While Juneau is working on its economic development plan, the federal government is back at adopting costly and burdensome new regulations at the expense of sustainable growth. By redefining the “waters of the United States,” the federal government is vastly expanding its authority over Alaska.
The Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers are proposing a rule that will greatly expand the federal Clean Water Act and federal overreach in Alaska. Under the Clean Water Act, those agencies have authority to protect navigable waters of the United States. The new rule would classify lands as waters of the United States because, if at any point in the year any water overflows that land, it can be regulated as if it were water. This rule would bring seasonal streams, ponds, ditches, depressions in fields, and large puddles under these agencies’ Clean Water Act jurisdiction.
For small businesses or subdivision developers, the change in jurisdiction could prevent the use of property or at the very least add tremendously expensive permitting processes to the use of property. The new federal control could mean owners would not be allowed to alter land formations, which prevents landowners from digging or excavation on their property, or even laying gravel.
In Juneau, the new definition will affect nearly every potential new housing site. It is doubtful there are any developable housing sites in Juneau that don’t have depressions that overflow during the year. Thus our attempt to increase available housing in Juneau can expect another federal roadblock, just as the state and the borough are reviewing and removing their unnecessary roadblocks.
The Juneau Economic Development Plan calls for the development of West Douglas to provide areas for business and housing growth. The proposed new federal rules pose a huge roadblock to that development. In addition to the many other existing challenges, we will be burdened with decisions created in Washington, D.C., with their “one-size-fits-all” attitude impact on our growing state and community.
It is possible to get permits, but the cost is high and prohibitive to many small businesses that are attempting to subdivide and build new homes. A recent U.S. Supreme Court case cited the average cost of a permit to be $270,000. Violating the regulations is punishable by fines up to $37,500 per day — a substantial risk for any business, especially a small one.
The cost of regulation is more devastating to small businesses than to the larger businesses. A recent study by the American Action Forum shows that for every 10 percent increase in regulatory costs in an industry, the number of small and medium-size businesses falls 3 to 6 percent. The number of large businesses, meanwhile, grows 2 to 3 percent. Thus this proposal by the EPA is also highly regressive.
The federal Small Business Administration’s Office of Advocacy called on the EPA to withdraw the rule. It pointed out that the agency failed to perform an economic analysis as required by the law. EPA brushed aside that recommendation, arguing that there won’t be any new costs because the new rule merely expands an existing regulation, again showing the federal appetite to expand its overreach with callousness.
Congress is attempting to reel in the EPA with legislation, S 1140, cosponsored by Alaska Sen. Dan Sullivan and HR 1732, the Regulatory Integrity Protection Act of 2015. It would provide relief by sending the EPA and Corps of Engineers back to the drawing board on its problematic Waters of the United States new rule.
Let us not forget that Alaska has a Department of Environmental Conservation and local planning and development ordinances. These work well to balance the need to protect our environment and our need to grow our economy. For the long term, Juneau needs to provide more available housing and a broader range of jobs if our community is to prosper.
• Neil MacKinnon is a member of the First Things First Alaska Foundation, which is dedicated to preserving the economic viability and future of Alaska by recognizing the benefits of responsible economic development and natural resource management.