Coal Mining Related Files COAL_Factsheet