A coalition of 14 state attorneys general announced its plan today to sue the Bush Administration over its “failure” to regulate emissions of carbon dioxide from the nation’s power plants. These legal solons charged that “the administration’s current policy regarding CO2 emissions violates the federal Clean Air Act…”
FACT: Curiously, the state AGs are suing EPA for…abiding by the law. During consideration of the 1990 Clean Air Act amendments, Congress specifically rejected proposals to authorize EPA to regulate emissions of carbon dioxide. That means EPA has no authority to do so. As the Supreme Court has said: “[f]ew principles of statutory construction are more compelling than the proposition that Congress does not intend sub silentio to enact statutory language that it has earlier discarded.”