The Obama administration continues to use federal regulatory agencies to impose policy where it cannot succeed legislatively. Now comes the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers in an attempt to basically declare any mud puddle in the U.S. as “navigable waters” and therefore under the jurisdiction and regulation of the Clean Water Act (CWA).
All of this “reg-speak” is really about an unprecedented effort by the EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to expand federal authority over private property via their Waters of the United States rule. The proposed rule will greatly expand federal Clean Water Act jurisdiction over small businesses and private land owners.
The proposed regulation provides that any “natural, man-altered, or man-made water body” with an ordinary high water mark will be considered a tributary. This requires the agencies (EPA and Army Engineers) to assert jurisdiction over practically any land over which water occasionally flows. This then requires permission from the agencies to do just about anything with the land in question.
Getting permission from the EPA to develop your land is a wealthy person’s game. Indeed, the Supreme Court noted, in Rapanos v. United States, that the average Clean Water Act permit costs more than $270,000. Of course, you could just ignore the EPA and take your chances. What could go wrong when the fines are up to $37,500 per day? By the way, the fine for making an unintentional mistake and not getting the EPA’s blessing for using your own property is also $37,500 per day. For all of the talk from the Obama administration about “equality and fairness” it sure is ironic that the well-heeled will be the only ones allowed to develop private property if this rule is adopted.
Now the EPA will assert that the public is in favor of this federal land grab and they have the comments and letters to prove it. In fact, according to a recent story in the New York Times, Gina McCarthy, the agency’s administrator, told a Senate committee in March that the agency had received more than one million comments, and nearly 90 percent favored the agency’s proposal. Unfortunately, the same article goes on to expose the EPA’s brazen manipulation of the rule comment process to manufacture such a result.
Speaking of Congress, on May 12, the House passed H.R. 1732, the Regulatory Integrity Protection Act of 2015, sponsored by Rep. Bill Shuster (R-PA) and Rep. Collin Peterson (D-MN). This legislation would provide relief for private property owners and small businesses by sending the EPA and the Army Corps back to the drawing board on its problematic Waters of the United States rule. H.R. 1732 passed the House by a vote of 261 to 155, with 24 Democrats crossing party lines. The bill now awaits action by the Senate.