THE HOCKEY STICK REVISITED

“The story behind the hockey stick provides a cautionary tale about the need to recognize the limited function of journal peer review and the dangers of proceeding with major policy decisions without applying a further level of due diligence equivalent to an audit or an engineering study.” Ross McKitrick, “Shattered Consensus: The True State of Global Warming”

Who is Michael Mann? In the rarified world of paleoclimatology, he’s a big deal. And now he’s at the center of Climategate.

Mann is an international climate superstar. He was a “Lead Author” of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s Third Assessment Report (TAR), and was selected by Scientific American as one of 50 leading “visionaries” in science and technology. That vision helped produce the infamous “hockey stick” graph, which showed relatively stable temperatures going back to 1000 AD (the shaft), and then a sharp increase beginning in 1900 (the blade). For some, the conclusion was crystal clear: anthropogenic emissions were causing global warming. The graph, and Mann himself, received international acclaim, and it was featured prominently in the TAR. Governments throughout the world relied on Mann’s temperature reconstructions to formulate policy.

The Dallas Morning News: Point Person: Q&A with Sen. James Inhofe

One of the most formidable opponents of the idea that climate change is driven by human activity is U.S. Sen. James Inhofe. When we reached him by phone last week, the Oklahoma Republican was in an “I told you so” mood over the recent revelation that top climate scientists had been twisting scientific data to fit their ideology. Last week, he called for Senate hearings on the scandal.

Did the Climategate e-mail scandal give you a sense of vindication?

Vindication and redemption. If you’d read that speech I gave on the [Senate] floor in ’05, it was essentially the same thing that’s coming out of these hijacked e-mails. Where I got it was from frustrated scientists who had come to me – and I’m talking about top scientists in America – saying they had consulted with the IPCC [Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change] or served on the IPCC, and their views were ignored and intentionally not made a part of these recommendations.

It’s important that we understand that the IPCC – which is part of the United Nations – when they come up with something, the press gets it from these summaries for policymakers. These are not scientists; these are politicians putting these assessments together. So when these scientists came to me and said they were frustrated because things they knew that weren’t true were coming out, I gave that speech.

Welcome Bloggers!

Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov Welcome Bloggers! Included below are links to several of the items Senator Inhofe covered today. If you have any questions, feel free to email Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov Keep Up To Date On Climategate/Inhofe Copenhagen"Truth Sqad" Inhofe Press Office on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/jiminhofepressoffice/ Inhofe Press Office on Twitter: www.twitter.com/inhofepress Inhofe EPW Press […]

The Hill: Inhofe: ‘We won,’ cap and trade is ‘dead’

Climate change skeptics have won the battle against cap and trade legislation, Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.) declared today.

Debating Rep. Ed Markey (D-Mass.), House co-sponsor of climate legislation, on CNN’s Situation Room, Inhofe argued the Climate Gate emails show that global warming science is false.

“Your bill is dead,” Inhofe told Markey. “The Boxer bill is dead,” he added, referring to the Senate version of the legislation.

Inhofe and other climate change skeptics say the so-called “ClimateGate” emails prove that scientists at a major research institution in Great Britain attempted to suppress evidence against global warming.

Proponents of man-made global warming claim the emails show only a few cases of unethical behavior and do not undermine the scientific consensus about climate change.

CBS Evening News: Climate Gate Casts Cloud on UN Copenhagen Global Warming Meetings

(CBS) Hundreds of world leaders and climate change experts are descending on Copenhagen to try to come up with a new pact to slow global warming.

At the same time, thousands of protestors across Europe Saturday were sending them a message: time to stop talking and make a deal.

Reaching that deal has now been complicated by what’s being called “Climate Gate,” a string of hacked private e-mails between global climate change scientists in the U.S. and Europe, casting doubts on the very science of which this summit is based, reports CBS News Correspondent Kimberly Dozier.

The e-mails show some of the world’s top experts decided to exclude or manipulate some research that didn’t help prove global warming exists.

1998 was the hottest year since record-keeping began…but the temperature went down the next year, and it’s only spiked a couple times since.

An e-mail exchange in 1999 shows scientists worked hard to demonstrate an upward trend. They talk of using a “trick” to “hide the decline” in global temperatures.

It worked like this: when temperature readings extrapolated from tree rings showed what looked like a decline in temperatures from the 1980s to the present, the scientists added in measurements taken later by more modern instruments, which gave them the answer they wanted.

The scientists say the e-mails are being misinterpreted.

“A lot of charges have been made that I think are quiet unjustified, cherry-picking information and taking it our of context and misrepresenting what it is actually saying,” Kevin Trenberth of National Center for Atmospheric Research told Dozier.

