EPA is pushing back against GOP calls to halt all work on its power plant greenhouse gas rule in light of the Supreme Court stay, arguing that the court’s order is “ambiguous” on the issue of whether all of the rule’s deadlines must be delayed if the rule survives legal challenge and that the issue will not be settled until that occurs.
“The ultimate effect of the stay on [Clean Power Plan (CPP)] deadlines will be determined when the stay is lifted,” acting EPA air chief Janet McCabe says in an April 18 letter to Senate environment committee Chairman James Inhofe (R-OK) that was obtained by InsideEPA/climate April 29.
The letter is a response to Inhofe’s March 10 letter arguing that the high court’s stay order includes “inherent” requirements to postpone, or toll, all of the deadlines in the rule to account for the litigation.
As evidence, Inhofe had argued that a stay application from electric co-ops asked the high court to “extend all compliance dates by the number of days between publication of the Rule and a final decision in this consolidated appeal.”
But McCabe in her recent letter — which echoes her earlier comments that it is “premature” to speculate whether the rule’s deadlines would be delayed — says that “different applicants requested different relief.”
“The government interpreted the stay applicants’ opening briefs as requesting that all CPP deadlines be tolled, and it opposed the stay in part on the grounds that such relief would be extraordinary and unprecedented,” she writes. “In their reply brief, however, the States clarified that they were only seeking a stay that would relieve States of the obligation to comply with CPP deadlines during the litigation and that the stay would not necessarily provide for day-to-day tolling of the deadlines.”
She adds that the high court’s Feb. 9 orders “did not discuss the parties’ differing views of whether and how the stay would affect the CPP’s compliance deadlines, and they did not expressly resolve the issue.”
The Department of Justice, on EPA’s behalf, said in a Feb. 4 brief to the high court that stay applicants “appear to seek much more than interim relief that would ‘temporarily divest [the Rule] of enforceability’ while review is ongoing. . . . Rather, they explicitly or implicitly ask this Court to toll all of the relevant deadlines set forth in the Rule, even those that would come due many years after the resolution of their challenge, for the period between the Rule’s publication and the final disposition of their lawsuits.”
But a coalition of states opposing the rule, led by West Virginia, said in a Feb. 5 reply brief that “contrary to EPA’s assertion . . . the States’ requested relief is a straightforward [Administrative Procedure Act] stay, which ‘halt[s] or postpone[s] [the Power Plan, [including] by temporarily divesting [the Power Plan] of enforceability.’”
The states added: “In the unlikely event the Plan survives judicial review, . . . tolling would be appropriate as a matter of basic fairness. But the exact shape of such an equitable disposition need not be decided today.”
The states cited a 1999 U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit decision in Michigan v. EPA that accepted post-decision briefing on a similar issue for an air regulation and then tolled the deadline for states to submit compliance plans after the stayed rule was upheld.
Deadline Advocacy
The deadline issue has been the subject of advocacy from both supporters and opponents of the rule, also known as the existing source performance standards (ESPS).
For example, a recent report from the Institute for Policy Integrity (IPI) at New York University largely agrees with EPA’s view, arguing the D.C. Circuit likely would settle the issue if the rule is upheld.
Further, the IPI report says that the D.C. Circuit in that scenario should avoid delaying the rule’s compliance deadlines because greater deployment of renewable power over the coming years could ease compliance.
“It is likely that compliance with the Clean Power Plan will be achievable on a shorter timeframe than originally envisioned,” the report says, arguing that recently extended tax credits for wind and solar power will deploy much more zero-emission resources than EPA projected when it finalized the rule in August 2015.
IPI’s report serves as a rebuttal to a March 2 white paper from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce that sought to build a legal case for why the high court stay requires a delay for all ESPS state plan submission and compliance deadlines.
Similarly, an April 8 post from the law firm Jones Day charges that EPA is “creating a confusing situation for those charged with implementing the Clean Power Plan.” It argues the agency must confirm that the stay means “compliance deadlines must therefore be postponed” to offer clarity to industry and states.
Associated Rules
In her recent letter, McCabe also confirms that the agency will continue work on associated rules — including an early action incentive program and model trading rules — because some states have “asked us to move forward with our outreach and to continue providing support and developing tools” to aid implementation.
“We will move forward developing these actions in a way that is consistent with the stay while providing states the tools they have asked for to help address carbon pollution from power plants,” she writes.
McCabe adds that EPA “has in the past moved forward with preparing for the potential implementation of a rule while it has been stayed, in anticipation of the possibility that the stay could be lifted. Such actions are unaffected by a stay.” To support the point, she cites a 2009 Supreme Court ruling in Nken v. Holder, which concerned how to consider a stay request of a deportation order.
EPA’s position is further confirmed by its April 26 move to send a proposed update to its Clean Energy Incentive Program to the White House for inter-agency review. — Lee Logan (llogan@iwpnews.com)
http://insideepaclimate.com/daily-news/epa-says-high-court-ambiguous-possible-delay-esps-deadlines