Oklahoma Republican Sen. James Inhofe – a climate change skeptic – says the e-mails prove the global warming threat is exaggerated. He wants a congressional investigation.

“We are relying upon that science for a bunch of stuff that we would be doing that would lose a lot of jobs and really affect Americans,” Inhofe told Dozier. “I do believe an investigation would show that they clearly have manipulated the data.”

The official U.S. position hasn’t changed: that climate change is real and needs to be addressed.

VIDEO: Inhofe: It’s ‘Dishonest’ for Obama to Attend Global Warming Summit and Say America Will Cap Carbon Emissions

CNSNews.com – Sen. Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma, ranking Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, says it is “dishonest” for President Barack Obama to attend the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen next week to announce that the United States will cap its carbon emissions because legislation to do so has no chance of passing in Congress.

The White House announced on November 26 that Obama will personally attend the climate summit on December 9 and announce there that the U.S. intends by the year 2020 to reduce its carbon dioxide emissions to 17 percent below what they were in 2005. This 17% reduction mirrors the reduction that would be mandated in the United States if the cap-and-trade bill that passed the House by a 219-212 vote on June 26 were enacted into law.

Financial Times: Backlash by sceptics begins to gain ground

The resurgent climate change sceptic movement claimed its first political scalp this week when Australia’s opposition Liberal party dumped its leader, Malcolm Turnbull, over his support for the federal government’s legislation to reduce carbon emissions.

Tony Abbott, the new opposition leader, has said the argument for climate change is “crap” and he is unconvinced by the science. This week he ruled out the two main methods that have been proposed for reducing carbon emissions: a trading scheme and a carbon tax.

However, global public opinion polls continue to show that most people around the world regard climate change as a serious man-made problem and favour action against it. Scepticism is strongest – and growing fastest – in the US, though even here a majority of voters believes carbon dioxide is causing global warming.

Financial Times: Global warming a ‘hoax’

Jim Inhofe has one mission for the Copenhagen climate change summit: to be a self-declared “one-man truth squad”.

“I want to make sure that people from around the world understand that there is no way that the United States is going to ratify any kind of treaty that is anything at all like Kyoto,” the cowboy-boot-wearing senator from Oklahoma told the Financial Times.

“And there is no way in the world that the Kerry-Boxer Bill on the floor of the Senate will even come up for a vote. It’s dead, gone,” said Mr Inhofe, referring to the climate change bill that is now languishing in the upper chamber.

President Barack Obama has conceded that the Copenhagen summit is not going to result in a binding international treaty. But when he travels to the Danish capital next week he will state that the US is working towards reducing its carbon emissions by 17 per cent from 2005 levels by 2020. To counteract the president’s message, Mr Inhofe, ranking Republican on the Senate’s environment and public works committee, plans to attend too.

CLIMATEGATE: WHO, WHAT, WHEN, WHERE

“There is one feature I notice that is generally missing in cargo cult science…It’s a kind of scientific integrity, a principle of scientific thought that corresponds to a kind of utter honesty–a kind of leaning over backwards. For example, if you’re doing an experiment, you should report everything that you think might make it invalid–not only what you think is right about it: other causes that could possibly explain your results; and things you thought of that you’ve eliminated by some other experiment, and how they worked…Details that could throw doubt on your interpretation must be given, if you know them. You must do the best you can–if you know anything at all wrong, or possibly wrong–to explain it. If you make a theory, for example, and advertise it, or put it out, then you must also put down all the facts that disagree with it, as well as those that agree with it.” –Richard Feynman, Nobel laureate physicist

Roger Pielke Jr.: Your Politics are Showing

In early 2005, almost five years ago, I began criticizing the scientists at RealClimate, including Gavin Schmidt and Michael Mann, for hiding a political agenda in the cloth of science. In The Honest Broker I call this behavior “stealth issue advocacy” and it is among the most insidious and certain ways for science to become pathologically politicized . To be clear, I have no problem with scientists being open advocates, with NASA’s Jim Hansen as perhaps the most visible example — through such advocacy is how democracies work. But when scientists claim to be representing the scientific establishment while at the same time are pursuing a political agenda, it hurts the credibility and trust given to scientists.

At the time I wrote:

. . . opponents to action on climate change have already taken a big step toward winning the political debate when advocates of action take the bait on uncertainty. By raising uncertainty as a red herring advocates for action spend considerable time and effort trying to disprove allegations of uncertainty as the centerpiece of their efforts, but no matter how this sideshow winds up, it will do little to change the underlying political outcome, as the opponents can just switch their justification to something else while maintaining their political commitment to opposition. This is an exceedingly difficult line of argument for environmentalists and scientists to accept because the former have hitched their agenda to science and the latter’s claims to authority lie in science.